BLADE INTERNATIONAL MARKETING CORPORATION, EVAN J. BORBON, EDGAR J. BORBON, AND MARCIAL GERONIMO, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND METROPOLITAN BANK & TRUST COMPANY, RESPON…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Blade International Marketing versus Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company
The Case
This is a petition to annul the decision of the Court of Appeals in a suit for a sum of money. Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company sued Blade International Marketing Corporation and its individual officers, Evan J. Borbon, Edgar J. Borbon, and Marcial Geronimo, to collect on obligations arising from commercial letters of credit and trust receipts. The bank applied for a writ of preliminary attachment. The case matters because it fixes a simple but examinable rule: an officer who signs a letter of credit or related document, binding himself personally and solidarily, cannot later escape liability by saying he signed a blank form or that he acted only for the corporation.
Procedural History
The bank filed a complaint for a sum of money with an application for a writ of preliminary attachment before the trial court. The individual defendants answered, denying personal liability and asserting that the trust receipts were simulated contracts. After due hearing, the trial court rendered judgment dismissing both the complaint and the counterclaim, without pronouncement as to costs. The bank appealed to the Court of Appeals, which reversed and set aside the trial court decision and entered a new one holding the defendants liable jointly and severally. The petitioners moved for reconsideration, and the Court of Appeals denied the motion for lack of merit. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court by petition, which the Court gave due course.
Facts
Blade International Marketing Corporation obtained several commercial letters of credit from Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company. The bank paid the suppliers by letters of credit against bills of exchange, and the merchandise and documents were delivered under trust receipts. These trust receipts required the entrustee to hold the goods, the documents, and the proceeds of sale for the payment of the bank's acceptances and the corporation's obligations.
The bank alleged eight causes of action and claimed that, without justifiable reason, the petitioners failed and refused to account for and turn over the proceeds of the goods. The petitioners answered that the individual defendants never signed the letters of credit and related documents in their personal capacities, that they acted only for the corporation, and that the trust receipts were simulated and therefore void.
The trial court dismissed the complaint and the counterclaim. The Court of Appeals reversed, finding the petitioners liable jointly and severally for the total obligation as of the end of May 1997, inclusive of interest and penalty charge until full payment, plus attorney's fees. Reconsideration was denied, and the case reached the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not the petitioners Evan J. Borbon, Edgar J. Borbon, and Marcial Geronimo are personally liable, jointly and severally with Blade International Marketing Corporation, for the fulfillment of its obligations under the letters of credit opened with the bank.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote a specific statutory provision. It rests on the contractual undertakings contained in the letters of credit and related documents, which the Court reads according to their terms. The governing principle is that a signatory is bound by what he signs, as the Court states:
An experienced businessman who signs important legal papers cannot disclaim the consequent liabilities therefor after being a signatory thereon.
This principle bears on the case because the petitioners admitted signing the documents, and the Court held them to the terms they accepted.
Ruling
The Court held the petitioners liable solidarily. The petitioners admitted that they signed the letters of credit and related documents, but claimed they signed the forms in blank. The Court rejected this excuse. The documents show that the petitioners agreed to jointly and severally undertake payment of the obligations and consented to each and all of the stipulated conditions on the documents. An experienced businessman who signs important legal papers cannot disclaim the consequent liabilities after being a signatory thereon. Thus, the Court of Appeals correctly found that the petitioners contractually agreed to hold themselves personally and solidarily liable with the corporation in the fulfillment of its obligations to the bank.
Doctrine
An officer or stockholder who signs a letter of credit or related document, expressly binding himself jointly and severally for the corporation's obligations, becomes personally and solidarily liable with the corporation. The fact that he signed a blank form, or that he acted in behalf of the corporation, does not relieve him, because the signed document defines his undertaking. A person who signs an important legal paper is presumed to know its contents and cannot later disclaim the liabilities that flow from his signature. The rule is captured in the Court's own words:
An experienced businessman who signs important legal papers cannot disclaim the consequent liabilities therefor after being a signatory thereon.
For a Bar answer, state the rule as a contract principle: the signatory is bound by the terms of the instrument he executes, and solidary liability arises from the express agreement contained in the document.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeals in its entirety, with no pronouncement as to costs. The bank won, and the petitioners were ordered to pay jointly and severally.
Remember This
The one line to memorize: an experienced businessman who signs important legal papers cannot disclaim the consequent liabilities after being a signatory thereon. Examiners use this case to test whether a corporate officer who signs a letter of credit or trust receipt in a personal and solidary capacity can hide behind the corporate veil, and the answer is no.