BERNARDO JIMENEZ AND JOSE JIMENEZ, AS OPERATORS OF JJ’S TRUCKING, PETITIONERS, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, PEDRO JUANATAS AND FREDELITO JUANATAS, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Jimenez versus National Labor Relations Commission
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by Bernardo Jimenez and Jose Jimenez, as operators of JJ's Trucking, against the National Labor Relations Commission and the father and son Pedro and Fredelito Juanatas. The petitioners ask the Supreme Court to annul the Commission's decision and its resolution denying reconsideration, both of which affirmed with modifications the labor arbiter's award against them. The case matters for two reasons a reviewee must hold onto: it fixes who carries the burden of proving payment of a debt, and it restates the four elements of an employer-employee relationship, with the control test at the center.
Procedural History
Pedro and Fredelito Juanatas filed a complaint for unpaid wages and commissions, separation pay, and damages before the labor arbiter. After hearings, Labor Arbiter Roque de Guzman rendered a decision ordering JJ's Trucking and Doctor Bernardo Jimenez to pay Pedro Juanatas separation pay of 15,050 pesos plus attorney's fees of ten percent, and dismissed the complaint of Fredelito Juanatas for lack of merit. The private respondents appealed. The National Labor Relations Commission modified the decision: it declared Fredelito an employee sharing in the commission and separation pay, ordered the payment of unpaid commissions totaling 84,387 pesos and five centavos, and reduced the attorney's fees to 8,438 pesos and seventy centavos. The petitioners' motion for reconsideration was denied, so they came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari.
Facts
In December 1987, Pedro and Fredelito Juanatas, father and son, were engaged in Bernardo Jimenez's trucking firm, JJ's Trucking. Pedro worked as driver and mechanic, Fredelito as helper. They were assigned to a ten-wheeler truck hauling soft drinks for Coca-Cola Bottling Company and were paid on commission, initially at seventeen percent and later raised to twenty percent in 1988.
The private respondents claimed that for 1988 and 1989 they received only a partial commission of 84,000 pesos out of gross income of almost one million pesos, leaving an unpaid balance, and that their services were illegally terminated in March 1990. The petitioners countered that Fredelito was never an employee but merely his father's helper, that all commissions had been paid, and that the truck had been sold in 1991, so there was no illegal dismissal.
The labor arbiter found for Pedro but dismissed Fredelito's complaint. On appeal, the Commission ruled that the commissions were not fully paid and that Fredelito was an employee. Hence this petition, raising two questions: whether the commissions were paid in full, and whether Fredelito was an employee of the trucking firm.
Issues
- Whether or not the National Labor Relations Commission committed grave abuse of discretion in ruling that the private respondents were not paid their commissions in full.
- Whether or not the National Labor Relations Commission committed grave abuse of discretion in ruling that Fredelito Juanatas was an employee of JJ's Trucking.
Applicable Provisions
Article 281 of the Labor Code, which the Commission invoked, provides:
An employee who is allowed to work after a probationary period shall be considered a regular employee.
The Court held that this provision speaks only to the regularization of a probationary employee and does not supply the basic factors that must underlie every employer-employee relationship.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court found no reason to disturb the Commission's finding that the commissions were not fully paid. The petitioners asserted payment, and the Court held that one who pleads payment bears the burden of proving it. The debtor must show with legal certainty that the obligation has been discharged. The petitioners' bare denial, unsupported by documents, was insufficient, and the notebook of alleged cash advances was inadmissible because it was undated, unsigned, and uncertain as to origin and authenticity. For failure to prove payment, the petitioners defaulted in their defense and in effect admitted the allegations.
On the second issue, the Court agreed with the petitioners. In determining the existence of an employer-employee relationship, the elements generally considered are the selection and engagement of the employee, the payment of wages, the power of dismissal, and the power to control the employee's conduct, with the control test assuming primacy. Here the agreement was between JJ's Trucking and Pedro Juanatas. The hiring of a helper was discretionary on Pedro, who would be responsible for the helper's compensation, and Pedro was entitled to the same commission with or without a helper. Fredelito was hired by his father, paid out of his father's commission, and subject to his father's control and supervision, not the petitioners'. The Court also rejected the Commission's reliance on Article 281, since the test is not the necessity or desirability of one's functions but the four elements, the control test being the most important.
Doctrine
First, one who pleads payment has the burden of proving it. The debtor must show with legal certainty that the obligation has been extinguished by payment, and a plaintiff's admission that some payments were made does not shift that burden. Second, the existence of an employer-employee relationship is determined by four elements: the selection and engagement of the employee, the payment of wages, the power of dismissal, and the power to control the employee's conduct, with the control test assuming primacy. Article 281 of the Labor Code does not define these elements; it only regularizes a probationary employee.
Disposition
The Court affirmed the judgment of the National Labor Relations Commission with the modification that the paragraph declaring Fredelito Juanatas an employee entitled to share in the award was deleted.
Remember This
Memorize this line: one who pleads payment has the burden of proving it, and the control test is the most important element of an employer-employee relationship. Examiners use this case in labor law on the four elements of employment and in evidence on the burden of proving payment.