🎧 Case Brief Lecture

AF REALTY & DEVELOPMENT, INC. AND ZENAIDA R. RANULLO, PETITIONERS, VS. DIESELMAN FREIGHT SERVICES, CO., MANUEL C. CRUZ, JR. AND MIDAS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 111448. January 16, 2002 January 16, 2002

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

AF Realty and Development versus Dieselman Freight Services

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by AF Realty and Development, Inc. and its vice-president, Zenaida Ranullo, against Dieselman Freight Services, Co., its director Manuel Cruz, Jr., and Midas Development Corporation. AF Realty sued for specific performance, insisting that a contract of sale of a commercial lot in Pasig had been perfected between it and Dieselman through the acts of Cruz, Jr. and two real estate brokers. The case matters because it settles a deceptively simple question: can a corporation be bound by the unauthorized acts of a single director, and can such a void sale of land be ratified by accepting the buyer's money? The answer turns on the written-authority requirement for sales of land through an agent.

Procedural History

AF Realty filed a complaint for specific performance with the Regional Trial Court of Pasig City, praying that Dieselman be ordered to execute a final deed of sale. Midas, which had bought the same lot from Dieselman, was allowed to intervene. After trial, the Regional Trial Court ruled in favor of AF Realty, holding that Cruz, Jr.'s acts bound Dieselman, that the perfected sale barred Midas's intervention, and that Midas had acted in bad faith. It ordered Dieselman to execute the final deed of sale and to pay attorney's fees, and dismissed the claims in intervention.

All the parties appealed to the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court, holding that no sale was perfected because Cruz, Jr. had no written authority from Dieselman's board, and that the sale to Midas was valid and made in good faith. It nevertheless awarded moral and exemplary damages and attorney's fees against Dieselman and Cruz, Jr. jointly and severally. On motions for reconsideration, the Court of Appeals issued an Amending Decision, limiting liability for the damages and attorney's fees to Cruz, Jr. alone, and ordering the return of the 300,000 pesos. AF Realty then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review, assigning errors of law.

Facts

Dieselman owned a commercial lot of 2,094 square meters on E. Rodriguez Avenue in Pasig, covered by a transfer certificate of title. On May 10, 1988, Manuel Cruz, Jr., a member of Dieselman's board of directors, issued a letter denominated Authority To Sell Real Estate to Cristeta Polintan, a real estate broker, authorizing her to look for buyers and negotiate the sale at 3,000 pesos per square meter. Cruz, Jr. had no written authority from Dieselman to sell the lot. Polintan, in turn, authorized Felicisima Noble to sell the same property, and Noble offered it to AF Realty at 2,500 pesos per square meter.

Zenaida Ranullo, AF Realty's vice-president, accepted the offer and issued a check for 300,000 pesos payable to Dieselman. Polintan received the check and signed an acknowledgement receipt stating that the amount was partial payment but refundable within two weeks should AF Realty disapprove Ranullo's action. On June 29, 1988, AF Realty confirmed its intention to buy, and Ranullo asked Polintan for Dieselman's board resolution authorizing the sale. Polintan could produce only the owner's copy of the title, the tax declaration and tax receipt, and a photocopy of Dieselman's articles of incorporation.

On August 2, 1988, Manuel Cruz, Sr., Dieselman's president, acknowledged receipt of the 300,000 pesos as earnest money but required AF Realty to finalize the sale at 4,000 pesos per square meter. AF Realty replied that it had paid the initial down payment and was willing to pay the balance. On August 13, 1988, Cruz, Sr. terminated the offer and demanded the return of the title. Meanwhile, on July 30, 1988, Dieselman had sold the same lot to Midas by a deed of absolute sale at 2,800 pesos per square meter, authorized by a board resolution dated May 27, 1988. Midas paid 500,000 pesos as down payment and placed the balance in escrow. The notice of lis pendens was annotated on the title only on August 15, 1988.

Issues

  • Whether or not a contract of sale of the lot was perfected between Dieselman and AF Realty through the acts of Cruz, Jr., Polintan, and Noble.
  • Whether or not the acceptance of the 300,000 pesos as partial payment ratified the unauthorized sale.
  • Whether or not the sale of the lot to Midas is valid and made in good faith.
  • Whether or not Cruz, Jr. may be held liable for damages and attorney's fees.

Applicable Provisions

Article 1874 of the Civil Code provides:

When a sale of a piece of land or any interest therein is through an agent, the authority of the latter shall be in writing; otherwise, the sale shall be void.

This is the decisive rule, because the sale to AF Realty was made through persons who had no written authority from Dieselman.

Article 1409 of the Civil Code provides:

The following contracts are inexistent and void from the very beginning: Those expressly prohibited or declared void by law. These contracts cannot be ratified. Neither can the right to set up the defense of illegality be waived.

This forecloses AF Realty's argument that Dieselman ratified the sale by accepting the partial payment.

Section 23 of the Corporation Code provides that the corporate powers of all corporations shall be exercised by the board of directors. The Court uses it to show that a director's acts bind the corporation only when duly authorized by the board.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court agreed with the Court of Appeals that no contract of sale was perfected. Corporate powers are exercised by the board of directors, which may validly delegate functions to officers or agents; absent such delegation, the declarations of an individual director relating to corporate affairs are not binding on the corporation. Cruz, Jr. had no written authority from the board to sell the lot or to appoint others for that purpose. His lack of authority precluded him from conferring any on Polintan, and Polintan could confer none on Noble. The Court applied the maxim that no one can give what he does not have, and the image that a spring cannot rise higher than its source. Since the sale was through an agent, Article 1874 governs, and the sale is void.

On the second issue, the Court held that ratification was impossible. A void contract under Article 1409 cannot be ratified, and the right to set up its illegality cannot be waived. The acceptance of the 300,000 pesos did not cure the defect.

On the third issue, the Court upheld the sale to Midas. It was authorized by a board resolution dated May 27, 1988. The notice of lis pendens was annotated only on August 15, 1988, after the sale to Midas on July 30, 1988, and operated prospectively; it did not retroact to make Midas a buyer in bad faith. The notarized deed of sale is admissible as to its date and execution without further proof.

On the fourth issue, the Court deleted the award of damages and attorney's fees against Cruz, Jr. Ranullo herself admitted that a board resolution was necessary to bind Dieselman and that Cruz, Jr. had no written authority, yet she tendered partial payment anyway. Cruz, Jr. should not be held liable for damages and attorney's fees.

Doctrine

A corporation acts only through its board of directors or through agents duly authorized by the board. A sale of land through an agent requires the agent's authority to be in writing; otherwise, the sale is void under Article 1874 of the Civil Code. A void contract is inexistent from the beginning and cannot be ratified, nor can the defense of illegality be waived, under Article 1409. A notice of lis pendens registered after a prior sale operates prospectively and does not retroact to taint the earlier buyer with bad faith.

Disposition

The Court affirmed the Court of Appeals with modification, deleting the award of damages and attorney's fees, and ordered Dieselman to return to AF Realty its partial payment of 300,000 pesos, with costs against the petitioners.

Remember This

Memorize the line: a sale of land through an agent without written authority is void and cannot be ratified. Examiners use this case to test the written-authority requirement under Article 1874 and the non-ratifiability of void contracts under Article 1409.