PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. ARMANDO RODRIGUEZ CAMAT AND WILFREDO TANYAG DEL ROSARIO, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
People versus Camat
The Case
This is a criminal appeal in which the People of the Philippines prosecuted Armando Rodriguez Camat and Wilfredo Tanyag del Rosario for a robbery on a Paranaque street that ended in the death of one man and the near death of another. The trial court convicted both of the special complex crime of robbery with homicide and frustrated homicide. The case matters for three reasons a reviewee should hold onto: it is a clean illustration of the constitutional exclusion of uncounselled confessions made during custodial investigation, it shows that a conviction may stand on the testimony of a single credible eyewitness even after the confessions are thrown out, and it corrects the designation of the offense, reminding us that there is no such crime as robbery with homicide and frustrated homicide.
Procedural History
An information for robbery with homicide and frustrated homicide was filed against both accused in the Regional Trial Court sitting in Makati, Branch 147, and each pleaded not guilty at arraignment. After hearing, the trial court rendered judgment in June 1987, finding both guilty beyond reasonable doubt, imposing reclusion perpetua, and ordering them to indemnify the heirs of Nelson Sinoy in the amount of 30,000 pesos and Gonzalo Penalver in the amount of 10,000 pesos. Both accused appealed to the Supreme Court, assigning a single error: that the trial court gravely erred in finding them guilty beyond reasonable doubt. The Supreme Court decided the appeal in April 1996.
Facts
About nine o'clock in the evening of September 1, 1985, two Philippine Marines in civilian clothes, Nelson Sinoy and Gonzalo Penalver, were walking along Quirino Avenue in Paranaque after attending a birthday party at Camp Claudio. Penalver carried a clutch bag containing a Sanwa electric tester. They noticed two men trailing them about ten meters behind, crossed the street to avoid them, but the two followed.
Wilfredo del Rosario rushed at Sinoy and kicked him. Armando Camat followed, drew a knife, and stabbed Sinoy. When Penalver kicked Camat, Camat stabbed him at the right rib; Penalver lost his balance, and del Rosario grabbed the clutch bag. The two victims ran away and, with the help of a man who identified himself as a policeman, were brought to the San Juan de Dios Hospital. Sinoy died despite surgery and blood transfusion. Penalver's wound was sutured and he was later transferred to the AFP Medical Center, where he received blood transfusion and was discharged only in March 1986.
Both accused raised alibi. Camat claimed he was at home in Baclaran by early evening, corroborated by his mother-in-law; del Rosario claimed he had been selling vegetables and went home at seven o'clock, corroborated by his mother. Both said they did not know each other before their arrest. Patrolman Odeo Cariño testified that Camat orally admitted participation and named del Rosario and a certain Roland, and that del Rosario in turn confessed and said the electric tester could be recovered from his relatives. Camat was arrested in October 1985 for acts of lasciviousness, and a vendor-witness later identified him at the police station. The vendor was not presented in court.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court erred in relying on the extrajudicial confessions of the accused, obtained during custodial investigation without the assistance of counsel, as basis for conviction.
- Whether or not the implication of del Rosario in Camat's extrajudicial confession may be used against del Rosario.
- Whether or not the conviction may stand on the testimony of a single eyewitness, Gonzalo Penalver.
- Whether or not the failure to present the police informer or vendor-witness violated the accused's right to confrontation.
- Whether or not the defense of alibi should prosper.
- Whether or not the accused were correctly convicted of robbery with homicide and frustrated homicide.
Applicable Provisions
Section 20, Article IV of the 1973 Constitution, then in force, provides:
No person shall be compelled to be a witness against himself. Any person under investigation for the commission of an offense shall have the right to remain silent and to counsel, and to be informed of such right. No force, violence, threat, intimidation, or any other means which vitiates the free will shall be used against him. Any confession obtained in violation of this section shall be inadmissible in evidence.
This is the provision that excludes the confessions of both accused, because the prosecution showed no warning of rights and no counsel.
Section 19, Article IV of the 1973 Constitution provides:
In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall be presumed innocent until the contrary is proven, and shall enjoy the right to be heard by himself and counsel, to be informed of the nature and cause of accusation against him, to have a speedy, impartial and public trial, to meet the witnesses face to face, and to have compulsory process to secure the attendance of witnesses and the production of evidence in his behalf.
This is the right of confrontation invoked by the accused, which the Court limits to proceedings before the trial court.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the trial court could not use the confessions. It is incumbent upon the prosecution to prove that, prior to questioning, the confessant was warned of his constitutionally protected rights, because the presumption of regularity of official acts does not apply during in-custody investigation. Even if the confession is the gospel truth, if it was made without the assistance of counsel it is inadmissible regardless of the absence of coercion or of voluntariness.
On the second issue, the Court held that no reliance may be placed on Camat's imputation against del Rosario. It violates the rule on res inter alios acta, meaning acts of others do not prejudice a stranger, and does not fall under the exceptions, especially since it was made after the supposed conspiracy. An extrajudicial confession is binding only upon the confessant and is hearsay as against his co-accused.
On the third issue, the Court held that even disregarding the confessions, the conviction stands. The testimony of a single eyewitness, if found convincing and trustworthy by the trial court, is sufficient to support a finding of guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Penalver's testimony was categorical, candid, and untainted by inconsistency, the scene was well-lighted, and no improper motive was shown.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that the right to meet witnesses face to face is limited to proceedings before the trial court, from arraignment to rendition of judgment, and is not available during custodial investigation. It was also the accused's own option to call the vendor by compulsory process.
On the fifth issue, the Court held that alibi is one of the weakest defenses, easy of fabrication. It must show not only that the accused was elsewhere but that it was physically impossible for him to be at the scene. Bagong Silang and Sanchez Streets are just a few meters from Quirino Avenue, and alibi is less plausible when established mainly by the accused and his immediate relatives.
On the sixth issue, the Court held that the accused should have been indicted only for the special complex crime of robbery with homicide under Article 294 of the Revised Penal Code. There is no crime of robbery with homicide and frustrated homicide. The term homicide in that article is understood in its generic sense, absorbing all other acts producing anything short of death, assuming death occurs by reason or on the occasion of the robbery, regardless of the number of homicides and physical injuries committed.
Doctrine
First, any confession obtained in violation of Section 20, Article IV of the 1973 Constitution is inadmissible in evidence; the prosecution must prove the warning and the assistance of counsel, and the presumption of regularity does not apply during in-custody investigation. Second, an extrajudicial confession binds only the confessant and is hearsay against his co-accused under the rule on res inter alios acta. Third, the testimony of a single eyewitness, if credible, suffices for conviction beyond reasonable doubt. Fourth, the right of confrontation is a trial right, not a right during custodial investigation. Fifth, alibi requires proof of physical impossibility. Sixth, there is no crime of robbery with homicide and frustrated homicide; the frustrated killing is absorbed in the special complex crime of robbery with homicide under Article 294.
Disposition
The judgment of conviction was affirmed, with the modification that the accused were declared guilty of robbery with homicide and the civil indemnity for the death of Nelson Sinoy was increased to 50,000 pesos.
Remember This
Memorize this line: there is no crime of robbery with homicide and frustrated homicide, because homicide in Article 294 is generic and absorbs all acts short of death. Examiners use this case to test the exclusion of uncounselled confessions, the hearsay nature of a co-accused's confession, and the correct designation of the special complex crime.