ACTIVE REALTY & DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, PETITIONER, VS. NECITA G. DAROYA, REPRESENTED BY ATTORNEY-IN-FACT SHIRLEY DAROYA-QUINONES, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Active Realty versus Daroya
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Active Realty and Development Corporation, the owner and developer of a subdivision in Antipolo, Rizal, against Necita Daroya, a contract worker in the Middle East who bought a lot from it on installment. The respondent sued for specific performance and damages before the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board, asking that the developer be compelled to execute a final deed of absolute sale after she paid the balance of the price. The case matters because the Supreme Court uses it to enforce the twin mandatory requirements for cancelling a contract to sell under the Maceda Law, and to remind developers that form will not be allowed to defeat the substantial rights of a lot buyer.
Procedural History
The respondent filed her complaint for specific performance and damages before the Arbitration Branch of the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board. The HLURB Arbiter ruled in her favor, holding the cancellation void because no cash surrender value was paid, and ordered a full refund of her payments with interest and attorney's fees. On appeal, the HLURB Board of Commissioners set aside that decision and, refusing to apply the Maceda Law, fashioned an equitable solution ordering a refund of one half of her total payments. The respondent appealed to the Office of the President, which modified the Board and held that the contract to sell subsisted, but since the lot had been sold to another buyer, ordered the developer to refund the actual value of the lot with interest, or to deliver a substitute lot at the respondent's option. The developer went up to the Court of Appeals, which denied due course to its petition for insufficiency of form and substance, and later denied reconsideration on a new ground of untimely filing. The developer then filed this petition for review on certiorari before the Supreme Court.
Facts
On January 2, 1985, Active Realty entered into a contract to sell with Necita Daroya over a 515 square meter lot for 224,025 pesos. She was to pay an initial amount of 53,766 pesos upon execution and the balance of 170,259 pesos in sixty monthly installments of 4,893.35 pesos. On May 5, 1989, the developer accepted her amortization of 40,000 pesos. By August 8, 1989, she was in default of 15,282.85 pesos, representing three monthly amortizations, and the developer sent her a notice of cancellation to take effect thirty days from receipt. The records do not show when she received it.
When the respondent offered to pay the balance of the contract price, the developer refused, saying it had already sold the lot to another buyer. She then sued, claiming she had already paid 314,816.76 pesos, which was 90,835.76 pesos more than the contract price, and that she was entitled to a final deed of sale upon paying the balance of 24,048.47 pesos.
The records showed that the developer never sent a notarized notice of cancellation and never refunded the cash surrender value. It offered to pay the cash surrender value only during the preliminary hearing before the HLURB arbiter, and it never attempted to pay through her last known address, even though it had been sending her written notices there to remind her of her arrears.
Issues
- Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in denying due course to the petition for review on purely formal grounds, thereby denying the petitioner its right to due process.
- Whether or not the petitioner can be compelled to refund to the respondent the value of the lot, or to deliver a substitute lot at her option.
Applicable Provisions
Section 3 of Republic Act Number 6552, the Realty Installment Buyer Protection Act or Maceda Law, provides:
(a) To pay, without additional interest, the unpaid installments due within the total grace period earned by him, which is hereby fixed at the rate of one month grace period for every one year of installment payments made; x x x
This grants the buyer who has paid at least two years of installments the right to cure the default within the earned grace period, without additional interest.
The same Section 3 provides:
(b) If the contract is cancelled, the seller shall refund to the buyer the cash surrender value of the payments on the property equivalent to fifty per cent of the total payments made; provided, that the actual cancellation of the contract shall take place after thirty days from receipt by the buyer of the notice of cancellation or the demand for rescission of the contract by a notarial act and upon full payment of the cash surrender value to the buyer.
This lays down the twin mandatory requirements for a valid cancellation: a notarized notice of cancellation, and full payment of the cash surrender value to the buyer.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled for the petitioner. It found that the petitioner substantially complied with the formal requirements of Rule 43. The original registry receipts accompanied the petition and counsel for the respondent actually received a copy, so the absence of an affidavit of service was not fatal. The petition was accompanied by the appealed decision and resolution, the decision of the HLURB Board, and that of the arbiter, which contained all the relevant facts, and the failure to attach other documents was due to the refusal of the Office of the President to issue certified true copies. The lack of a board resolution was cured by a Secretary's Certificate ratifying the authority of counsel. And the motion for reconsideration was in fact filed a day before the expiration of the extended period. The Court stressed that the appellate court gave premium to form and failed to consider the important rights of the parties.
On the second issue, the Court ruled in the affirmative. The contract to sell is governed by the Maceda Law, whose declared policy is to protect buyers of real estate on installment against onerous and oppressive conditions. The respondent had paid four years of installments, more than the contract price itself. Yet the petitioner failed to comply with the mandatory twin requirements for a valid cancellation: it sent no notarized notice of cancellation and never refunded the cash surrender value. For that failure, the contract to sell remained valid and subsisting, and under Section 3(a) the respondent had the right to offer to pay the balance without interest, which she did.
Ordinarily the petitioner would have had no recourse but to accept payment. But since the lot had already been sold to another buyer, valued at 1,700 pesos per square meter, the Court held it just and equitable that the petitioner refund the actual value of the lot, 875,000 pesos, with twelve percent interest per annum from August 26, 1991 until fully paid, or deliver a substitute lot at the respondent's option. The Court also rejected the Board's one half refund as punishing the buyer while ignoring the seller's failure, and rejected the arbiter's full refund because the respondent was entitled to the lot itself after paying her balance.
Doctrine
A contract to sell real estate on installment is governed by the Maceda Law, and its cancellation is valid only upon compliance with the twin mandatory requirements of Section 3(b): a notarized notice of cancellation or demand for rescission by notarial act, and full payment of the cash surrender value equivalent to fifty percent of the total payments made. Absent such compliance, the contract remains valid and subsisting, and the buyer who has paid at least two years of installments may pay the unpaid installments without additional interest within the grace period of one month for every year of payments made. Where the seller has resold the lot and can no longer deliver it, the seller must refund the actual value of the lot with legal interest, or deliver a substitute lot at the buyer's option. Procedural rules on appeal are liberally construed in favor of substantial compliance where a strict application would defeat the substantial rights of the parties.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed in toto the decision of the Office of the President, ordering the petitioner to refund 875,000 pesos with twelve percent interest per annum from August 26, 1991 until fully paid, or to deliver a substitute lot at the respondent's option, with costs against the petitioner.
Remember This
Memorize the twin requirements: no notarized notice of cancellation and no cash surrender value means no valid cancellation, and the contract to sell subsists. Examiners use this case to test the Maceda Law's protection of installment buyers and the rule that substantial compliance with procedural rules prevails over strict form.