VICTOR G. VALENCIA, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, HON. TEOFISTO T. GUINGONA, JR., AS EXECUTIVE SECRETARY, HON. ERNESTO GARILAO, SECRETARY OF AGRARIAN REFORM, CRISOSTOMO M. C…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Valencia versus Court of Appeals
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Victor G. Valencia, a government retiree and landowner, against the Court of Appeals, the Executive Secretary, the Secretary of Agrarian Reform, and a group of farmer-beneficiaries who had been issued Certificates of Land Transfer over his two parcels of land in Canlaon City, Negros Oriental. Valencia sought to recover possession of his property after his civil law lease agreements expired, only to find that his lessees' farmhands had been recognized as tenants and granted land transfer certificates under the Operation Land Transfer program. The case matters because it settles two things at once: the proper mode and forum for appealing agrarian reform decisions, and the substantive rule that a civil law lessee cannot, without the landowner's consent, install a tenant who then acquires security of tenure. It is also a reminder that social justice is for the deserving, rich or poor alike.
Procedural History
Valencia first filed a letter of protest with the Minister of Agrarian Reform, which was referred to the regional office. After investigation, the Department of Agrarian Reform regional office dismissed his protest and held that the private respondents had the right to remain on the land. His motion for reconsideration was denied. He then appealed to the Office of the President, which affirmed the regional order but excluded his homestead area from the coverage of Presidential Decree Number 27. Valencia went up to the Court of Appeals, which dismissed his petition on a technical ground: his appeal was filed out of time, because under Section 54 of Republic Act Number 6657 he should have gone directly to the Court of Appeals within fifteen days instead of appealing to the Office of the President under the Department of Agrarian Reform Memorandum Circular Number 3, series of 1994. His motion for reconsideration was denied. He then filed this petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court.
Facts
Valencia owned two parcels of land in Barangay Linothangan, Canlaon City. He acquired the first parcel in May 1957; its only tenant, Digoy Besario, was succeeded by his son Jesus Besario, and in July 1961 Valencia and Jesus Besario voluntarily terminated their landlord-tenant relationship through a public instrument, returning physical possession to Valencia. In October 1962 Valencia entered into a ten-year civil law lease over both parcels with Glicerio Henson. Before that lease expired, and apparently without objection from Henson, Valencia leased the property for five years to Father Andres Flores beginning August 1970. That lease prohibited subleasing or encumbering the land without Valencia's written consent, which effectively barred installing a leasehold tenant.
During Henson's lease, Henson brought Crescenciano Frias and Marciano Frias to work the land. During Father Flores's lease, Flores designated a number of farmhands, including Francisco Obang as overseer, who shared produce with him. When the Flores lease expired in June 1975, Valencia demanded that the occupants vacate so he could work the land by administration through an overseer. They refused and continued cultivating the land. Without Valencia's knowledge or consent, they applied for Certificates of Land Transfer under the Operation Land Transfer program, and in December 1985 the Department of Agrarian Reform issued the certificates to them.
Valencia filed a second protest and sought cancellation of the certificates. An administrative investigation found, among other things, that the overseer had collected the owner's shares without authority and remitted nothing to Valencia, that some respondents sublet their farmholdings, and that the land had been included in a final survey despite the pending protest. The investigating officer recommended cancellation of the certificates, but the regional office dismissed the protest. Only Catalino Mantac later entered into a leasehold contract with Valencia.
Issues
- Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in dismissing the petition on the ground that Valencia's appeal to the Office of the President, instead of to the Court of Appeals, was filed out of time.
- Whether or not Department of Agrarian Reform Memorandum Circular Number 3, series of 1994, providing for an appeal to the Office of the President, is valid and consistent with Section 54 of Republic Act Number 6657 and the rules of court.
- Whether or not an appeal to the Office of the President from a decision of the Department Secretary is proper under the doctrine of exhaustion of administrative remedies.
- Whether or not a contract of civil law lease may prohibit the civil law lessee from employing a tenant on the land subject of the lease.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1649 of the Civil Code provides:
The lessee cannot assign the lease without the consent of the lessor, unless there is a stipulation to the contrary.
This is the provision the Court uses to hold that the lessee cannot install a tenant, since the right to hire a tenant is an attribute of ownership.
Section 6 of Republic Act Number 3844, as amended, provides:
Parties to Agricultural Leasehold Relations. — The agricultural leasehold relation shall be limited to the person who furnishes the landholding, either as owner, civil law lessee, usufructuary, or legal possessor, and the person who personally cultivates the same.
The Court reads this as presupposing an existing leasehold relation, not as authorizing a civil law lessee to create one without the landowner's consent.
Section 54 of Republic Act Number 6657 provides:
Decisions of the Department of Agrarian Reform Adjudication Board may be appealed to the Court of Appeals within a period of fifteen days from receipt of the notice of the decision.
This provision, harmonized with the circular, establishes the mode of appeal from the adjudication board to the Court of Appeals.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled for Valencia. Interpreting and harmonizing laws with laws is the best method of interpretation, and where two rules on the same subject apparently conflict, they should be reconciled so that both are given effect. The circular and Section 54 serve different purposes: the circular provides a mode of appeal for matters outside the adjudication board's jurisdiction and corrects technical errors, while Section 54 and the rules implement judicial review over quasi-judicial agencies. Valencia's appeal to the Office of the President was timely, and his subsequent petition for review to the Court of Appeals was filed within the fifteen-day reglementary period.
On the second issue, the Court held the circular valid. The power of the Department Secretary to promulgate internal rules of administrative procedure is lodged in him by necessary implication as part of his express power to promulgate rules and regulations necessary to carry out department objectives, policies, functions, plans, programs and projects.
On the third issue, the Court held that an administrative decision must first be appealed to administrative superiors up to the highest level before it may be elevated to a court. An appeal to the Office of the President from the decision of the Department Secretary is the last step in the administrative hierarchy and a plain, speedy and adequate remedy.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that a civil law lease can prohibit the lessee from employing a tenant. Section 6 of Republic Act Number 3844 does not automatically authorize a civil law lessee to employ a tenant without the landowner's consent; the right to hire a tenant is basically a personal right of a landowner. Under Article 1649, the lessee cannot assign the lease without the lessor's consent, and here the lessee was expressly prohibited from subleasing or encumbering the land, which includes installing a leasehold tenant, since the right to do so is an attribute of ownership.
Doctrine
A civil law lessee cannot, without the landowner's consent, install a tenant on the land; Section 6 of Republic Act Number 3844 presupposes an existing leasehold relation and does not create one. The right to hire a tenant is an attribute of ownership, and a lease may prohibit subleasing or encumbering, which includes installing a tenant. Department of Agrarian Reform Memorandum Circular Number 3, series of 1994, is a valid exercise of the Secretary's rule-making power, and an appeal to the Office of the President is the last step in the administrative hierarchy before judicial review. Social justice is for the deserving, whether rich or poor.
Disposition
The Court granted Valencia's petition, reversed and set aside the Court of Appeals decision and resolution, and remanded the case for further proceedings consistent with its ruling.
Remember This
The single line to memorize: a civil law lessee cannot install a tenant without the landowner's consent, because the right to hire a tenant is an attribute of ownership. Examiners use this case to test the interplay of agrarian reform, the exhaustion of administrative remedies, and the limits of a lessee's rights under Article 1649 of the Civil Code.