CALTEX REGULAR EMPLOYEES AT MANILA OFFICE, LEGAZPI BULK DEPOT AND MARINDUQUE BULK DEPOT – (MACLU), PETITIONERS, VS. CALTEX (PHILIPPINES), INC. AND NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMI…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Caltex Regular Employees Association versus Caltex Philippines
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by the Caltex Regular Employees Association at the Manila Office, the Legazpi Bulk Depot and the Marinduque Bulk Depot against Caltex Philippines, Incorporated and the National Labor Relations Commission. The Union asks the Supreme Court to annul the decision of the National Labor Relations Commission, which had reversed the Labor Arbiter and held that the 1985 Collective Bargaining Agreement granted the employees only one day of rest. The case matters because it is the leading authority on how a collective bargaining agreement is read as a whole: the body of the contract governs, an annex is subordinate to it, and the long continued practice of the parties is the surest guide to what they meant.
Procedural History
The Union filed a complaint for unfair labor practice against Caltex, alleging violation of the 1985 Collective Bargaining Agreement and shortchanging of employees. Labor Arbiter Valentin Guanio ruled in favor of the Union, finding that the employees had been given two days of rest, so that work on Saturday, the first day of rest, should be paid at first day-off rates; he nevertheless cleared Caltex of unfair labor practice. Caltex appealed, and the National Labor Relations Commission set aside the Labor Arbiter's decision, holding that the agreement granted only one day of rest, namely Sunday. The Union's motion for reconsideration was denied. The Union then came to the Supreme Court on a petition for certiorari, charging the Commission with grave abuse of discretion.
Facts
On 12 December 1985, the Union and Caltex entered into a Collective Bargaining Agreement to remain in force until midnight of 31 December 1988. Article III on hours of work fixed the regular work week at eight hours per day, seven days, Monday through Sunday, and provided that work on the employee's one day of rest shall be considered a special work day paid at day of rest rates. Annex B of the agreement set out the mathematical formulae for computing regular day pay, overtime pay, night shift differential, day off pay, Sunday premium pay and holiday premium pay, including first day-off and second day-off rates.
In August 1986, the Union called Caltex's attention to alleged violations of Annex B, such as non-payment of night shift differential and overtime pay and non-payment at first day-off rates for work on Saturday. Caltex's Industrial Relations manager evaluated the claims and implemented recomputed payments, but no differential was paid for work performed during the first two and one-half hours of a Saturday.
On 7 July 1987, the Union filed its complaint. It claimed that Saturday was the employees' day of rest and that work on those first two and one-half hours should be paid at day of rest rates. Caltex answered that Saturday was never designated a day of rest, that the agreement provided only one day of rest, Sunday, and that the first and second day-off rates in Annex B applied only to operations personnel at the refinery, depots and terminals who worked six consecutive days, not to Manila Office personnel.
Issues
- Whether or not the 1985 Collective Bargaining Agreement granted the employees one day of rest or two days of rest, so that work on Saturday is payable at day of rest rates.
- Whether or not Annex B, with its first day-off and second day-off rates, prevails over Article III of the agreement.
- Whether or not Caltex is guilty of offsetting undertime against overtime, and of violating the rule on overtime compensation, by paying regular rates for Saturday work.
Applicable Provisions
Article III of the 1985 Collective Bargaining Agreement provides:
In conformity with Presidential Decree 442, otherwise known as the Labor Code of the Philippines, as amended, the regular work week shall consist of eight (8) hours per day, seven (7) days, Monday through Sunday, during which regular rates of pay shall be paid in accordance with Annex B and work on the employee's one Day of Rest, shall be considered a special work day, during which Day of Rest rates of pay shall be paid as provided in Annex B. Daily working schedules shall be established by management in accordance with the requirements of efficient operations on the basis of eight (8) hours per day for any five (5) days. Provided, however, employees required to work in excess of forty (40) hours in any week shall be compensated in accordance with Annex B of this Agreement.
The word one describing the employee's day of rest is the textual anchor of the Court's holding that only a single day of rest was agreed upon.
Article 87 of the Labor Code, as amended, provides in relevant part:
Art. 87. Overtime Work. — Work may be performed beyond eight (8) hours a day provided that the employee is paid for the overtime work and additional compensation equivalent to his regular wage plus at least twenty-five percent (25%) thereof.
This fixes what counts as overtime: hours beyond the applicable daily or weekly work period, not merely hours worked on an inconvenient day.
Article 88 of the Labor Code, as amended, provides:
Art. 88. Undertime not offset by overtime. — Undertime work on any particular day shall not be offset by overtime work on any other day. Permission given to the employee to go on leave on some other day of the week shall not exempt the employer from paying the additional compensation requited in this Chapter.
The Court invokes this prohibition only to show that it has no application where Saturday hours are regular hours, not overtime.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the parties intended only one day of rest. The plain and ordinary meaning of Article III is that day of rest rates are paid for work on an employee's one day of rest, and the use of the word one emphasizes that only a single day of rest shall be scheduled. The Court compared the 1973, 1976, 1979 and 1982 agreements, which carried parallel provisions, and noted that the Union had never suggested that more than one day of rest was agreed, while Caltex had never treated the contract as granting two. The contemporaneous and subsequent conduct of the parties may be taken into account in interpreting a contract.
On the second issue, the Court held that Annex B cannot prevail. An annex expresses the idea of joining a smaller or subordinate thing with another, larger or of higher importance; it has a subordinate role, without independent significance separate from that to which it is tacked on. Annex B is not a memorandum of amendments or a codicil containing new terms, and it neither conferred rights on the employees nor imposed obligations on Caltex. Its formulae serve as a company-wide guide, and the first and second day-off rates apply only to operations personnel at the refinery, depots and terminals who must be on duty six consecutive days, not to Manila Office personnel. The Labor Arbiter's inference was based on conjecture and speculation. The Court added that the deletion, from all agreements after 1970, of the proviso granting two consecutive days off meant the parties had agreed to remove it, and the Union cannot unilaterally re-insert it by strained inference.
On the third issue, the Court held that there was no offsetting of undertime against overtime. Overtime work consists of hours worked on a given day in excess of the applicable work period, which here is eight hours; it is not enough that the hours fall on disagreeable or inconvenient hours. Under the agreement, Saturday is not a rest day, and hours worked on a Saturday are normal hours paid at regular rates unless the employee has in fact rendered work in excess of forty hours in the calendar week. The company practice of allowing employees to leave thirty minutes early, established for their convenience in avoiding heavy traffic, shortened the hours actually worked but did not shorten the work required for computing overtime and premium pay.
Doctrine
- A collective bargaining agreement is interpreted according to the plain and ordinary meaning of its language; the word one describing an employee's day of rest means a single day of rest.
- An annex is subordinate to the body of the agreement and cannot modify or alter its terms; it has no independent significance apart from the contract to which it is attached.
- The contemporaneous and subsequent conduct and long continued practice of the parties are competent aids in construing a contract, especially where the practice is wholly consistent with its actual language.
- Overtime work is work beyond the applicable work period of eight hours a day or forty hours a week; work on a Saturday is not overtime by that fact alone.
- The prohibition against offsetting undertime with overtime does not apply where the hours in question are regular hours, not overtime.
Disposition
The Supreme Court dismissed the petition for lack of merit, upheld the National Labor Relations Commission, and held that the employees are entitled only to one day of rest, Sunday, with Saturday work paid at regular rates unless forty hours in the calendar week have been exceeded.
Remember This
Memorize the line that an annex has a subordinate role, without any independent significance separate from that to which it is tacked on, and that long continued practice is contemporaneous and practical construction of the parties' intent. Examiners use this case on contract interpretation in labor law, on the hierarchy between a collective bargaining agreement and its annexes, and on what genuinely constitutes overtime.