EMILIO C. VILLAROSA, PETITIONER, VS. HON. DEMOSTHENES L. MAGALLANES, AND JUDE THADDEUS SAYSON, TOTE GARGALICANO, RAMON ABLANQUE, PETE IBRADO, JOSE RUIZ, HECTOR BAJA AND CYPRESS …
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Villarosa versus Magallanes
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari filed by Emilio Villarosa against Judge Demosthenes Magallanes and several private respondents who had been his rivals in a barangay election. Villarosa had caused the filing of perjury charges against the private respondents before the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Bacolod, based on allegedly false statements in their sworn counter-affidavits submitted in an election offense proceeding. Judge Magallanes, sitting in the Regional Trial Court, quashed the informations on the ground that jurisdiction lay with the courts of Manila, where the counter-affidavits were forwarded to the Commission on Elections for preliminary investigation. The case matters because it fixes the venue of perjury committed through a false affidavit: the offense is tried where the false evidence was submitted and became material, not where the affidavit was later transmitted.
Procedural History
After preliminary investigation, the Regional State Prosecutor filed eight informations for perjury against the private respondents before the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Bacolod. The private respondents moved to quash on the ground that exclusive jurisdiction lay with the proper court in Manila, since the counter-affidavits had been forwarded to the Law Department of the Commission on Elections in Manila. The Municipal Trial Court in Cities denied the motion to quash, and later denied the motion for reconsideration.
The private respondents then filed a petition for certiorari before Branch 54 of the Regional Trial Court of Bacolod City, presided over by Judge Demosthenes Magallanes. The Regional Trial Court granted the petition, nullified the orders of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities, and quashed the informations without prejudice on the ground of lack of jurisdiction, holding that jurisdiction belonged to the Manila court. The motion for reconsideration was denied. Villarosa then elevated the matter to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari, ascribing grave abuse of discretion to the respondent judge.
Facts
In the barangay elections of May 12, 1997, Emilio Villarosa and Jude Thaddeus Sayson were candidates for barangay captain, and Sayson won. Several others won as barangay councilors. Earlier, on May 7, 1997, one Victoria Delfin filed a verified complaint with the Office of the Election Officer in Bacolod City against the private respondents for violation of the Omnibus Election Code, alleging that they had posted campaign streamers before the start of the campaign period.
The private respondents filed counter-affidavits denying the complaint. These counter-affidavits were forwarded to the Law Department of the Commission on Elections in Manila for preliminary investigation, and that office found probable cause. The counter-affidavits then became the basis for Villarosa to file a complaint for perjury against the private respondents with the Office of the City Prosecutor of Bacolod City, on the theory that their sworn denial of having posted streamers on April 30, 1997 was false.
After preliminary investigation, eight informations for perjury were filed before the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Bacolod. Each information alleged that the accused willfully and feloniously made untruthful statements upon a material matter in a counter-affidavit submitted before the Commission on Elections, duly subscribed and sworn to before an assistant city prosecutor, falsely alleging that he had not personally posted his campaign streamers on April 30, 1997 nor authorized anyone to do so. The private respondents moved to quash, and the case wound its way to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Bacolod has jurisdiction over the perjury cases, the counter-affidavits having been executed and originally submitted in Bacolod.
- Whether or not the transmission of the counter-affidavits to the Law Department of the Commission on Elections in Manila for preliminary investigation makes the offense triable in the Manila courts.
Applicable Provisions
Article 183 of the Revised Penal Code, as quoted in the decision, defines the offense charged:
Article 183. False testimony in other cases and perjury in solemn affirmation. The penalty of arresto mayor in its maximum period to prision correccional in its minimum period shall be imposed upon any person who, knowingly make untruthful statements and not being included in the provisions of the next preceding articles, shall testify under oath, or make an affidavit, upon any material matter before a competent person authorized to administer an oath in cases in which the law so requires.
This is the crime the informations charged, and its element of a false statement upon a material matter before a competent officer anchors the Court's ruling on where the offense was committed.
Section 15, Rule 110 of the Rules on Criminal Procedure, as quoted in the decision, governs venue:
Section 15. Place where action is to be instituted. (a) Subject to existing laws, the criminal action shall be instituted and tried in the court of the municipality or territory where the offense was committed or where any of its essential ingredients occurred.
This is the fundamental principle the Court applies: the perjury case belongs where the offense or any of its essential ingredients took place.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled that jurisdiction is vested in the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Bacolod. The disputed affidavit containing the alleged false statements was filed by the private respondents with the Office of the Election Officer in Bacolod City, where the complaint for violation of the Omnibus Election Code was lodged. It was in that proceeding that the alleged untruthful statements became material in deciding whether the private respondents violated the election law. As the Court put it, it was in Bacolod where the criminal intent to assert a falsehood under oath became manifest.
On the second issue, the Court held that the transmission of the untruthful affidavit to the Law Department of the Commission on Elections in Manila for preliminary investigation did not make the offense triable in the Manila courts. The Court agreed with the Solicitor General that it was in the Office of the Election Officer in Bacolod City where the counter-affidavits were executed and originally submitted, and hence it was there that the operative acts constituting perjury, if proven, were committed.
The Court distinguished the old case of United States versus Cañet, on which the private respondents relied. In that case the issue was whether the perjury case should be filed in Manila, where the affidavit was subscribed and sworn to, or in Iloilo, where the affidavit was filed in a pending judicial proceeding. Here, the threshold issue was whether the case should be filed in Bacolod, where the election offense proceeding was pending and the counter-affidavits were submitted, or in Manila, where they were forwarded for preliminary investigation. The Court stressed that the lis mota, the core of the offense of perjury, is the deliberate or intentional giving of false evidence in the court where such evidence is material. The purpose of the rule is to avert the prevalence of a corrupt assertion of falsehood under oath, which is an imposition upon the court and exposes it to a miscarriage of justice.
Finally, the Court warned that to hold that the Manila court has jurisdiction would open the floodgates to judicial anarchy. It would congest the dockets of the Manila courts and impose physical and financial burdens on litigants nationwide who must travel from remote areas to pursue justice in Manila, inevitably discouraging the prosecution of offenses of this nature.
Doctrine
In perjury committed through a false affidavit, venue lies in the court of the place where the affidavit was executed and originally submitted and where the false statements became material, not where the affidavit was later transmitted for preliminary investigation. The lis mota, the core of the offense, is the deliberate or intentional giving of false evidence in the proceeding where such evidence is material. This rule rests on Section 15, Rule 110 of the Rules on Criminal Procedure, which requires that the criminal action be instituted and tried where the offense was committed or where any of its essential ingredients occurred, applied to the crime defined in Article 183 of the Revised Penal Code.
Disposition
The petition was granted; the resolution and order of the Regional Trial Court were set aside, and the orders of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Bacolod denying the motion to quash were reinstated, without costs.
Remember This
Memorize this line: the core of perjury is not the swearing but the intentional giving of false evidence where it is material, so the case is filed where the false affidavit was submitted, not where it was forwarded. Examiners use this case to test venue in perjury and the application of Section 15, Rule 110 where an affidavit travels from one office to another.