🎧 Case Brief Lecture

FILINVEST CREDIT CORPORATION, PETITIONER, VS. HON. COURT OF APPEALS AND SPOUSES EDILBERTO AND MARCIANA TADIAMAN, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 115902. September 27, 1995 September 27, 1995

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Filinvest Credit Corporation versus Spouses Tadiaman

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Filinvest Credit Corporation against the spouses Edilberto and Marciana Tadiaman. Filinvest seeks to set aside the decision of the Court of Appeals which affirmed in full the judgment of the trial court on the spouses' counterclaim for damages. The case began as an action for replevin filed by Filinvest to recover a mortgaged cargo truck after the spouses defaulted on their promissory note. It matters to a reviewee because the Supreme Court draws a bright line between the right to seize and the manner of seizing: a mortgagee may be entitled to possession, yet still be liable in damages for taking the property through subterfuge, concealment, and bad faith.

Procedural History

Filinvest filed a complaint for replevin and damages against the spouses Tadiaman before the Regional Trial Court of San Fernando, Pampanga, Branch 46. After trial, that court rendered judgment on the main action in favor of Filinvest, ordering the spouses to pay the balance of the promissory note with interest, attorney's fees, and costs. On the counterclaim, however, the trial court ruled in favor of the spouses and ordered Filinvest to pay actual damages, moral damages, exemplary damages, attorney's fees, and a proportionate part of the costs.

Filinvest appealed only that portion of the judgment on the counterclaim to the Court of Appeals. In its decision of 26 May 1994, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court in full, finding no merit in the appeal. Filinvest then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari. The Supreme Court gave due course to the petition and required the parties to submit their memoranda.

Facts

The spouses Edilberto and Marciana Tadiaman, residents of Cabanatuan City, purchased a ten wheeler Isuzu cargo truck from Jordan Enterprises, Incorporated, in Quezon City, on installments. They executed a promissory note for 196,680 pesos payable in twenty four monthly installments, and a chattel mortgage over the truck to secure that note. Jordan Enterprises assigned its rights to Filinvest Finance and Leasing Corporation, which in turn assigned them to Filinvest Credit Corporation.

The spouses later defaulted on the installments, and Filinvest filed an action for replevin and damages. On Filinvest's motion, a writ of replevin was issued, and the truck was seized in the province of Isabela by persons who represented themselves as special sheriffs of the court but who turned out to be employees of Filinvest. These persons brought the truck all the way back to Metro Manila.

The spouses filed a counterbond, and the trial court ordered the return of the truck. That order was not immediately carried out because the spouses met delaying tactics from Filinvest. When they finally recovered the truck, they found it cannibalized. The deputy sheriff's report recounted how the truck was hidden in a compound, how Filinvest personnel insisted they did not know its whereabouts, and how missing parts had been replaced with worn out ones. The spouses then pressed their counterclaim for damages.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals committed reversible error in dismissing Filinvest's appeal from the trial court's decision on the spouses' counterclaim and in affirming that decision in full.
  • Whether or not Filinvest is liable for damages for the manner in which it carried out the seizure of the mortgaged truck.
  • Whether or not the awards of actual, moral, and exemplary damages and attorney's fees are proper.

Applicable Provisions

Section 3 of Rule 60 of the Rules of Court provides:

Sec. 3. Order. — Upon the filing of such affidavit and bond with the clerk or judge of the court in which the action is pending, the judge of such court shall issue an order describing the personal property alleged to be wrongfully detained, and requiring the sheriff or other proper officer of the court forthwith to take such property into his custody.

This fixes who may enforce a writ of replevin, namely the sheriff or other proper officer of the court, and not the litigant's own employees.

Section 4 of Rule 60 of the Rules of Court provides:

Sec. 4. Duty of the officer. — Upon receiving such order the officer must serve a copy thereof on the defendant together with a copy of the application, affidavit and bond, and must forthwith take the property, if it be in the possession of the defendant or his agent, and retain it in his custody.

This confirms that the taking must be done by the officer himself, which Filinvest circumvented by using its own people.

Section 2 of Rule 60 of the Rules of Court provides:

SEC. 2. Affidavit and bond. — Upon applying for such order the plaintiff must show ... (a) That the plaintiff is the owner of the property claimed, particularly describing it, or is entitled to the possession thereof.

This answers the trial court's error, since a mortgagee entitled to possession, and not only the owner, may institute replevin.

Article 19 of the Civil Code provides:

Every person must, in the exercise of his rights and in the performance of his duties, act with justice, give everyone his due, and observe honesty and good faith.

This is the standard Filinvest violated when it seized the truck through misrepresentation and concealed and stripped it.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the Court of Appeals committed no reversible error. Filinvest's first ground was baseless because its petition never disclosed what the decision of Branch 9 of the Regional Trial Court of Manila was about. The fourth ground failed because the unappealed portion of the trial court's decision did in fact order the spouses to pay the unpaid balance of the promissory note with interest and attorney's fees. All the other grounds were deemed waived for not having been raised in the appeal to the Court of Appeals.

On the second issue, the Court ruled that Filinvest is liable for damages not because it commenced replevin, but because of the manner it carried out the seizure. It asked the trial court to appoint a special sheriff, yet used its own employees who misrepresented themselves as deputy sheriffs. Filinvest invoked the statement in Bachrach Motor Company versus Summers that the mortgagee must act in an orderly manner and without breach of the peace, but the Court found this misplaced, since Bachrach itself held that where the debtor refuses to yield the property, the creditor must bring an action and cannot lawfully take the property by force against the will of the debtor. By filing replevin, Filinvest admitted it could not acquire possession in an orderly or peaceful manner, and it should have left enforcement of the writ to the proper officer.

On the third issue, the Court ruled that Filinvest committed bad faith in violation of Article 19 of the Civil Code. On actual damages, since Filinvest itself admitted that only 33,222 pesos, and not 50,000 pesos, was spent for the lost spare parts, it may be held liable only for that amount. On moral damages, the Court agreed with the trial court that Filinvest's acts fell within Articles 19 and 21 of the Civil Code, and that moral damages may be recovered under Article 2219 for acts referred to in Article 21. The prayer for nominal damages could no longer be granted because the spouses did not appeal its omission. The award of exemplary damages was in order.

Doctrine

A mortgagee who is entitled to possession after default must still respect the procedure for seizure. The right to possession does not authorize taking the law into one's own hands, and the creditor cannot do through a public officer what he cannot do himself. A writ of replevin must be enforced by the sheriff or other proper officer of the court, never by the litigant's own employees posing as officers. A party that resorts to subterfuge, concealment, and cannibalization of the mortgaged property acts in bad faith and violates Article 19 of the Civil Code, which requires every person to act with justice, give everyone his due, and observe honesty and good faith. Actual damages are limited to the amount proved, while moral damages lie under Article 2219 for acts referred to in Article 21.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the petition and affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeals, with the modification that the actual damages awarded to the spouses be reduced to 33,222 pesos.

Remember This

The one line to memorize is that a mortgagee entitled to possession may not seize the property through force or subterfuge, for the right to possess is not a license to take the law into one's own hands. Examiners use this case to test the interplay of replevin under Rule 60, the extent of a mortgagee's right after default, and liability for bad faith under Article 19 of the Civil Code.