🎧 Case Brief Lecture

JOSE C. RAMIREZ, PETITIONER, VS. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS, MUNICIPAL BOARD OF CANVASSERS OF GIPORLOS, EASTERN SAMAR AND ALFREDO I. GO, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 122013. March 26, 1997 March 26, 1997

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Ramirez versus Commission on Elections

The Case

This is a special civil action of certiorari and mandamus brought by Jose C. Ramirez against the Commission on Elections, the Municipal Board of Canvassers of Giporlos, Eastern Samar, and his rival Alfredo I. Go. Ramirez asks the Supreme Court to annul two resolutions of the Commission en banc that ordered a recomputation of the Statement of Votes and to restore his proclamation as vice mayor. The case matters because it fixes two rules every election lawyer must know: a petition to correct a manifest error in the Statement of Votes may be filed directly with the Commission en banc, and such an error must be corrected in the Statement of Votes itself, on the basis of the election returns, not through a mere certification.

Procedural History

After the May 1995 elections, Alfredo Go filed with the Commission on Elections a petition for correction of what he claimed was a manifest error in the Statement of Votes. The Commission en banc, in its first resolution dated August 1, 1995, directed the Municipal Board of Canvassers to reconvene, recompute the votes in the Statement of Votes, and proclaim the winning candidate accordingly. Ramirez and the Board filed separate motions for clarification. In its second resolution dated September 26, 1995, the Commission en banc reiterated its earlier ruling and rejected the Board's recommendation to resort to the election returns. Ramirez then came to the Supreme Court on certiorari and mandamus, seeking to annul both resolutions and to reinstate his proclamation.

Facts

Jose C. Ramirez and Alfredo I. Go were candidates for vice mayor of Giporlos, Eastern Samar in the election of May 8, 1995. The Municipal Board of Canvassers proclaimed Ramirez the winner on the basis of results showing 1,367 votes for him against 1,235 votes for Go.

On May 16, 1995, Go filed with the Commission on Elections a petition for correction of manifest error in the Statement of Votes. He alleged that, based on the entries in the Statement of Votes, he actually obtained 1,515 votes against Ramirez's 1,367, but that an error in addition credited him with only 1,235 votes. In his Answer with Counter-Protest, Ramirez disputed this. He claimed that it was the entries for him in several precincts that were erroneously reflected, and that those entries actually referred to the votes of a mayoralty candidate, Rodito Fabillar. He insisted that, per the Certificates of Votes prepared by the Boards of Election Inspectors, the totals were actually 1,367 for him and 1,235 for Go.

The Commission en banc twice ordered the Board to reconvene and recompute the votes in the Statement of Votes, reminding the Board that it is the Statement of Votes, duly certified, that supports the Certificate of Canvass and Proclamation. Ramirez then filed this petition, arguing that the Commission en banc acted without jurisdiction because the case was never acted upon by any of its divisions, and that the Board had already corrected the errors on its own through a certification dated May 22, 1995.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Commission on Elections en banc may take cognizance of a petition for correction of manifest error in the Statement of Votes filed directly with it, without the case first being heard and decided by a division.
  • Whether or not the certification issued by the Municipal Board of Canvassers was a valid correction of the manifest errors in the Statement of Votes.

Applicable Provisions

Section 3 of Article 9 of the Constitution provides:

The Commission on Elections may sit en banc or in two divisions, and shall promulgate its rules of procedure in order to expedite disposition of election cases, including pre-proclamation controversies. All such election cases shall be heard and decided in division, provided that motions for reconsideration of decisions shall be decided by the Comelec en banc.

This is the provision Ramirez invoked to argue that the case had to pass through a division first.

Section 5 of Rule 27 of the 1993 Rules of the Commission on Elections provides:

Pre-proclamation Controversies Which May Be Filed Directly With the Commission. (a) The following pre-proclamation controversies may be filed directly with the Commission: When the issue involves the correction of manifest errors in the tabulation or tallying of the results during the canvassing as where (1) a copy of the election returns or certificate of canvass was tabulated more than once, (2) two or more copies of the election returns of one precinct, or two or more copies of certificate of canvass were tabulated separately, (3) there had been a mistake in the copying of the figures into the statement of votes or into the certificate of canvass, or (4) so-called returns from non-existent precincts were included in the canvass, and such errors could not have been discovered during the canvassing despite the exercise of due diligence and proclamation of the winning candidates had already been made. The petition shall be heard and decided by the Commission en banc.

This is the rule that authorizes the en banc to act directly on a petition to correct a manifest error in the Statement of Votes.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the Commission en banc acted within its jurisdiction. While election cases, including pre-proclamation controversies, are as a rule first heard and decided by a division, the Court pointed out that in none of the cases cited for that proposition was the issue the correction of a manifest error in the Statement of Votes. Rule 27, Section 5 of the Commission's 1993 Rules expressly allows such a petition to be filed directly with the en banc, and the Court had approved this practice in earlier cases and did so again. The Court added that Ramirez was in any event estopped: he not only participated in the proceedings but sought affirmative relief from the en banc by filing a Counter-Protest asking that the entries in the Statement of Votes for several precincts be corrected. It is not right for a party who submits his case for decision to attack the decision later for lack of jurisdiction because it turns out to be adverse to him.

On the second issue, the Court held that the certification was not the proper way to correct manifest errors. The corrections should be made either by inserting them in the Statement of Votes originally prepared and submitted by the Board, or by preparing an entirely new Statement of Votes incorporating the corrections. More importantly, the corrections should be based on the election returns, but the corrections appeared to have been made on the basis of the Certificates of Votes. The Court also reminded the Board that it is the Statement of Votes, duly prepared and certified, that supports the Certificate of Canvass and Proclamation.

Doctrine

First, a petition for correction of a manifest error in the tabulation or tallying of results, such as a mistake in copying figures into the Statement of Votes, is a pre-proclamation controversy that may be filed directly with the Commission on Elections en banc, and the en banc may hear and decide it. Second, a manifest error in the Statement of Votes must be corrected in the Statement of Votes itself, either by inserting the corrections therein or by preparing a new Statement of Votes, and the corrections must be based on the election returns, not on Certificates of Votes or a separate certification. Third, a party who invokes the jurisdiction of the Commission by seeking affirmative relief therein is estopped from later attacking that jurisdiction when the ruling turns out to be adverse to him.

Disposition

The petition was dismissed, and the two resolutions of the Commission on Elections were upheld, leaving the order to reconvene and recompute the votes in the Statement of Votes in force.

Remember This

The one line to memorize: a manifest error in the Statement of Votes is corrected in the Statement of Votes itself, on the basis of the election returns, and the petition may go straight to the Commission en banc. Examiners use this case on the jurisdiction of the Commission en banc over pre-proclamation controversies and on the proper manner of correcting manifest errors.