BANK OF AMERICA NT&SA, BANK OF AMERICA INTERNATIONAL, LTD., PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, HON. MANUEL PADOLINA, EDUARDO LITONJUA, SR., AND AURELIO K. LITONJUA, JR., RESPOND…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Bank of America versus Litonjua
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by the Bank of America NT and SA and Bank of America International, Ltd. against the spouses of commerce, so to speak — Eduardo Litonjua, Senior, and Aurelio Litonjua, Junior — who had sued the banks in the Regional Trial Court of Pasig for an accounting of the revenues of six vessels and of the proceeds of their foreclosure sale, and for damages for breach of trust. The banks sought to stop the case at the threshold, first by a motion to dismiss and then by a petition for certiorari in the Court of Appeals. The case matters because it gathers in one decision three recurring bar topics: the real party in interest and the distinction between failure to state a cause of action and lack of cause of action; the doctrine of forum non conveniens, which literally means the forum is inconvenient; and the requisites of litis pendentia and forum shopping as grounds for dismissal.
Procedural History
The Litonjuas filed their complaint in the Regional Trial Court of Pasig. The defendant banks moved to dismiss on two grounds: forum non conveniens and lack of cause of action. The trial court, through Judge Manuel Padolina, denied the motion and gave the banks ten days to answer. The banks moved for reconsideration; the trial court denied that too. Instead of answering, the banks went up to the Court of Appeals on a petition for review on certiorari, which the appellate court treated as a petition for certiorari. The Court of Appeals dismissed the petition and later denied the banks' motion for reconsideration. The banks then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45, raising three assigned errors: that the Litonjuas, being mere stockholders, had no personality to sue; that the complaint should have been dismissed on the ground of forum non conveniens; and that the Litonjuas were guilty of forum shopping because of the pendency of civil actions in England and Hong Kong.
Facts
The Litonjuas were engaged in the shipping business and owned two vessels, the Don Aurelio and the El Champion, through their wholly owned corporations. They deposited the revenues of that business, together with other funds, with branches of the defendant banks in the United Kingdom and Hong Kong up to 1979. The banks then induced them to expand the fleet, offering easy loans, and four more vessels were acquired through their corporations: the El Carrier, the El General, the El Challenger, and the El Conqueror. The banks, according to the complaint, placed the operation of the vessels and the funds derived from them under their complete and exclusive control and disposition, and put the possession of the vessels in the hands of persons they selected.
The Litonjuas alleged that the banks, as trustees, never fully rendered an account of the income from the operations or of the proceeds of the subsequent foreclosure sale. Because of the breach of fiduciary duty and negligence, revenues declined, the loans matured unpaid, and all six vessels — including the two originally owned by the Litonjuas — were foreclosed and sold at public auction. The Litonjuas claimed they lost personal funds equivalent to ten percent of the acquisition cost of the four vessels and were left with an unpaid loan balance.
The banks countered that the borrowers and registered owners were the foreign corporations, not the Litonjuas, who were mere stockholders; that the loans, the restructuring agreements, and the sales all took place abroad and were governed by English law; and that the Litonjuas had refused to contest the civil actions the banks had earlier filed in England and Hong Kong.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court committed grave abuse of discretion in refusing to dismiss the complaint on the ground that the Litonjuas, being mere stockholders of the corporate borrowers and owners, have no personality to sue.
- Whether or not the complaint should be dismissed on the ground of forum non conveniens.
- Whether or not the Litonjuas are guilty of forum shopping because of the pendency of the foreign actions.
Applicable Provisions
Section 1, Rule 16 of the Rules of Court, as discussed in the decision, lists the grounds for a motion to dismiss, and the Court notes that forum non conveniens is not among them:
Section 1. Grounds. — Within the time for but before filing the answer to the complaint or pleading asserting a claim, a motion to dismiss may be made on any of the following grounds: (a) That the court has no jurisdiction over the person of the defending party; (b) That the court has no jurisdiction over the subject matter of the claim; (c) That venue is improperly laid; (d) That the plaintiff has no legal capacity to sue; (e) That there is another action pending between the same parties for the same cause; (f) That the cause of action is barred by a prior judgment or by the statute of limitations; (g) That the pleading asserting the claim states no cause of action; (h) That the claim or demand set forth in the plaintiff's pleading has been paid, waived, abandoned, or otherwise extinguished; (i) That the claim on which the action is founded is unenforceable under the provisions of the statute of frauds; and (j) That a condition precedent for the filing of the action has not been complied with.
This provision bears on the case because the Court holds that forum non conveniens cannot be invoked as a ground for a motion to dismiss, since the rule does not include it.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that there was no grave abuse of discretion. A case is dismissible for lack of personality to sue only upon proof that the plaintiff is not the real party in interest, and this is raised as failure to state a cause of action, judged on the face of the complaint. A complaint states a cause of action when it contains three elements: the legal right of the plaintiff, the correlative obligation of the defendant, and the act or omission of the defendant violating that right. The complaint here alleged all three: the right of the Litonjuas to demand an accounting from the banks as trustees under a fiduciary relationship, the obligation of the banks to render that accounting, and their failure to do so. The Court stressed the difference between failure to state a cause of action, which is an insufficiency of allegation and may be raised at the earliest stage, and lack of cause of action, which is an insufficiency of factual basis and may be raised only after the facts are resolved. Any uncertainty in the complaint should be resolved to enable a full inquiry into the merits, to avoid multiplicity of suits.
On the second issue, the Court also ruled for the Litonjuas. Forum non conveniens is addressed to the sound discretion of the trial court, and a Philippine court may assume jurisdiction if three requisites are met: that the Philippine court is one to which the parties may conveniently resort; that it is in a position to make an intelligent decision as to the law and the facts; and that it has or is likely to have power to enforce its decision. All three were present. Moreover, the doctrine should not be used as a ground for a motion to dismiss, because the rule does not list it; the propriety of desistance requires a factual determination and is more properly a matter of defense.
On the third issue, the Court held that there was no forum shopping. Forum shopping exists where the elements of litis pendentia are present and a final judgment in one case will amount to res judicata in the other. For litis pendentia, there must be identity of parties or of interests, identity of rights asserted and reliefs prayed for founded on the same acts, and a judgment in one that would amount to res judicata in the other. The banks merely enumerated the foreign cases without showing the identity of rights and reliefs or the elements of res judicata, and they failed to attach a single foreign judgment to their pleadings.
Doctrine
A complaint is dismissed for failure to state a cause of action only when, on its face, it lacks the three elements of a cause of action: the plaintiff's legal right, the defendant's correlative obligation, and the defendant's act or omission violating that right. Lack of personality to sue is raised as failure to state a cause of action, not as lack of cause of action.
Forum non conveniens is not a ground for a motion to dismiss under Section 1, Rule 16 of the Rules of Court. A Philippine court may assume jurisdiction where it is one to which the parties may conveniently resort, it can make an intelligent decision on the law and the facts, and it can enforce its decision; the doctrine is a matter of defense requiring factual determination.
Forum shopping requires the elements of litis pendentia: identity of parties or interests, identity of rights asserted and reliefs prayed for founded on the same acts, and a judgment in one case that would amount to res judicata in the other. The party invoking it must show these elements, including the foreign judgments relied upon.
Disposition
The petition was denied for lack of merit, with costs against the petitioners; the banks lost, and the denial of their motion to dismiss by the trial court and the Court of Appeals stood.
Remember This
Memorize the line that forum non conveniens is not a ground for a motion to dismiss under Section 1, Rule 16, and that it is a matter of defense addressed to the sound discretion of the trial court. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between failure to state a cause of action and lack of cause of action, and the requisites of litis pendentia and forum shopping.