TERESITA SALCEDO-ORTANEZ, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, HON. ROMEO F. ZAMORA, PRESIDING JUDGE, BR. 94, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT OF QUEZON CITY AND RAFAEL S. ORTANEZ, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Salcedo-Ortanez versus Court of Appeals
The Case
This is a petition for review brought by Teresita Salcedo-Ortanez against the Court of Appeals, the presiding judge of the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, and her husband Rafael S. Ortanez. The private respondent had sued for annulment of their marriage, and during trial the lower court admitted in evidence three cassette tapes of the wife's telephone conversations with unidentified persons, tapes secretly made by wiretapping the family telephone. The wife challenged that admission all the way to the Supreme Court. The case matters because it settles, in plain terms, that tape recordings obtained by wiretapping without the consent of all the parties are barred by statute from any judicial proceeding, and because it reminds the bar when the extraordinary writ of certiorari may be used to correct an interlocutory evidentiary ruling.
Procedural History
Private respondent Rafael S. Ortanez filed a complaint for annulment of marriage with damages before the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, Branch 94, presided over by Judge Romeo F. Zamora, on the grounds of lack of a marriage license and the psychological incapacity of the petitioner. After presenting his evidence, the private respondent orally offered his exhibits, which included the three cassette tapes. The petitioner filed her objection and comment to the offer, but on the same day the trial court admitted all of the offered evidence. The petitioner's motion for reconsideration was denied. She then went to the Court of Appeals on a petition for certiorari, assailing the admission of the tapes. The Court of Appeals dismissed the petition, holding that tape recordings are not inadmissible per se and that certiorari is not the proper remedy to rectify an error in admitting evidence during trial, since the ruling is interlocutory and should be questioned in an appeal from the judgment on the merits. From that adverse judgment, the petitioner came to the Supreme Court by petition for review under Rule 45.
Facts
On the second of May 1990, Rafael S. Ortanez filed with the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City a complaint for annulment of marriage with damages against his wife, Teresita Salcedo-Ortanez, alleging lack of a marriage license and her psychological incapacity.
During the trial, the husband presented his evidence and formally offered his exhibits. Among them were three cassette tapes of alleged telephone conversations between the wife and unidentified persons. It turned out that these recordings were made and obtained when the husband allowed his friends from the military to wiretap his home telephone.
The wife objected to the offer, but the trial court admitted all of the husband's evidence on the very day her objection was submitted. Her motion for reconsideration was denied, and her petition for certiorari in the Court of Appeals was dismissed. The Supreme Court then took up the question of whether the tapes could lawfully be admitted at all.
Issues
- Whether or not the remedy of certiorari under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court was properly availed of by the petitioner in the Court of Appeals to challenge an interlocutory order admitting evidence.
- Whether or not the cassette tapes of the wife's telephone conversations, obtained by wiretapping without the consent of all the parties, are admissible in evidence.
Applicable Provisions
Section 1 of Republic Act Number 4200, the Anti-Wiretapping Law, provides:
It shall be unlawful for any person, not being authorized by all the parties to any private communication or spoken word, to tap any wire or cable, or by using any other device or arrangement, to secretly overhear, intercept, or record such communication or spoken word by using a device commonly known as a dictaphone or dictagraph or detectaphone or walkie-talkie or tape-recorder, or however otherwise described.
This defines the act that produced the tapes, and it is the absence of authorization from all the parties that makes the recording unlawful.
Section 4 of the same law provides:
Any communication or spoken word, or the existence, contents, substance, purport, or meaning of the same or any part thereof, or any information therein contained, obtained or secured by any person in violation of the preceding sections of this Act shall not be admissible in evidence in any judicial, quasi-judicial, legislative or administrative hearing or investigation.
This is the exclusionary rule that directly governs the tapes and bars their use in the annulment case.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court acknowledged the general rule that the extraordinary writ of certiorari is not available to challenge an interlocutory order of a trial court, the proper remedy being an ordinary appeal from an adverse judgment that incorporates the grounds for assailing the interlocutory order. But the Court recognized an exception: where the assailed interlocutory order is patently erroneous and the remedy of appeal would not afford adequate and expeditious relief, certiorari may be allowed as a mode of redress. The Court found that this exception applied, because the order admitted tapes that the law expressly makes inadmissible.
On the second issue, the Court held that the trial court and the Court of Appeals failed to consider Republic Act Number 4200 in admitting the cassette tapes. The Court stressed that absent a clear showing that both parties to the telephone conversations allowed the recording, the inadmissibility of the tapes is mandatory under the law. The Court also noted that the statute imposes a penalty of imprisonment of not less than six months and up to six years for its violation. Having concluded that the tapes are inadmissible under Philippine law, the Court found no need to address the parties' arguments on the applicability of American jurisprudence.
Doctrine
First, an interlocutory order admitting evidence is generally not the proper subject of a petition for certiorari; the remedy is an appeal from the judgment on the merits. By way of exception, certiorari will lie where the interlocutory order is patently erroneous and appeal would not afford adequate and expeditious relief.
Second, and more importantly for evidence and family law, a tape recording of a private telephone conversation made without the authorization of all the parties is unlawful under Section 1 of Republic Act Number 4200, and by force of Section 4 of the same law it shall not be admissible in evidence in any judicial, quasi-judicial, legislative, or administrative hearing or investigation. The exclusion is mandatory; absent a clear showing that both parties consented to the recording, the tapes cannot be received.
Disposition
The Supreme Court granted the petition, set aside the decision of the Court of Appeals, and declared the subject cassette tapes inadmissible in evidence.
Remember This
Memorize the rule that a wiretap recording made without the consent of all the parties is not merely objectionable but statutorily inadmissible in any proceeding under Republic Act Number 4200. Examiners use this case in evidence and criminal procedure, testing the anti-wiretapping exclusion and the narrow exception allowing certiorari against a patently erroneous interlocutory ruling.