PHILIPPINE AIRLINES, INC., PETITIONER, VS. AIRLINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION OF THE PHILIPPINES, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Philippine Airlines versus Airline Pilots Association of the Philippines
The Case
This is a labor case between Philippine Airlines, the employer, and the Airline Pilots Association of the Philippines, the exclusive bargaining representative of the airline's commercial pilots. The dispute began when the company unilaterally retired a pilot, Captain Albino Collantes, under the retirement plan negotiated with the union. The union cried illegal dismissal and union busting and called a strike, and the Secretary of Labor assumed jurisdiction over the dispute. The case matters because it fixes the relationship between a negotiated retirement plan and the retirement law, and because it marks the limits of the Secretary's power to rewrite a collective bargaining agreement.
Procedural History
The union filed a notice of strike with the Department of Labor and Employment. Pursuant to Article 263 (g) of the Labor Code, the Secretary of Labor assumed jurisdiction over the labor dispute. On June 13, 1998, the Secretary issued an order recognizing the retirement as a valid exercise of the company's option under the retirement plan, but directing that the benefits be computed under Article 287 of the Labor Code, and adding that the company must first consult the pilot concerned before implementing his retirement. The company's motion for reconsideration was denied on June 1, 1991. The company then went up to the Court of Appeals on a petition for certiorari with a prayer for injunction and a temporary restraining order. The Court of Appeals denied the petition on March 2, 2000, and denied the motion for reconsideration on June 19, 2000. The company then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari.
Facts
Philippine Airlines and the pilots' association had a long-standing relationship governed by a collective bargaining agreement. Article XXVII of that agreement incorporated the 1967 retirement plan. Under the plan, a pilot becomes eligible for normal retirement upon completing twenty years of service as a pilot or upon logging twenty thousand hours. A pilot who remains in service after his normal retirement date may retire either at his own option or at the option of the company.
The company exercised that option and unilaterally retired Captain Albino Collantes under the late retirement provision. The union took the position that the retirement amounted to illegal dismissal and union busting, and it filed a notice of strike. The Secretary of Labor assumed jurisdiction over the dispute.
In his order, the Secretary upheld the retirement as a valid exercise of the company's option, but held that the computation of benefits should follow Article 287 of the Labor Code rather than the retirement plan, and imposed the added requirement that the company consult the pilot before implementing his retirement. The company challenged that order all the way to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not the amount of retirement pay under the retirement plan should be increased by applying Article 287 of the Labor Code.
- Whether or not the Secretary of Labor, in imposing that computation, adjudicated a matter outside the issues raised and thereby denied the company due process.
- Whether or not the Secretary of Labor may amend the collective bargaining agreement and the retirement plan without violating the constitutional proscription against impairment of contracts.
- Whether or not the company must consult the pilot concerned before exercising its option to retire him.
Applicable Provisions
Article 287 of the Labor Code, as amended by Republic Act Number 7641, provides:
Article 287. Retirement. Any employee may be retired upon reaching the retirement age established in the collective bargaining agreement or other applicable employment contract. In case of retirement, the employee shall be entitled to receive such retirement benefits as he may have earned under existing laws and any collective bargaining agreement and other agreements: provided, however, That an employee's retirement benefits under any collective bargaining and other agreements shall not be less than those provided herein. In the absence of a retirement plan or agreement plan providing for retirement benefits of employees in the establishment, an employee upon reaching the age of sixty years or more, but not beyond sixty-five years which is hereby declared as the compulsory retirement age, who has served at least five years in the said establishment, may retire and shall be entitled to retirement pay equivalent to at least one-half month salary for every year of service, a fraction of at least six months being considered as one whole year. Unless the parties provide for broader inclusions, the term one-half month salary shall mean fifteen days plus one-twelfth of the 13th month pay and the cash equivalent of not more than five days of service incentive leaves.
This provision is the measure the Secretary applied, and the Court had to test whether the negotiated plan falls below its floor.
Section 2, Article VII of the 1967 retirement plan provides:
Section 2. Late Retirement. Any member who remains in the service of the Company after his normal retirement date may retire either at his option or at the option of the Company and when so retired he shall be entitled either (a) to a lump sum payment of 5,000 pesos for each completed year of service rendered as a pilot, or (b) to such termination pay benefits to which he may be entitled under existing laws, whichever is the greater amount.
This is the contractual option the company exercised, and the Court upheld it as the correct basis of the award.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the benefits under the retirement plan are not less than those under Article 287, and so the plan, not the Labor Code, governs the computation. The Court reasoned that the pilots' situation is peculiar: a pilot who retires after twenty years or twenty thousand hours is still in the prime of his life and at the peak of his career, unlike one who retires at sixty. The Labor Code provision, the Court said, was intended for those with no more plans of employment after retirement, who are in need of financial assistance. The Court also noted that the pilots receive, in addition to the plan benefits, an equity in the pilots' retirement benefit fund, contributed exclusively by the company at twenty percent of each pilot's gross monthly pay, so that a pilot receives an amount equivalent to two hundred forty percent of his gross monthly income for every year of service. In short, the benefits under the plan are greater than those under Article 287.
On the due process point, the Court held that when the Secretary imposed the added requirement of consultation, he resolved a question outside the issues raised, depriving the company of an opportunity to be heard.
On the contract point, the Court held that the Secretary cannot amend the agreement by adding terms the parties never agreed to.
On the consultation issue, the Court held that the added requirement in effect amended the plan. The option of an employer to retire its employees is recognized as valid, and the requirement to consult the pilots defeats the exercise of that option and gives the pilot an undue prerogative to assail management's decision. Due process requires only that notice be given to the pilot of the decision to retire him. The Court quoted its earlier ruling in Bulletin Publishing Corporation versus Sanchez:
The aforestated sections explicitly declare, in no uncertain terms, that retirement of an employee may be done upon initiative and option of the management. And where there are cases of voluntary retirement, the same is effective only upon the approval of management.
Doctrine
A retirement plan negotiated in a collective bargaining agreement governs the computation of retirement benefits where those benefits are not less than those required by Article 287 of the Labor Code. The statutory floor applies; the parties may provide more, and the greater benefit prevails. The employer's option to retire an employee under the agreed plan is a valid management prerogative, and due process requires only notice to the employee of the decision to retire him, not consultation or consent. The Secretary of Labor, in assuming jurisdiction over a labor dispute, may not amend the collective bargaining agreement by imposing terms the parties did not agree to, and may not adjudicate matters outside the issues raised, for that would deny the employer due process.
Disposition
The petition was granted. The Court reversed and set aside the decision and resolution of the Court of Appeals, modified the order of the Secretary of Labor so that the retirement benefits of Captain Collantes are based on the 1967 retirement plan and the pilots' retirement benefit plan, deleted the directive requiring consultation before retirement, and affirmed the order in all other respects.
Remember This
Memorize this line: a negotiated retirement plan prevails over Article 287 of the Labor Code whenever its benefits are not less than the statutory minimum, and the employer's option to retire needs notice, not consultation. Examiners use this case to test the retirement floor under Article 287, the management prerogative to retire, and the limits of the Secretary of Labor's jurisdiction over a collective bargaining agreement.