🎧 Case Brief Lecture

WILMAR P. LUCERO, PETITIONER, VS. COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS AND JOSE L. ONG, JR., RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 113107. July 20, 1994 July 20, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Lucero versus Commission on Elections

The Case

This is the case of Lucero versus the Commission on Elections and Ong, a special civil action for certiorari decided by the Supreme Court in July 1994. Wilmar Lucero and Jose Ong were rival candidates for the congressional seat of the Second Legislative District of Northern Samar in the synchronized elections of May 1992. After a long and tangled pre-proclamation controversy, the Commission on Elections en banc issued a resolution directing the provincial board of canvassers to include certain questioned returns in the canvass and to call a special election in one precinct. Both candidates came to the Supreme Court to challenge that resolution. The case matters because it fixes the order of operations in a failure-of-election situation: the votes that were actually counted must first be canvassed, and only then may the Commission determine whether the failure in another precinct would affect the result and so justify a special election.

Procedural History

The controversy began before the Commission on Elections in a pre-proclamation case filed by Lucero, in which he asked that the provincial board of canvassers be ordered to suspend the proclamation of Ong, to correct the certificate of canvass for Las Navas, to hold a special election in Precinct No. 13, and to recount the votes in several precincts. The Commission en banc issued a resolution ordering the ballot boxes of two precincts brought before it, and a recount of one precinct was in fact conducted by a special board of election inspectors.

Ong then filed a special civil action for certiorari with the Supreme Court, which issued a temporary restraining order and later rendered a decision granting the petition, nullifying the Commission's orders and directing the provincial board of canvassers to proceed with dispatch and proclaim the winner. On reconsideration, the Supreme Court modified that judgment, annulling the Commission's orders in part but affirming them as to the holding of a special election in Precinct No. 13 and the recount of the ballots in Precinct No. 16, and directing the Commission to assign the case to one of its divisions to resolve the pre-proclamation issues.

The case was raffled to the First Division of the Commission, which heard the parties but could not obtain the concurrence of at least two of its members. The case was therefore elevated to the Commission en banc, which promulgated a new resolution in January 1994. Both Lucero and Ong then came to the Supreme Court by separate special civil actions for certiorari, which the Court consolidated and decided on the merits.

Facts

In the May 1992 elections, five candidates vied for the congressional seat of the Second Legislative District of Northern Samar. The provincial board of canvassers credited Ong with 24,272 votes and Lucero with 24,068 votes, a lead of 204 votes for Ong. That tally, however, did not include the results of three precincts of the municipality of Silvino Lobos: Precinct No. 7, whose submitted returns were illegible; Precinct No. 13, where the ballot boxes were snatched and no election was held; and Precinct No. 16, where all copies of the election returns were missing.

Lucero asked the Commission on Elections to suspend Ong's proclamation, to correct the certificate of canvass for Las Navas, to call a special election in Precinct No. 13, and to recount the votes in the affected precincts. The Commission directed the provincial board to desist from reconvening, and later ordered the ballot boxes of Precincts No. 7 and 16 brought before it. A recount in Precinct No. 16 recorded 43 votes for Lucero and 2 votes for Ong. Ong challenged these orders before the Supreme Court, which nullified them and directed the board to complete the canvass and proclaim the winner.

On reconsideration, the Supreme Court modified its judgment. It affirmed the holding of a special election in Precinct No. 13 and the recount of the ballots in Precinct No. 16, and it expressly ruled that the correction of the manifest error in the certificate of canvass of Las Navas was in order under Section 15 of Republic Act No. 7166. The Commission en banc then issued the resolution of January 1994 that gave rise to these consolidated petitions. That resolution directed the provincial board to include in the canvass the votes reflected in the so-called Commission copy of the returns of Precinct No. 7, to correct the Las Navas totals, and to call a special election in Precinct No. 13, leaving the question of a recount in Precinct No. 7 to be decided only after that special election.

Issues

  • Whether or not there should first be a count of the ballots of Precinct No. 7 of Silvino Lobos before determining the necessity of holding a special election in Precinct No. 13 of Silvino Lobos.
  • Whether or not the Commission on Elections acted with grave abuse of discretion in ordering the correction of the alleged manifest error in the municipal certificate of canvass of Las Navas.
  • Whether or not the Commission on Elections acted with grave abuse of discretion in calling for a special election in Precinct No. 13 almost two years after the synchronized elections.

Applicable Provisions

Section 6 of the Omnibus Election Code provides:

Section 6. Failure of election. -- If, on account of force majeure, violence, terrorism, fraud, or other analogous causes the election in any polling place has not been held on the date fixed, or had been suspended before the hour fixed by law for the closing of the voting, or after the voting and during the preparation and the transmission of the election returns or in the custody or canvass thereof, such election results in a failure to elect, and if in any of such cases the failure or suspension of election would affect the result of the election, the Commission shall, on the basis of a verified petition by any interested party and after due notice and hearing, call for the holding or continuation of the election not held, suspended or which resulted in a failure to elect on a date reasonably close to the date of the election not held, suspended or which resulted in a failure to elect but not later than thirty days after the cessation of the cause of such postponement or suspension of the election or failure to elect.

This provision supplies the two requisites for a special election: a failure of election, and a failure that would affect the result of the election.

The first paragraph of Section 4 of Republic Act No. 7166 provides:

Section 4. Postponement, Failure of Election and Special Elections. -- The postponement, declaration of failure of election and the calling of special elections as provided in Sections 5, 6 and 7 of the Omnibus Election Code shall be decided by the Commission sitting en banc by a majority votes of its members. The causes for the declaration of a failure of election my occur before or after the casting of votes or on the day of the election.

This provision confirms that the power to declare a failure of election and to call a special election belongs to the Commission sitting en banc.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court answered in the affirmative. It found the Commission's disposition on Precinct No. 7 unclear and illogical. The Commission itself doubted the authenticity of the so-called Commission copy of the returns of Precinct No. 7, yet it ordered that copy included in the canvass while postponing any recount. The Court held that the Commission could not, without arbitrariness and abuse of discretion, give faith to returns it doubted. More fundamentally, the evidence showed that there was no counting of votes in Precinct No. 7 at all: the election returns were prepared at the municipal building and not at the polling place, contrary to law. The Court held that since there was no counting, no valid election returns could be made, and any copy purporting to come from that precinct is a fabrication. A recount, which presupposes a prior count, would therefore be unwarranted. The Court then explained the logic of the special election in Precinct No. 13:

This result of the election means the net result of the election in the rest of the precincts in a given constituency, such that if the margin of a leading candidate over that of his closest rival in the latter precincts is less than the total number of votes in the precinct where there was failure of election, then such failure would certainly affect the result of the election; hence, a special election must be held.

Consequently, the holding of a special election in Precinct No. 13 could be determined only after the votes in Precinct No. 7 shall have been counted and included in the canvass.

On the second issue, the Court held that Ong's grievance was without merit. The order correcting the manifest error in the Las Navas certificate of canvass was made pursuant to the Court's own declaration in the earlier case, which had become final and was entered in judgment. Ong could not relitigate that issue.

On the third issue, the Court held that the Commission did not gravely abuse its discretion. The parties admitted that the failure of election in Precinct No. 13 was due to ballot-box snatching, and they did not dispute the necessity of a special election there. Applying the two requisites of Section 6, the Court noted that the margin of Ong over Lucero, after the additional votes were credited, was 143, which was less than the 213 registered voters in Precinct No. 13. The failure of election would therefore affect the result, and a special election was properly called.

Doctrine

A special election under Section 6 of the Omnibus Election Code requires two requisites: first, that there is a failure of election, and second, that such failure would affect the result of the election. The result of the election means the net result in the rest of the precincts of the constituency; if the margin of the leading candidate over the closest rival is less than the total number of votes in the precinct where the failure occurred, the failure affects the result and a special election must be held.

Where no counting of votes was actually held at the polling place, no valid election returns can be made, and any copy purporting to come from that precinct is a fabrication. A recount presupposes a prior count; without a count, a recount is unwarranted, and the questioned returns cannot be included in the canvass. The count of the votes of a precinct where an election was actually held must precede the determination of whether a special election is needed in a precinct where no election was held.

A final and executory judgment may not be relitigated; a party who failed to move for reconsideration is bound by the entry of judgment.

Disposition

The Supreme Court granted the petitions in part, set aside the challenged resolution insofar as it directed the inclusion of the questioned returns of Precinct No. 7 and the holding of a special election in Precinct No. 13 before a count of those votes, and directed the Commission on Elections to proceed in accordance with the Court's ruling.

Remember This

Memorize this line: a special election requires a failure of election that would affect the result, and the result is measured by comparing the winning margin against the total votes in the failed precinct. Examiners use this case to test the order of operations in pre-proclamation controversies and the rule that a recount presupposes a valid count.