AIR MATERIAL WING SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION, INC., PETITIONER, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Air Material Wing Savings and Loan Association versus National Labor Relations Commission
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by Air Material Wing Savings and Loan Association against the National Labor Relations Commission and its former notarial and legal counsel, Luis Salas. The association asks the Supreme Court to set aside the Commission's ruling that Salas was its employee and that he was entitled to notarial fees. The case matters because it settles two questions every labor lawyer must know: when a lawyer engaged by a corporation is an employee rather than an independent contractor, and whether a labor arbiter may adjudicate a claim for notarial fees.
Procedural History
Salas filed a complaint before the labor arbiter for separation pay, leave benefits, cost of living allowances, refund of Social Security System premiums, damages, notarial fees, and attorney's fees. The association moved to dismiss on the ground that no employer-employee relationship existed and that the claims fell within the jurisdiction of the regular courts. The motion was denied, and a motion for reconsideration was likewise denied. The labor arbiter dismissed most of Salas's claims but ordered the association to pay notarial fees from 1987 up to March 2, 1990, plus attorney's fees. On appeal, the National Labor Relations Commission affirmed the decision in its entirety. The association then came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari, alleging grave abuse of discretion.
Facts
In 1980, Air Material Wing Savings and Loan Association appointed Luis Salas as its notarial and legal counsel. By an implementing order dated January 23, 1987, the board of directors reappointed him for a term of three years effective March 1, 1987, unless sooner terminated for cause or as the board might deem necessary for the interest and protection of the association. The order fixed his monthly compensation or retainer's fee and enumerated his duties, which included acting on all legal matters of his office, seeking remedies to collect overdue accounts of members, and defending all suits against the association's interest.
On January 9, 1990, the association issued another order reminding Salas of the approaching termination of his legal services under their contract. This prompted Salas to file his complaint for various monetary claims.
The labor arbiter held that Salas was not illegally dismissed, that he was a managerial employee not entitled to the leave and allowance claims, and that his notarial fees from 1980 to 1986 had already prescribed. The arbiter nonetheless ordered payment of notarial fees from 1987 to 1990 and attorney's fees. The Commission affirmed in full.
Issues
- Whether or not Salas was an employee of the association under the four elements of an employer-employee relationship.
- Whether or not the labor arbiter and the National Labor Relations Commission had jurisdiction over Salas's claim for notarial fees.
- Whether or not there was substantial evidence to support the award of notarial fees from 1987 to 1990.
Applicable Provisions
Paragraph 3 of Article 217 of the Labor Code, as discussed in the decision, defines the money claims within the jurisdiction of labor arbiters:
The labor arbiter has original and exclusive jurisdiction over money claims of workers when such claims have some reasonable connection with the employer-employee relationship.
This provision bears on the case because Salas's claim for notarial fees arose from his employment as notarial officer, placing it within the labor arbiter's jurisdiction.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that an employer-employee relationship existed. The elements of that relationship are the selection and engagement of the employee, the payment of wages, the power of dismissal, and the employer's power to control the employee's conduct. All four were present: the board selected Salas in a regular meeting, the association paid him a monthly compensation or retainer's fee, it reserved the power of dismissal for cause or as it deemed necessary, and it defined his duties and functions as its legal counsel. The Court noted that a lawyer, like any other professional, may very well be an employee of a private corporation, as when a big corporation hires a staff of lawyers as in-house counsel, pays them regular salaries, ranks them in its table of organization, and otherwise treats them like its other officers and employees, as distinguished from a law firm acting as outside counsel on a retainer basis. The finding of the Commission on this factual question was accorded great respect and even finality when supported by substantial evidence.
On the second issue, the Court held that the labor arbiter had jurisdiction. Salas's claim for notarial fees was based on his employment as a notarial officer of the association and thus came under the jurisdiction of the labor arbiter.
On the third issue, the Court disagreed with the Commission. The letter-contract of January 23, 1987, contained no stipulation for the separate payment of notarial fees in addition to his basic salary. On the contrary, his notarial services were part of his regular functions and were already covered by his monthly compensation. The fact that the notarial fees were paid by members-borrowers for the association's own account was not a sufficient basis for his claim in the absence of any agreement to that effect. There was therefore no substantial evidence to support the award.
Doctrine
A lawyer, like any other professional, may be an employee of a private corporation. The test is the four elements of an employer-employee relationship: selection and engagement, payment of wages, power of dismissal, and the power of control. Where the corporation selects the lawyer, pays him a monthly retainer, reserves the power to dismiss him, and defines his duties, the relationship is one of employment, not of independent contract.
Labor arbiters have original and exclusive jurisdiction over money claims of workers when such claims have some reasonable connection with the employer-employee relationship, as stated in paragraph 3 of Article 217 of the Labor Code. A claim for notarial fees based on the claimant's employment as notarial officer of the employer falls within that jurisdiction.
An award of notarial fees cannot stand where the contract of employment contains no stipulation for their separate payment and the notarial services were part of the employee's regular functions already covered by his monthly compensation.
Disposition
The Court affirmed the judgment of the National Labor Relations Commission with the modification that the award of notarial fees and attorney's fees was disallowed.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a lawyer may very well be an employee of a private corporation, and the four elements of selection, wages, dismissal, and control decide the question. Examiners like to use this case to test the employer-employee test applied to professionals and the scope of a labor arbiter's jurisdiction over money claims reasonably connected to the employment relationship.