🎧 Case Brief Lecture

ISABELO DE LOS REYES, PETITIONER, VS. FELIX M. ROXAS, JUDGE OF THE COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE OF RIZAL, RESPONDENT.

G.R. No. 1156. January 05, 1903 January 5, 1903

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Isabelo de los Reyes versus Judge Felix M. Roxas

The Case

This is a petition for the writ of certiorari filed by Isabelo de los Reyes against Felix M. Roxas, the judge of the Court of First Instance of Rizal. The petitioner asks the Supreme Court to correct, by the extraordinary writ of certiorari, what he claims was the respondent judge's refusal to hear the witnesses for the defense in the case in which the petitioner had been convicted. The case matters because it draws the classic line between an error committed within jurisdiction, which certiorari does not reach, and an act done without or in excess of jurisdiction, which it does. It is an early and enduring statement of the scope of the writ.

Procedural History

The petitioner had been convicted by the court presided over by the respondent judge. Seeking relief, the petitioner came to the Supreme Court by a petition for certiorari against the judge himself. The petition did not pass through an intermediate appellate court. The Supreme Court, speaking through Justice Willard, resolved the petition directly and denied it.

Facts

The petitioner, Isabelo de los Reyes, was convicted by the court over which the respondent, Felix M. Roxas, presided as judge of the Court of First Instance of Rizal.

According to the petition, the judge, in the course of the trial, refused to hear the witnesses for the defendant. The petition did not allege that the court which convicted the petitioner lacked jurisdiction to try the case. Neither did it allege any affirmative action by the judge outside of his jurisdiction. It alleged only a failure to act, a refusal to hear the defense witnesses.

On these allegations the petitioner sought the writ of certiorari from the Supreme Court.

Issues

  • Whether or not the remedy of certiorari lies to correct a judge's refusal to hear the witnesses for the defendant during a trial over which the court had jurisdiction.
  • Whether or not the failure of a judge to take action, as distinguished from affirmative action outside of his jurisdiction, constitutes an error correctible by certiorari.

Applicable Provisions

The decision does not quote any statutory provision. Its ruling rests on the settled scope of the extraordinary remedy of certiorari, which the Court states in the decision itself:

The remedy by certiorari does not apply to this case.

This statement bears on the case because it fixes the boundary of the writ: certiorari corrects acts done without or in excess of jurisdiction, not errors committed by a judge in the exercise of a jurisdiction he possesses.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that certiorari does not lie. The complaint does not allege that the court which convicted the petitioner had no jurisdiction to try the case. Neither does it allege any affirmative action by the judge outside of his jurisdiction. What it alleges is a failure to take action, a refusal to hear the witnesses for the defendant.

On the second issue, the Court held that such a refusal, if true, would constitute error, but it would be error committed by the judge in the exercise of a jurisdiction which he possessed. The Court put the distinction plainly:

This, if true, would constitute error, but it would be error committed by the judge in the exercise of a jurisdiction which he possessed.

Because the error, if any, was committed within jurisdiction, the remedy by certiorari does not apply. The petition was denied.

Doctrine

Certiorari is an extraordinary remedy that reaches only acts done without or in excess of jurisdiction. It does not correct errors committed by a judge in the exercise of a jurisdiction he possesses. A judge's refusal to hear the witnesses for the defendant, if true, is error, but it is error within jurisdiction, reviewable by appeal and not by certiorari. The writ does not lie where the petition alleges only a failure to act, and not affirmative action outside of jurisdiction.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the petition for certiorari, and the respondent judge prevailed.

Remember This

The line to memorize: error within jurisdiction is not correctible by certiorari, only acts without or in excess of jurisdiction are. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between a judge's erroneous refusal to act within a case he may try and an act done outside his jurisdiction.