🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. LOMA GOCE Y OLALIA, DAN GOCE AND NELLY D. AGUSTIN, ACCUSED.  NELLY D. AGUSTIN, ACCUSED-APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 113161. August 29, 1995 August 29, 1995

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

People versus Agustin

The Case

This is a criminal appeal by Nelly Agustin, who was convicted by the Regional Trial Court of Manila of illegal recruitment committed by a syndicate and in large scale under the Labor Code. The prosecution charged that she and the spouses Dan and Loma Goce, representing themselves as having the capacity to send Filipino workers abroad, recruited eight complainants for a fee without any license or authority from the Department of Labor. The case matters because it fixes the outer boundaries of what counts as recruitment and placement — showing that even the seemingly innocent act of introducing applicants to a placement agency can be criminal when done for a fee and without authority.

Procedural History

An information for illegal recruitment by a syndicate and in large scale was filed in January 1988 before the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 5, against the Goce spouses and Nelly Agustin. A warrant of arrest was issued in January 1987, but none of the accused was arrested, so in February 1989 the trial court ordered the case archived while keeping a standing warrant. Agustin was finally apprehended by the Parañaque police in February 1993. Her counsel moved to revive the case, the trial court reinstated it in April 1993, and Agustin pleaded not guilty at her arraignment in May 1993. After trial, the court rendered judgment in November 1993 finding her guilty as a principal and sentencing her to life imprisonment and a fine of 100,000 pesos. She appealed directly to the Supreme Court.

Facts

Sometime in March or April 1987, Rogelio Salado was introduced by his brother-in-law Lorenzo Alvarez to Nelly Agustin at her residence in Parañaque. Agustin presented herself as the manager of the Clover Placement Agency and showed a job order as proof that he could be deployed abroad. He paid 5,000 pesos as a processing fee and was issued a receipt. Later, at the agency's office in Ermita, Manila, he met the Goce spouses, the owners, and was told by Loma Goce that the placement fee was actually 12,000 pesos. A receipt was issued in the name of the agency showing only 2,000 pesos paid per applicant, although each had actually paid 5,000 pesos.

Ramona Salado was persuaded by Agustin to apply as a cutter or sewer in Oman, on the promise that she and her husband could live together while working there, and the couple paid 4,000 pesos as placement fees, plus 2,000 pesos for passports. Dionisio Masaya applied with the agency, met Agustin who introduced herself as its manager, and paid 1,900 pesos in May 1986 and 10,000 pesos in September 1986. Ernesto Alvarez met Agustin in February 1987, was offered a job as an ambulance driver in Oman at a monthly salary of about 600 to 700 dollars, and paid 3,000 pesos twice as processing fees. Several months passed, but none of the complainants left for abroad. In October 1987 they went to the Philippine Overseas Employment Administration and discovered that the Clover Placement Agency was not licensed to recruit. When they demanded refunds, Agustin returned only 500 pesos to Salado and 500 pesos to Alvarez.

Only Agustin testified for the defense. She claimed she was merely a neighbor of the Goce spouses, that they were licensed recruiters who had previously sent her son to Saudi Arabia, and that she merely introduced the complainants to them upon the request of Lorenzo Alvarez. She denied any participation in the recruitment and any knowledge of the receipts, and explained that the 500 pesos she gave Salado and Alvarez were a loan and financial help, respectively.

Issues

  • Whether or not the act of introducing complainants to the Goce couple falls within the meaning of illegal recruitment and placement under the Labor Code.
  • Whether or not there is proof of conspiracy to commit illegal recruitment among Agustin and the Goce spouses.
  • Whether or not there is proof that Agustin offered or promised overseas employment to the complainants.

Applicable Provisions

Article 13(b) of the Labor Code defines recruitment and placement:

Recruitment and placement refers to any act of canvassing, enlisting, contracting, transporting, utilizing, hiring or procuring workers, and includes referrals, contract services, promising or advertising for employment, locally or abroad, whether for profit or not; provided, that any person or entity which, in any manner, offers or promises for a fee employment to two or more persons shall be deemed engaged in recruitment and placement.

This definition is the measure of the offense, because it shows that referrals and promises of employment for a fee are themselves recruitment activities.

Article 38 of the Labor Code, as amended by Presidential Decree No. 2018, makes recruitment by non-licensees illegal and defines the qualifying circumstances:

Any recruitment activity, including the prohibited practices enumerated in Article 34 of this Code, undertaken by non-licensees or non-holders of authority shall be deemed illegal and punishable under Article 39 hereof.

This provision supplies the very prohibition violated by Agustin, who was neither licensed nor authorized to recruit.

Section 4 of Rule 130 of the Rules of Court governs the presentation of the lost receipts:

When the original writing has been lost or destroyed or cannot be produced in court, upon proof of its execution and loss or destruction, or unavailability, its contents may be proved by a copy or a recital of its contents in some authentic document, or by the recollection of witnesses.

This rule allowed the prosecution to prove the contents of the lost receipts through xerox copies.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that Agustin did not merely introduce the complainants to the Goce couple. All four prosecution witnesses testified that it was Agustin whom they first approached about working overseas, that it was from her that they learned the fees and the papers required, and that they met the Goce spouses only after talking to her. As an employee of the Goces, she was in fact making referrals to the agency of which she was a part, and was therefore engaging in recruitment activity. The Court stressed that there is illegal recruitment when one gives the impression of having the ability to send a worker abroad, and that her act of collecting payments for passports, training, placement, medical tests and other expenses unquestionably constituted recruitment within the meaning of the law.

On the second issue, the Court found that the evidence clearly established that Agustin confabulated with the Goces in their plan to deceive the complainants. Citing its ruling in People versus Sendon, the Court held that the non-prosecution of the other suspects furnished no ground to fault the trial court's decision convicting her, since the prosecution of persons equally or more culpable may come later after their identities and addresses are ascertained and they are taken into custody.

On the third issue, the Court found that Agustin gave the complainants the distinct impression that she had the power or ability to send people abroad for work, such that they were convinced to give her the money she demanded. Their positive and affirmative testimonies were more worthy of credit than her uncorroborated and self-serving denials. Even assuming the xerox copies of the receipts were inadmissible as secondary evidence, the Court held that their absence did not warrant acquittal, because the complainants duly proved through their testimonies that she was involved in the entire recruitment process.

Doctrine

Recruitment and placement under Article 13(b) of the Labor Code is broad: it includes referrals, and any person who in any manner offers or promises employment for a fee to two or more persons is deemed engaged in recruitment. A person who gives the impression of having the ability to send a worker abroad engages in illegal recruitment when she is not licensed or authorized to do so. One who refers applicants to a placement agency of which she is a part, and who collects fees for passports, training, placement and medical tests, performs acts of recruitment and not a mere act of introduction. Conspiracy may be established by the concerted acts of the accused, and the non-prosecution or non-conviction of a co-conspirator does not bar the conviction of the accused who is proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt.

Disposition

The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the trial court in its entirety, finding Nelly Agustin guilty of illegal recruitment in large scale and sentencing her to life imprisonment and a fine of 100,000 pesos, with costs against her.

Remember This

The single line to memorize is that there is illegal recruitment when one gives the impression of having the ability to send a worker abroad, for a fee, without a license. Examiners like to use this case to test whether a mere "introducer" or "referrer" can be convicted of illegal recruitment, and to test the rule that the non-prosecution of a co-conspirator does not prevent the conviction of the accused.