PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. RAFAEL APOLONIA, ACCUSED-APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
People versus Apolonia
The Case
This is the People of the Philippines against Rafael Apolonia, a criminal appeal from a conviction for murder. Apolonia was charged, together with an unidentified companion referred to in the information as John Doe, with the shooting death of Pepito Alonzo in Nasugbu, Batangas. The case matters to a reviewee for three reasons: it is a clean illustration of conviction on circumstantial evidence when no witness saw the trigger pulled, it shows how the Supreme Court treats a "lone witness" and a shaky alibi, and it separates treachery, which was appreciated, from evident premeditation, which was not.
Procedural History
An information for murder was filed before the Regional Trial Court of Nasugbu, Batangas. The John Doe was never identified and has remained at large. At arraignment, Apolonia entered a plea of not guilty. After trial, the trial court found him guilty of murder beyond reasonable doubt, sentenced him to reclusion perpetua, and ordered him to indemnify the heirs of Pepito Alonzo in the amount of 80,000 pesos by way of actual, moral and exemplary damages. Apolonia appealed directly to the Supreme Court, assigning as errors the giving of full faith and credit to the lone testimony of Aquilino Alonzo and the finding of guilt despite what he called a lack of strong and convincing evidence.
Facts
On the afternoon of 17 September 1990, in Sitio Bayabasan, Barangay Aga, Nasugbu, Batangas, Apolonia and an unidentified companion went to the house of Aquilino Alonzo. Apolonia was carrying a long firearm and appeared angry, his voice loud and ferocious. He asked Aquilino where his brother Pepito was. When Aquilino could not say, the two men left. Fearing for his brother, Aquilino followed them along a footpath.
Aquilino heard a gunshot, hid behind a mango tree, and from about eight meters away saw Apolonia fire his gun in a direction where Aquilino would shortly find his brother's body. The two men stood between Aquilino and the victim, so Aquilino did not actually see Apolonia aim at Pepito or pull the trigger. After the shooting, the two men fled in haste. Aquilino walked to the spot and found Pepito lifeless, lying face up. He reported the matter to the Barangay Chairman and then to the Nasugbu police.
Police officers who went to the scene recovered two empty shells of 30 caliber rifle ammunition and one live round of the same caliber. The municipal health officer examined the body and described a very large, mutilated gunshot wound at the right back side of the head, with the brains spilling out, and deduced that the victim had been shot at close range. Apolonia, for his part, set up alibi: that he had been farming in Barangay Medina, Magallanes, Cavite from morning until five in the afternoon of that day, corroborated by Ernesto Tampis, his employer and a cousin of his wife. He was arrested in Tagaytay City more than a year later, on 5 October 1991, while meeting his daughter arriving from Singapore.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court erred in giving full faith and credit to the lone testimony of Aquilino Alonzo despite its alleged contradictions.
- Whether or not the trial court gravely erred in finding the accused guilty beyond reasonable doubt of murder despite the absence of an eyewitness to the actual shooting.
- Whether or not the defense of alibi should have been sustained.
- Whether or not the qualifying circumstances of treachery and evident premeditation attended the killing.
Applicable Provisions
Section 5 of Rule 133 of the Rules of Court, on circumstantial evidence, provides:
Section 5. Circumstantial evidence, when sufficient. Circumstantial evidence is sufficient for conviction if: (a) There is more than one circumstance; (b) The facts from which the inferences are derived are proven; and (c) The combination of all the circumstances is such as to produce a conviction beyond reasonable doubt.
This is the provision under which the Court sustained the conviction even though no witness saw Apolonia shoot the victim.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the alleged inconsistency in Aquilino's testimony about the time of day was a minor one, born of confusion during cross-examination that the trial judge's clarificatory questions cleared up. Far from destroying credibility, the Court said, such unrehearsed responses enhance it, especially where the witness had no motive to lie against Apolonia, his wife's uncle, with whom he had been on harmonious terms. The Court reaffirmed the settled rule that the trial judge's appraisal of credibility is accorded great weight absent a showing that he overlooked facts of substance.
On the second issue, the Court held that it is not indispensably necessary that an eyewitness saw the accused in the very act of shooting. The evidence being circumstantial, the Court applied Section 5 of Rule 133 and found all three requisites satisfied. It then listed the circumstances that pointed to Apolonia: he and a companion went looking for Pepito; he was armed with a long firearm; he appeared angry; Aquilino heard a gunshot while following them; he saw Apolonia fire his gun at someone; he saw the two flee; he found his brother's body where Apolonia had fired; the police recovered two empty shells and one live round; and the autopsy showed a large gunshot wound at the back of the head.
On the alibi, the Court held that alibi must be so convincing as to preclude any doubt that the accused could not have been physically present at the place of the crime or its vicinity at the time of its commission. Here Apolonia himself testified that the two places were only twenty kilometers apart and that one could travel between them on foot, and his corroboration came from a relative, which the Court described as weak.
On the qualifying circumstances, the Court upheld treachery: the victim was shot from behind, with his back to his killer, and was not armed, so the attack offered no risk to the assailant from any defensive or retaliatory act. Evident premeditation, however, was not shown, because no evidence established the nature or the time of the planning or when the plan was first conceived. With no aggravating or mitigating circumstance, the penalty for murder was imposed in its medium period, reclusion perpetua.
Doctrine
Conviction may rest on circumstantial evidence provided there is more than one circumstance, the facts from which the inferences are drawn are proven, and the combination of all the circumstances produces a conviction of guilt beyond reasonable doubt. An eyewitness to the actual shooting is not indispensable. Alibi, to prosper, must be so convincing as to preclude any doubt that the accused could not have been at the scene or its vicinity at the time of the crime, and it is weak when established mainly by the accused or by his relatives. Treachery exists when a defenseless victim is shot or stabbed from behind, the means of attack offering no risk to the assailant from any defensive or retaliatory act. Evident premeditation cannot be appreciated without evidence of the nature or time of the planning and preparation and of when the plan was conceived.
Disposition
The trial court's decision was affirmed with modification: Apolonia was ordered to pay the heirs of Pepito Alonzo a death indemnity of 50,000 pesos in lieu of actual, moral and exemplary damages, with costs against him.
Remember This
The line worth memorizing is that it is not indispensably necessary that an eyewitness saw the accused in the very act of shooting, so long as the circumstantial evidence meets the three requisites of Section 5 of Rule 133. Examiners like to use this case on circumstantial evidence, on the weakness of alibi corroborated only by a relative, and on the distinction between treachery, which was present, and evident premeditation, which was not.