PHILIPPINE NATIONAL BANK, PETITIONER, VS. HON. PRES. JUDGE BENITO C. SE, JR., RTC, BR. 45, MANILA; NOAH’S ARK SUGAR REFINERY; ALBERTO T. LOOYUKO, JIMMY T. GO AND WILSON T. GO, R…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Philippine National Bank versus Noah's Ark Sugar Refinery
The Case
This is a special civil action for certiorari, prohibition, and mandamus filed by the Philippine National Bank against Judge Benito C. Se, Jr. of the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 45, and against Noah's Ark Sugar Refinery and its officers Alberto T. Looyuko, Jimmy T. Go, and Wilson T. Go. The Bank holds five negotiable warehouse receipts, or quedans, covering sugar stocks stored in Noah's Ark's warehouse, and it had already won a final and executory judgment ordering the delivery of those stocks to it. The question is whether the warehouseman may refuse to deliver the sugar until its storage fees are paid, or whether it must first file a separate action to collect them. The case matters because it fixes the character of the warehouseman's lien as a possessory lien that survives even a final judgment of delivery, and it teaches how a warehouseman's rights under the Warehouse Receipts Law interact with the binding force of contracts.
Procedural History
The Bank filed a complaint for specific performance with damages and an application for a writ of attachment before the Regional Trial Court of Manila. The trial court denied the application for preliminary attachment and likewise denied reconsideration. The Bank then filed a petition for certiorari with the Court of Appeals, which ruled in its favor, set aside the trial court's orders, and directed the trial court to render summary judgment for the Bank. Instead, the trial court rendered judgment dismissing the Bank's complaint for lack of cause of action, and it denied the Bank's motion for reconsideration. The Bank elevated the matter to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45, and the Supreme Court reversed the trial court and ordered Noah's Ark and its officers to deliver the sugar stocks to the Bank, or alternatively to pay actual damages of 39.1 million pesos, with legal interest, attorney's fees, litigation expenses, and costs. The Supreme Court denied the motions for reconsideration and for clarification filed by Noah's Ark. Back in the trial court, Noah's Ark filed an omnibus motion asking that proceedings be deferred until its claim for a warehouseman's lien could be heard. The trial court granted the motion, received evidence on the lien, and then issued an order declaring a valid warehouseman's lien and holding execution in abeyance until the lien was satisfied. The Bank then filed this petition before the Supreme Court to annul those orders and to compel execution.
Facts
In 1989, Noah's Ark Sugar Refinery issued five warehouse receipts, or quedans, for sugar deposited by Rosa Sy, RNS Merchandising, and St. Therese Merchandising. The receipts were in substantially the form and contained the terms prescribed for negotiable warehouse receipts by the Warehouse Receipts Law. Two of the receipts were negotiated and endorsed to Luis T. Ramos, and three to Cresencia K. Zoleta. Ramos and Zoleta used the quedans as security for two loans from the Philippine National Bank, one for 15.6 million pesos and the other for 23.5 million pesos, and endorsed the quedans to the Bank.
Ramos and Zoleta failed to pay their loans upon maturity in January 1990. In March 1990, the Bank demanded delivery of the sugar stocks covered by the quedans. Noah's Ark refused, claiming ownership of the sugar, and the Bank sued. Noah's Ark answered that it had agreed to sell the sugar to the original depositors for 63 million pesos, but that the buyers' checks were dishonored, so the buyers never acquired ownership and could not pass a better right to the Bank.
The Bank moved for summary judgment. The trial court denied the motion, but the Court of Appeals nullified that denial and directed summary judgment for the Bank. The trial court instead dismissed the complaint, and the Supreme Court reversed it, ordering delivery of the sugar to the Bank or payment of 39.1 million pesos in damages. When the Bank sought execution, Noah's Ark asked the trial court to hear its claim for storage fees and preservation expenses. The trial court upheld the warehouseman's lien and stayed execution until the lien was satisfied, prompting this petition.
Issues
- Whether or not the final and executory judgment in favor of the Bank bars Noah's Ark from claiming a warehouseman's lien for storage fees and preservation expenses.
- Whether or not the warehouseman may refuse to deliver the sugar stocks until its lien is satisfied, without filing a separate action for collection.
- Whether or not the trial court acted with grave abuse of discretion in staying execution until the lien is paid.
Applicable Provisions
Section 27 of the Warehouse Receipts Law defines what claims are included in the warehouseman's lien:
SECTION 27. What claims are included in the warehouseman's lien. - Subject to the provisions of section thirty, a warehouseman shall have lien on goods deposited or on the proceeds thereof in his hands, for all lawful charges for storage and preservation of the goods; also for all lawful claims for money advanced, interest, insurance, transportation, labor, weighing coopering and other charges and expenses in relation to such goods; also for all reasonable charges and expenses for notice, and advertisement of sale, and for sale of the goods where default has been made in satisfying the warehouseman's lien.
This provision is the source of Noah's Ark's right to charge storage fees and preservation expenses over the sugar it held.
Section 31 of the same law states the effect of the lien on delivery:
SECTION 31. Warehouseman need not deliver until lien is satisfied. - A warehouseman having a lien valid against the person demanding the goods may refuse to deliver the goods to him until the lien is satisfied.
This is the provision that allows Noah's Ark to withhold the sugar from the Bank until payment.
Article 1159 of the Civil Code governs the binding force of the warehouse receipts:
ART. 1159. Obligations arising from contracts have the force of law between the contracting parties and should be complied with in good faith.
This provision binds the Bank to the express stipulation on storage fees printed on the face of the receipts.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled for Noah's Ark. The earlier resolution denying clarification did not foreclose the warehouseman's lien, because the only question then resolved was the propriety of summary judgment and the claim of ownership over the sugar. The Court could not have contemplated the lien while ownership was still being determined, and no storage fees could be due while no one had yet been declared owner. The Court also noted that the receipts themselves stipulate that storage is free for one week and that storage fees are charged thereafter, so the fees are chargeable by agreement.
On the second issue, the Court held that the Bank, as endorsee of the quedans, is bound by the express terms on their face, and that even without such a stipulation, law and equity dictate payment of the lien under Sections 27 and 31. The Court quoted Section 31 and reasoned that the goods may not be delivered until the lien is satisfied. The Bank is in estoppel: it cannot claim the sugar on the strength of the receipts while disclaiming the storage fees written on them. The Court stressed that the lien is possessory in nature, and that under Section 29 of the Warehouse Receipts Law the warehouseman loses the lien by surrendering possession without requiring payment. Hence the right must be enforced at this juncture, before delivery.
On the third issue, the Court found no grave abuse of discretion. The trial court merely recognized the legitimate right of Noah's Ark, after being declared warehouseman, to recover storage fees before releasing the sugar. The Court simplified the rule: while the Bank is entitled to the sugar as endorsee of the quedans, delivery to it shall be effected only upon payment of the storage fees.
Doctrine
A warehouseman has a lien on the goods deposited for all lawful charges for storage and preservation, and a warehouseman having a lien valid against the person demanding the goods may refuse to deliver them until the lien is satisfied. The lien is possessory in nature, so the warehouseman must demand payment before surrendering possession, because surrender without payment extinguishes the lien. A final judgment ordering delivery of the goods does not extinguish the lien; delivery is effected only upon payment of the storage fees. The endorsee of a negotiable warehouse receipt is bound by the express terms and conditions on its face, including the stipulation on storage fees, by force of Article 1159 of the Civil Code, and is in estoppel to deny those terms while claiming the goods under the same receipt.
Disposition
The petition was dismissed for lack of merit, the challenged orders of the trial court were affirmed, and costs were taxed against the Philippine National Bank.
Remember This
The one line to memorize: the endorsee of a quedan is entitled to the goods, but delivery shall be effected only upon payment of the warehouseman's lien. Examiners use this case to test the possessory character of the warehouseman's lien under Sections 27 and 31 of the Warehouse Receipts Law, and its interplay with the finality of judgments and Article 1159 of the Civil Code.