CATALINO SAN PEDRO, AND SPS. PEDIE & CECILIA GUANZON SURNAMED LORESTO, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, RTC JUDGE OF KALOOKAN CITY, DEPUTY SHERIFF VIRGILIO A. SORIANO & WILLIA…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
San Pedro versus Court of Appeals
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari with prohibition and preliminary injunction filed by Catalino San Pedro and the spouses Pedie and Cecilia Loresto against the Court of Appeals, the Regional Trial Court judge of Kalookan City, the deputy sheriff, and private respondent William Ledesma. The petitioners ask the Supreme Court to stop the immediate execution of a judgment in an unlawful detainer case, arguing that a separate suit for annulment of the respondent's title should first be resolved. The case matters because it settles, in one compact ruling, two rules every Bar candidate must carry into the examination room: the mandatory nature of the periodic deposit on appeal in ejectment cases, and the rule that a suit questioning ownership does not abate an ejectment action.
Procedural History
William Ledesma filed a complaint for unlawful detainer with preliminary injunction before the Metropolitan Trial Court of Kalookan City against the spouses Pedie and Cecilia Loresto. The trial court rendered judgment against the Lorestos, ordering them to vacate the premises, to pay reasonable compensation for its use and occupation, and to pay attorney's fees and costs. The spouses appealed to the Regional Trial Court of Kalookan City. Meanwhile, the Lorestos, together with Catalino San Pedro, filed a separate action for annulment of Ledesma's title before Branch 125 of the Regional Trial Court of Kalookan City. Because the spouses failed to make the periodic deposits fixed in the appealed decision, Ledesma moved for execution pending appeal; the motion was granted, and a writ of execution and notice to vacate were issued. The petitioners then went to the Court of Appeals on a petition for certiorari, mandamus and prohibition, which was denied; their motion for reconsideration was likewise denied. They then came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari with prohibition and preliminary injunction.
Facts
On the thirteenth of January, 1993, William Ledesma filed a complaint for unlawful detainer against the spouses Loresto over premises in Kalookan City. On the fourteenth of May, 1993, the Metropolitan Trial Court rendered judgment ordering the spouses to vacate and surrender possession of the premises, to pay twelve thousand pesos monthly as reasonable compensation for its use and occupation from the sixth of September, 1992, until actual surrender, and to pay five thousand pesos in attorney's fees and one hundred sixty-six pesos in costs.
The spouses appealed to the Regional Trial Court. In the meantime, the Lorestos and Catalino San Pedro instituted an action for annulment of Ledesma's title, claiming that the property had already been titled in the name of Don Mariano San Pedro and had been in the possession of San Pedro's predecessors since 1900.
On the fourteenth of September, 1993, Ledesma moved for execution pending appeal, citing the spouses' failure to make the periodic deposits of twelve thousand pesos as reasonable value of the use of the premises. The motion was granted, and a writ of execution and notice to vacate were issued. The Court of Appeals denied the petitioners' petition, and denied their motion for reconsideration, bringing them to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court may order execution pending appeal of a judgment in an ejectment case where the defendant spouses failed to make the periodic deposits of the reasonable compensation for the use of the property.
- Whether or not the pendency of an action for annulment of title over the same property abates the ejectment suit or bars the execution of the judgment therein.
- Whether or not the Supreme Court, in a petition for certiorari, may rule on the petitioners' claims of ownership and on the alleged falsity of the private respondent's title.
Applicable Provisions
Section 8 of Rule 70 of the Rules of Court, as cited in the decision, provides:
If the judgment is rendered against the defendant, the same shall be immediately executory, and the defendant may stay the execution thereof by perfecting an appeal, filing a supersedeas bond, and making a periodic deposit of the rental or reasonable compensation for the use and occupation of the property during the pendency of the appeal.
This provision supplies the three requisites that must concur to stay execution, and its mandatory character is the basis for the Court's ruling that execution issues as a matter of right upon noncompliance.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that judgments in ejectment cases favorable to the plaintiff are immediately executory and may be stayed only by the concurrence of three acts: perfecting an appeal, filing a supersedeas bond, and making a periodic deposit of the rental or reasonable compensation during the pendency of the appeal. The Court stressed that the deposit, like the supersedeas bond, is a mandatory requirement; if it is not complied with, execution will issue as a matter of right. The only exceptions are fraud, accident, mistake or excusable negligence preventing the deposit, or supervening events materially changing the situation of the parties and making execution inequitable. Since the spouses did not deny failing to make the monthly deposits and did not invoke any exception, the trial court merely complied with its ministerial duty, and the Court of Appeals committed no grave abuse of discretion.
On the second issue, the Court held that the pendency of an action questioning ownership does not abate an ejectment suit or bar execution of the judgment therein. The rationale is that an ejectment suit involves only material possession, or possession de facto, while an action for annulment of title involves ownership; there may be identity of parties and subject matter, but not of the cause of action or the relief prayed for. The Court listed the settled instances, among them injunction suits, accion publiciana, quieting of title, reconveyance, and suits for annulment of sale, title, or document, all of which do not abate ejectment actions.
On the third issue, the Court refused to pass upon the claims of ownership and the alleged falsity of the title, holding that these are factual matters to be threshed out in the annulment suit pending before Branch 125. It likewise held that the question of whether unlawful detainer was the proper remedy should be addressed in the pending appeal before the Regional Trial Court, not in the certiorari proceeding.
Doctrine
First, a judgment in an ejectment case favorable to the plaintiff is immediately executory; to stay it, the defendant must perfect an appeal, file a supersedeas bond, and make a periodic deposit of the rental or reasonable compensation. These requisites must concur, and the deposit is mandatory, so that noncompliance entitles the plaintiff to execution as a matter of right, subject only to the exceptions of fraud, accident, mistake or excusable negligence, or supervening events making execution inequitable.
Second, the pendency of an action questioning ownership, such as an annulment of title, does not abate an ejectment suit or bar execution of the judgment therein, because ejectment concerns only material possession while the annulment suit concerns ownership.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the petition for lack of merit, with costs against the petitioners, thereby sustaining the execution of the judgment in the ejectment case.
Remember This
Memorize the three concurring requisites to stay execution in ejectment, and the rule that the periodic deposit is mandatory so that execution issues as a matter of right. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between material possession in ejectment and ownership in an annulment suit, and the limits of a certiorari petition.