🎧 Case Brief Lecture

CECILIO P. DE LOS SANTOS AND BUKLOD MANGGAGAWA NG CAMARA (BUMACA), PETITIONERS, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION (SECOND DIVISION), HON. COMMISSIONERS VICTORIANO R. CALAY…

G.R. No. 121327. December 20, 2001 December 20, 2001

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

De los Santos versus Camara Steel

The Case

This is a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 filed by Cecilio de los Santos and the union Buklod Manggagawa ng Camara against the National Labor Relations Commission and Camara Steel Industries, Incorporated. The petitioner asks the Supreme Court to annul the Commission's decision that set aside the Labor Arbiter's award and remanded the case for further proceedings on the question of who really employed him. The case matters because it gathers into one decision the whole cluster of labor-law doctrines a reviewee must command: the four standards for the existence of an employer-employee relationship, the primacy of the control test, the statutory test for labor-only contracting, the limits of loss of trust and confidence as a just cause, and the relaxed application of procedural rules in labor cases.

Procedural History

De los Santos filed a complaint for illegal dismissal before the Labor Arbiter. The Arbiter ruled in his favor, finding that Camara Steel had illegally dismissed him and ordering his reinstatement with full back wages and attorney's fees. Camara Steel appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission. Top-Flite, the manpower agency, moved to intervene. The Commission reversed the Labor Arbiter and ordered the entire records returned to the arbitration branch of origin for further proceedings, chiefly to determine whether an employer-employee relationship existed and to summon Top-Flite as a necessary party. De los Santos then came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari under Rule 65, alleging grave abuse of discretion.

Facts

On 3 May 1991 De los Santos began working at Camara Steel, a company manufacturing steel products such as liquefied petroleum gas cylinders and drums. He was first assigned to the assembly line, then became operator of a blasting machine. After an accident forced him to go on leave for one and a half months, he was reassigned as a janitor tasked with cleaning the premises and occasionally transferring scrap and garbage.

On 11 May 1993, while doing his usual chores, he momentarily left his pushcart to answer the call of Narciso Honrado, the scrap in-charge, who summoned him to the company clinic. There Honrado handed him a box, which he placed on his pushcart for transfer to the other lot of the company near gate 2. On his way out, the security guard found in the box two pieces of electric cable and another piece, with a total estimated value of 50 to 100 pesos. De los Santos explained that the electric cord had been declared scrap by Honrado, whose instructions he was merely following. Honrado admitted responsibility and his error in declaring the cables as scrap, and the general manager, apparently appeased by his apology, exculpated him of any wrongdoing.

Taking an unexpected turn, the company filed a criminal complaint for frustrated qualified theft against Honrado and De los Santos, which the Provincial Prosecutor of Pasig later dismissed for lack of evidence. On 23 August 1993, upon the request of Top-Flite, the alleged manpower agency, Camara Steel terminated his services. Hence the complaint for illegal dismissal.

Issues

  • Whether or not there existed an employer-employee relationship between De los Santos and Camara Steel, and whether Top-Flite was an independent contractor or a labor-only contractor.
  • Whether or not De los Santos was illegally dismissed from his employment.
  • Whether or not the National Labor Relations Commission committed grave abuse of discretion in remanding the case to the Labor Arbiter for failure to summon Top-Flite.

Applicable Provisions

Article 282 of the Labor Code, as quoted in the decision, provides:

Article 282. Termination by employer. An employer may terminate an employment for any of the following causes: x x x (c) Fraud or willful breach by the employee of the trust reposed in him by his employer or duly authorized representative x x x x

This is the just cause Camara Steel invoked, and the Court measures whether a janitor's position falls within the trust and confidence this provision contemplates.

Section 4, paragraph (f), Rule VIII-A, Book III of the Omnibus Rules Implementing the Labor Code, as quoted in the decision, provides:

"Labor-only" contracting as defined in Section 4, paragraph (f), Rule VIII-A, Book III, of the Omnibus Rules Implementing the Labor Code states that a "labor-only" contractor, prohibited under this Rule, is an arrangement where the contractor or subcontractor merely recruits, supplies or places workers to perform a job, work or service for a principal and the following elements are present: (a) The contractor or subcontractor does not have substantial capital or investment to actually perform the job, work or service under its own account or responsibility; and, (b) The employees recruited, supplied or placed by such contractor or subcontractor are performing activities which are directly related to the main business of the principal.

This is the statutory yardstick by which the Court classifies Top-Flite, and a finding of labor-only contracting makes the principal answerable as the real employer.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that an employer-employee relationship existed between De los Santos and Camara Steel. It applied the four standards: the manner of selection and engagement, the mode of payment of wages, the power of dismissal, and the power of control over the employee's conduct, the last being the most determinative, what the Court calls the control test. De los Santos was interviewed and hired through Camara Steel's timekeeper, who worked under a company supervisor. His daily time records, though some bore the heading of Top-Flite, were signed by Camara Steel's assistant manager, personnel manager, and department head. The power to dismiss lay with Camara Steel, which admitted that Top-Flite merely requested his termination. As the Court put it, if Top-Flite were truly the employer, it would not be asking permission to dismiss him.

On the character of Top-Flite, the Court held it to be a labor-only contractor, a mere supplier of labor, because it adduced no substantial evidence of adequate capital or investment, and because the work of a janitor is directly related to the main business of the principal. The Court stressed that a party cannot dictate the character of its business by a unilateral declaration in a contract; that character is measured by the criteria set by statute.

On the second issue, the Court held that De los Santos was illegally dismissed. It was Honrado who handed him the box, and no evidence showed he knew its contents or conspired with Honrado. Honrado was forgiven; De los Santos was dismissed and criminally charged. The Court also rejected loss of trust and confidence, because that cause presupposes a position of trust and confidence, and the task of a janitor does not fall under that category.

On the third issue, the Court held that the remand was improper. Top-Flite had been impleaded and had in fact submitted a position paper, so it was heard. Jurisdiction over the person may be acquired not only by summons but by voluntary appearance, which includes the submission of pleadings. Administrative tribunals exercising quasi-judicial powers are not bound by the rigidity of technical rules, and in labor cases strict technical adherence may be relaxed in the interest of the workingman.

Doctrine

First, the existence of an employer-employee relationship is tested by four standards: selection and engagement, payment of wages, power of dismissal, and power of control, with the control test the most determinative. Second, labor-only contracting exists where the contractor lacks substantial capital or investment and the workers perform activities directly related to the main business of the principal; the principal is then responsible as if the workers had been directly employed. Third, the character of a contractor's business is determined by statutory criteria, not by the parties' own declaration in a contract. Fourth, loss of trust and confidence requires that the employee hold a position of trust and confidence, and a janitor's task does not qualify. Fifth, jurisdiction over the person may be acquired by voluntary appearance, and labor tribunals may relax technical rules in favor of the workingman.

Disposition

The petition was granted; the decision of the National Labor Relations Commission was reversed and set aside, and the decision of the Labor Arbiter ordering reinstatement with back wages and attorney's fees was reinstated and adopted.

Remember This

Memorize the line that a party cannot dictate the character of its business by a unilateral declaration in a contract, for that character is measured by the criteria set by statute. Examiners use this case for the control test, for labor-only contracting, and for the rule that loss of trust and confidence cannot reach a janitor.