JOSEFINA TANDO, CARMEN TANDO, CECILIA TANDO-ARNOLD, HILDA TANDO-TERENCIO, AND KALIBO RURAL BANK, INC., PETITIONERS, VS. HON. COURT OF APPEALS AND BENJAMIN TAGLE, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Tando versus Tagle
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by the heirs of the spouses Jose and Esperanza Tando, together with the Kalibo Rural Bank, against Benjamin Tagle. The action began as a complaint for redemption of a parcel of land. Fernando Tagle, the father of Benjamin, had mortgaged his land to the bank, and the bank later foreclosed it. Esperanza Tando redeemed the property from the bank, and the question is whether that redemption was valid and whether the Tagles retained the right to redeem the land from her. The case matters because it shows how the Supreme Court treats a conflict between the factual findings of the trial court and those of the Court of Appeals, and because it applies the rule that a redemption by a third person, once validly made, extinguishes the rights of the mortgagee and voids any later sale of the same property.
Procedural History
Fernando Tagle filed the complaint for redemption with the then Court of First Instance of Kalibo, Aklan, Branch 3, which later became the Regional Trial Court. The trial court dismissed the complaint against the Tando spouses and the Kalibo Rural Bank. It declared that the plaintiff could not redeem the land, that the Tando spouses were the absolute owners, and that the Deed of Assignment presented by the plaintiff was invalid or inexistent. It also declared valid the Deed of Sale executed by the bank in favor of Esperanza Tando.
Benjamin Tagle, who substituted his deceased father, appealed to the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals reversed and set aside the decision of the trial court. It ordered the defendants to allow the plaintiff to redeem the property within the remaining redemption period of three years, four months, and seven days from finality of judgment. It fixed the redemption price at seven thousand one hundred fifty-one pesos and six centavos, plus expenses. It declared void the Final Deed of Sale in favor of the bank and the Deed of Sale in favor of Esperanza Tando. It also awarded twenty thousand pesos per annum as the annual income of the property from November 15, 1971 until redemption, and twenty thousand pesos as attorney's fees.
The petitioners moved for reconsideration, which the Court of Appeals denied. The petitioners then filed this petition for review on certiorari before the Supreme Court.
Facts
Fernando Tagle owned a parcel of land in Barrio Cabatanga, Makato, Aklan, with an area of 292,177 square meters. On August 17, 1962, he mortgaged the property to the Kalibo Rural Bank. Two years later, he sold the riceland portion of the same property to Jose Gonzales through a deed of sale purportedly with a right to repurchase within five years.
On July 15, 1969, the bank extrajudicially foreclosed the mortgage and, being the highest bidder, purchased the property. A Certificate of Sheriff's Sale was issued and registered. On March 23, 1970, Esperanza Tando, mother of the petitioner heirs, redeemed the foreclosed property from the bank. She also redeemed the riceland portion from Jose Gonzales. These redemptions were made by virtue of a Deed of Assignment of Right of Redemption executed by Fernando Tagle in her favor.
On August 12, 1970, the provincial sheriff executed a Final Deed of Sale over the foreclosed property in favor of the bank. On September 7, 1970, the bank executed a Deed of Sale over the same property in favor of Esperanza. Benjamin Tagle later offered on several occasions to redeem the property from Esperanza, the last being in April 1971, but she refused. Fernando then filed the action for redemption. Fernando died in January 1974 and was substituted by Benjamin. The Tando spouses also died and were substituted by their children, the petitioners.
Issues
- Whether or not Esperanza Tando redeemed the property pursuant to a Deed of Assignment executed by Fernando Tagle, thereby rendering void the subsequent deeds of sale in her favor.
- Whether or not the Deed of Assignment presented by the private respondent was the authentic document that contained the real agreement of the parties.
- Whether or not the private respondent is entitled to an award of twenty thousand pesos per annum representing the income of the property from the date he filed the petition for redemption up to the final transfer of the property in his favor.
Applicable Provisions
Article 428 of the Civil Code provides:
The owner has the right to enjoy and dispose of a thing, without other limitations than those established by law. The owner has also a right of action against the holder and possessor of the thing in order to recover it.
This provision bears on the case because the Court held that since the Tagles had not lost ownership of the property, they were entitled to enjoy it, including the income therefrom, which supports the award of twenty thousand pesos per annum.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court found in the affirmative. There was an admission by the petitioners of this fact when they adopted the factual findings of the Court of Appeals in their petition. The Court also noted that Esperanza was issued a Deed of Redemption by the bank, which was duly registered. The Court reasoned that banks are strictly protective of their interests and would not allow a stranger to a mortgage contract to redeem a foreclosed property upon a mere verbal representation of the mortgagor. The former assistant manager of the bank testified that it was their practice to require authorization from the defaulting borrower before allowing redemption by third persons, and that Esperanza showed such an authorization. Thus, Esperanza validly redeemed the property, which removed from the bank whatever right it had over the property. As a consequence, the bank had no right to be issued a final deed of sale by the provincial sheriff, much less to sell the property to the Tandos. The Court of Appeals therefore did not err in declaring the two deeds of sale void.
On the second issue, the Court again found in the affirmative. The testimony of the private respondent appeared more logical and credible, being corroborated by other witnesses. Benjamin testified that Alejo Terencio went to their house with the draft deed, which Fernando, Benjamin, and two other witnesses signed, and which provided for a five-year redemption period. He explained that Terencio took the original before notarization and never returned it. This was corroborated by Araceli Gonzales and by the bank's former assistant manager. The Court found Terencio's testimony inconsistent with that of the mortgagees, and noted that it was unlikely the Tagles would negotiate for a mere five-month redemption period when that was the same period left for them to redeem from the bank. The Court agreed that the deed of assignment presented by the private respondent was the authentic document.
On the third issue, the Court ruled in the affirmative. The private respondent's right of redemption was subject to a five-year period, which had not yet expired when the Tagles initiated the complaint. Consequently, they did not lose ownership over the property and were entitled to enjoy it, including the income therefrom. As the petitioners did not dispute the amount of income set at twenty thousand pesos per annum, the Court found no valid reason to alter it.
Doctrine
A valid redemption of foreclosed property by a third person, duly authorized by the mortgagor, extinguishes the rights of the mortgagee over the property. Any subsequent final deed of sale issued to the mortgagee, and any sale made by the mortgagee to another, are void because the mortgagee no longer had any right to transfer. A bank, being strictly protective of its interests, will not permit a stranger to redeem a foreclosed property on mere verbal representation; it requires written authority from the defaulting borrower. When the factual findings of the trial court and the Court of Appeals conflict, the Supreme Court may review the facts as an exception to the general rule that factual questions are not reviewable in a petition for review. Finally, under Article 428 of the Civil Code, the owner has the right to enjoy and dispose of a thing, and an owner who has not lost ownership by a valid redemption is entitled to the income of the property.
Disposition
The petition was denied. The decision and resolution of the Court of Appeals were affirmed, with costs against the petitioners.
Remember This
A valid redemption by a third person authorized by the mortgagor wipes out the mortgagee's rights and voids any later sale of the property. Examiners use this case to test the rule on the review of conflicting factual findings and the requirement of written authority for redemption by a stranger to the mortgage.