🎧 Case Brief Lecture

CENTRAL PHILIPPINE UNIVERSITY, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, REMEDIOS FRANCO, FRANCISCO N. LOPEZ, CECILIA P. VDA. DE LOPEZ, REDAN LOPEZ AND REMARENE LOPEZ, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 112127. July 17, 1995 July 17, 1995

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Central Philippine University versus Court of Appeals

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Central Philippine University against the Court of Appeals and the heirs of the late Don Ramon Lopez, Senior. The University asks the Supreme Court to overturn the appellate decision that reversed the trial court and remanded the case for the fixing of a period. The dispute concerns a parcel of land donated in 1939 on the condition that the donee establish a medical college on it. The case matters because it teaches how the Court classifies an onerous donation, why the burden imposed on the donee is a resolutory condition rather than a suspensive one, and why an action to revoke such a donation does not easily prescribe.

Procedural History

The heirs of Don Ramon Lopez, Senior, filed an action for annulment of donation, reconveyance and damages before the Regional Trial Court of Iloilo City. The trial court ruled in their favor, holding that the University failed to comply with the conditions of the donation, declaring the donation null and void, and directing the University to execute a deed of reconveyance in favor of the heirs.

The University appealed to the Court of Appeals. The appellate court ruled that the annotations on the certificate of title were resolutory conditions, breach of which would terminate the rights of the donee and make the donation revocable. It also found, however, that the donor did not fix a period within which the first condition must be fulfilled, so the University could not yet be considered in default. The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court and remanded the case for the determination of the time within which the University should comply with the first condition.

The University then elevated the matter to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari, assigning as errors the appellate court's holdings on the onerous nature of the donation, on prescription, and on the remand for the fixing of a period.

Facts

Sometime in 1939, Don Ramon Lopez, Senior, then a member of the Board of Trustees of the Central Philippine College, now Central Philippine University, executed a deed of donation in favor of the school. The subject was a parcel of land identified as Lot Number 3174-B-1, and a transfer certificate of title was issued in the name of the donee with annotations copied from the deed of donation. The land was to be used exclusively for the establishment of a medical college with all its buildings as part of the curriculum. The college was not to sell, transfer, or encumber the land. The land was to be called the Ramon Lopez Campus, with a cornerstone bearing that name, and any net income was to go into a fund for the improvement of the campus.

On 31 May 1989, the heirs of the donor filed an action for annulment of donation, reconveyance and damages. They alleged that from 1939 up to the filing of the action, the University had not complied with the conditions of the donation. They also argued that the University had negotiated with the National Housing Authority to exchange the donated property for another land.

The University answered that the action had prescribed, that it never used the property for any purpose other than that intended, and that it never sold, transferred, or conveyed the land to any third party. The trial court nevertheless found non-compliance and annulled the donation. The Court of Appeals reversed and remanded for the fixing of a period, and the case reached the Supreme Court.

Issues

  • Whether or not the annotations in the certificate of title are onerous obligations and resolutory conditions of the donation, non-compliance with which renders the donation revocable.
  • Whether or not the action of the private respondents is barred by prescription.
  • Whether or not the case should be remanded to the trial court for the fixing of the period within which the University should establish the medical college.

Applicable Provisions

Article 1181 of the Civil Code provides:

On conditional obligations, the acquisition of rights, as well as the extinguishment or loss of those already acquired, shall depend upon the happening of the event which constitutes the condition.

This provision governs whether the burden imposed on the donee is a condition precedent or a resolutory condition, and the Court uses it to hold that the donation was valid from the start and that non-compliance extinguishes the donee's rights.

Article 1197 of the Civil Code provides:

If the obligation does not fix a period, but from its nature and circumstances it can be inferred that a period was intended, the courts may fix the duration thereof.

This is the general rule on the fixing of a period, which the Court considers but declines to apply here because more than a reasonable period had already elapsed.

Article 1191 of the Civil Code provides:

The power to rescind obligations is implied in reciprocal ones, in case one of the obligors should not comply with what is incumbent upon him.

The Court invokes this provision to hold that, absent any just cause for fixing a period, rescission may be decreed.

Article 1378 of the Civil Code provides:

In case of doubt, the interpretation of a gratuitous contract shall be resolved in favor of the least transmission of rights and interests.

The Court uses this rule of interpretation to resolve incidental doubts in favor of the donor's heirs.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the donation was onerous, one executed for a valuable consideration equivalent to the donation itself, because the donor imposed on the donee the obligation to establish a medical college on the land. The Court explained that when land is donated on the condition that the donee build a school upon it, the condition is not a condition precedent or suspensive condition but a resolutory one. The donation had to be valid before the condition could be fulfilled, and if the condition is not complied with, the donation may be revoked and all rights acquired under it are lost and extinguished.

On the second issue, the Court held that prescription did not bar the action. The condition depended upon the exclusive will of the donee as to when it would be fulfilled, and the donee's absolute acceptance and acknowledgment of its obligation were sufficient to prevent the statute of limitations from barring the action. The Court also held that the time from which the cause of action accrued could not be specifically determined, since the starting point is the expiration of a reasonable period and opportunity for the donee to comply. The period could not be quantified in a specific number of years because of factors beyond the donee's control, such as government regulations on education, building requirements, and property restrictions.

On the third issue, the Court held that while Article 1197 generally allows the courts to fix the duration of a period, that general rule could not be applied here. More than a reasonable period of fifty years had already been allowed the University to comply, and it failed to do so. Fixing a period would be a mere technicality that would serve no purpose but to delay and multiply suits. Absent any just cause for fixing a period, there was no obstacle to decreeing rescission. The Court also noted that since the deed of donation was basically gratuitous, doubts on incidental circumstances should be resolved in favor of the least transmission of rights and interests.

Doctrine

A donation is onerous when it imposes on the donee a burden equivalent to the value of the donation. When land is donated on the condition that the donee build a school or medical college upon it, the condition is not suspensive but resolutory: the donation is valid from the start, and non-compliance extinguishes the donee's rights and allows revocation. The donee's acceptance of the donation binds it to comply, and where the time for compliance depends on the donee's exclusive will, the statute of limitations does not bar the action to revoke. Under Article 1197 the courts may fix a period, but where more than a reasonable period has already elapsed without compliance, rescission may be decreed under Article 1191 without need of fixing a term.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the petition, reinstated and affirmed the trial court's decision, modified the Court of Appeals decision, and directed the University to reconvey the donated lot to the private respondents within thirty days from the finality of the judgment, with costs against the petitioner.

Remember This

The one line to memorize: a donation burdened with the obligation to build a school is onerous, and the burden is a resolutory condition whose breach revokes the donation. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between suspensive and resolutory conditions in donations, the non-prescription of the action where the period depends on the donee's will, and the interplay of Articles 1181, 1191, and 1197 of the Civil Code.