RIDO MONTECILLO, PETITIONER,VS. IGNACIA REYNES AND SPOUSES REDEMPTOR AND ELISA ABUCAY, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Montecillo versus Reynes
The Case
This is the case of Montecillo versus Reynes, a petition for review on certiorari decided by the Supreme Court in July 2002. Rido Montecillo, the buyer in a deed of sale over a parcel of land in Mabolo, Cebu City, assails the decision of the Court of Appeals affirming the trial court's judgment that declared his deed of sale null and void. The private respondents are Ignacia Reynes, the vendor, and the spouses Redemptor and Elisa Abucay, who had earlier bought a portion of the same lot and built their house on it. The case matters because it draws the sharp line every civil law student must be able to draw: the difference between failure to pay the consideration, which is a mere breach of an existing valid contract, and lack of consideration, which prevents a valid contract from ever existing. It also teaches that the manner of payment of the price is part of the price itself, so that a disagreement on it is a failure to agree on the price.
Procedural History
On June 20, 1984, Reynes and the Abucay spouses filed before the Regional Trial Court of Cebu City, Branch 18, a complaint for declaration of nullity and quieting of title against Montecillo. After trial, the court rendered judgment on March 24, 1993, declaring the deed of sale in favor of Montecillo null and void, ordering the cancellation of his certificate of title and the issuance of a new one in the names of the Abucay spouses, and awarding moral damages and attorney's fees. Montecillo appealed to the Court of Appeals, which affirmed the trial court's decision in full on July 16, 1998, and denied his motion for reconsideration on February 11, 1999. Montecillo then came to the Supreme Court through a petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45.
Facts
Ignacia Reynes owned a lot in Mabolo, Cebu City, containing 448 square meters and covered by Transfer Certificate of Title No. 74196. In 1981, she sold 185 square meters of it to the Abucay spouses, who built a residential house on the portion they bought. On March 1, 1984, Reynes, who was illiterate and signed only by affixing her thumb-mark, executed a deed of sale over the lot in favor of Montecillo for a purchase price of 47,000 pesos. The deed recited that the price was paid to her in hand, but the agreement was that Montecillo would pay within one month from signing. He never paid her a single centavo.
When the period lapsed, Reynes demanded the return of the deed. Montecillo refused, so she executed a document unilaterally revoking the sale and furnished him a copy. On May 23, 1984, she sold the entire lot to the Abucay spouses for 50,000 pesos, confirming their earlier purchase of the 185 square meter portion. The respondents later learned that a new certificate of title, No. 90805, had been issued in Montecillo's name.
In his defense, Montecillo claimed he was a buyer in good faith who had paid the price, though he admitted a balance of 10,000 pesos. He said the real consideration was the amount he paid to Cebu Ice and Cold Storage Corporation to release a chattel mortgage on a house built on the lot, a mortgage that belonged to Bienvenido Jayag. The trial court found that Reynes was never a party to that mortgage obligation, and that the payment to release Jayag's house was a matter between Montecillo and Jayag.
Issues
- Whether or not there was an agreement between Reynes and Montecillo that the 47,000 peso consideration stated in the deed of sale would be paid to Cebu Ice and Cold Storage to secure the release of the certificate of title.
- Whether or not, absent such an agreement, the deed of sale is void from the beginning or merely rescissible.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1240 of the Civil Code provides:
Payment shall be made to the person in whose favor the obligation has been constituted, or his successor in interest, or any person authorized to receive it.
This governs the first issue, because Montecillo paid a stranger to the sale, not the vendor or anyone authorized by her.
Article 1318 of the Civil Code provides:
There is no contract unless the following requisites concur: (1) Consent of the contracting parties; (2) Object certain which is the subject matter of the contract; (3) Cause of the obligation which is established.
This is the yardstick for the second issue, since a deed of sale without cause lacks an essential requisite.
Article 1352 of the Civil Code provides:
Contracts without cause produce no effect whatsoever.
This supplies the consequence: not rescission of a valid contract, but total nullity.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petition is devoid of merit. The deed of sale does not state that the price should be paid to Cebu Ice and Cold Storage, and Montecillo presented no evidence that Reynes agreed, verbally or in writing, to such payment. Under Article 1240, payment to be effective must be made to the vendor or her authorized representative. Payment to a third person is valid only insofar as it redounds to the creditor's benefit, and here Reynes had nothing to do with Jayag's mortgage debt and benefited nothing from the payment. The Court also stressed that in a petition for review under Rule 45, only questions of law may be raised, and the factual findings of the trial court, affirmed by the Court of Appeals, are binding.
On the second issue, the Court rejected Montecillo's argument that this was a mere breach of the obligation to pay, remediable by rescission under Article 1191. The deed recited that the price was paid in hand on the date of signing, yet the evidence showed Montecillo never paid Reynes anything. The Court ruled that failure to pay the consideration is different from lack of consideration: the former gives a right to demand fulfillment or cancellation of an existing valid contract, while the latter prevents the existence of a valid contract. Where the deed states that the price has been paid but in fact it never was, the deed is null and void from the beginning for lack of consideration, a rule settled as early as 1920.
The Court went further. Even granting Montecillo's version, there was no meeting of the minds on the manner of payment: Reynes expected direct payment to her within one month, while Montecillo thought he was to pay Cebu Ice and Cold Storage. Citing its ruling that the manner of payment of the price is an essential element of a valid sale, the Court held that an agreement on the price but a disagreement on the manner of its payment prevents consent. Thus the deed was void from the beginning not only for lack of consideration but also for lack of consent.
Doctrine
First, payment of the price must be made to the vendor, her successor in interest, or a person authorized to receive it; payment to a third person binds the creditor only insofar as it redounded to her benefit.
Second, and this is the line to memorize: failure to pay the consideration is not the same as lack of consideration. Failure to pay presupposes a valid contract and gives rise to rescission or specific performance under Article 1191. Lack of consideration means no contract ever arose, because cause is an essential requisite under Article 1318, and a contract without cause produces no effect whatsoever under Article 1352. Where a deed of sale recites that the price was paid but in truth it never was, the sale is null and void from the beginning.
Third, the parties must agree not only on the price but also on the manner of its payment; a disagreement on the manner of payment is a failure to agree on the price, and therefore a lack of consent.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the petition, affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeals, and ordered Montecillo to pay the costs; the Abucay spouses prevailed as the rightful vendees of the lot.
Remember This
Memorize the line: failure to pay the consideration is breach, but lack of consideration means no contract at all, so a deed reciting a price never actually paid is void from the beginning. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between void and rescissible contracts, and to test whether you know that the manner of payment is part of the price.