MONA A. TOMALI, PETITIONER, VS. CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION, OFFICE ON MUSLIM AFFAIRS (OMA) AND ROCAINA M. LUCMAN, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Tomali versus Civil Service Commission
The Case
This is a special civil action for certiorari brought by Mona A. Tomali against the Civil Service Commission, the Office on Muslim Affairs, and Rocaina M. Lucman. Tomali asks the Supreme Court to set aside the dismissal of her protest against her replacement in the contested position of Development Management Officer II in the Office on Muslim Affairs. The case matters because it fixes the legal effect of an appointment to the civil service that is not submitted to the Civil Service Commission within the period required by law, and it explains when, if at all, security of tenure may be invoked by the appointee.
Procedural History
Tomali filed a protest with the Office on Muslim Affairs against her replacement, and the protest was treated as a complaint before the Merit Systems Protection Board. In a decision dated 23 July 1992, the Merit Systems Protection Board dismissed the protest for lack of merit, holding that her appointment was incomplete for lack of approval by the Civil Service Commission and that no security of tenure attached to it. Her motion for reconsideration was denied on 27 November 1992. She then appealed to the Civil Service Commission, which, in its Resolution Number 93-945 dated 12 March 1993, dismissed the appeal for lack of merit. From that resolution, she came to the Supreme Court by a special civil action for certiorari, questioning the dismissal of her protest and her replacement by the private respondent.
Facts
On 01 July 1990, Mona A. Tomali was appointed Development Management Officer II in the Office on Muslim Affairs by then Executive Director Dimasangcay A. Pundato. She assumed the duties and functions of the office four months later, on 01 November 1990, at which time the appointment had not yet been transmitted to the Civil Service Commission for approval. Before this position, she had worked with the Mindanao State University as Records Clerk, then Clerk Typist, and finally as Budget Assistant.
On 16 July 1991, the new Director of the Office on Muslim Affairs, Doctor Ali Basir Lucman, revoked the previous incomplete appointment of Tomali and appointed the private respondent, Rocaina M. Lucman, to the same position. Tomali protested her replacement in a letter dated 29 July 1991, and on 01 August 1991 the Chief of the Human Resources Management Division communicated to her the disapproval or expiration of her appointment. The private respondent forthwith took her oath of office and assumed the duties of the position. Tomali reiterated her protest on 12 August 1991.
It appears that Tomali's appointment was issued on 01 July 1990, but it was only on 31 May 1991 that it was submitted to the Civil Service Commission, which disapproved it. The Merit Systems Protection Board and later the Civil Service Commission both ruled against her, and she brought the matter to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not an appointment to a civil service position that is not submitted to the Civil Service Commission within thirty days from its issuance is ineffective.
- Whether or not security of tenure may be invoked by an appointee whose appointment has not been approved by the Civil Service Commission.
- Whether or not the appointing authority may recall or revoke an incomplete appointment and appoint another person in place of the appointee.
- Whether or not the public respondents committed grave abuse of discretion in dismissing the protest of the petitioner.
Applicable Provisions
Section 9 of Presidential Decree Number 807, on the powers and functions of the Commission, provides:
Section 9. Powers and Functions of the Commission. The Commission shall administer the Civil Service and shall have the following powers and functions: x x x (h) Approve all appointments, whether original or promotional, to positions in the civil service, except those of presidential appointees, members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines, police forces, firemen, and jailguards, and disapprove those where the appointees do not possess the appropriate eligibility or required qualifications. An appointment shall take effect immediately upon issue by the appointing authority if the appointee assumes his duties immediately and shall remain effective until it is disapproved by the Commission, if this should take place, without prejudice to the liability of the appointing authority for appointments issued in violation of existing laws or rules: Provided, finally, That the Commission shall keep a record of appointments of all officers and employees in the civil service. All appointments requiring the approval of the Commission as herein provided, shall be submitted to it by the appointing authority within thirty days from issuance, otherwise, the appointment becomes ineffective thirty days thereafter.
This provision requires the appointing authority to submit the appointment to the Commission within thirty days from issuance, failing which the appointment becomes ineffective, and it is the basis for the ruling that no title to the office is permanently vested without the Commission's approval.
Section 11, Rule V of the Omnibus Rules Implementing Book V of Executive Order Number 292, the Administrative Code of 1987, provides:
Section 11. An appointment not submitted to the Commission within thirty days from the date of issuance which shall be the date appearing on the face of the appointment, shall be ineffective. x x x.
This rule implements the statutory requirement and confirms that the appointment is ineffective when not submitted within the prescribed period.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that an appointment to a position in the civil service must be submitted to the Civil Service Commission for approval, in order to determine whether the proposed appointee is qualified and whether the rules on appointment are followed. Under Section 9 of Presidential Decree Number 807, all appointments requiring approval must be submitted within thirty days from issuance, otherwise the appointment becomes ineffective thirty days thereafter. Under Section 11, Rule V of the Omnibus Rules, an appointment not submitted within thirty days from the date of issuance, which is the date appearing on the face of the instrument, shall be ineffective. The Court found that Tomali's appointment was issued on 01 July 1990 but was submitted to the Commission only on 31 May 1991, and was disapproved, so it had become ineffective by operation of law.
On the second issue, the Court held that without the favorable certification or approval of the Commission, when such approval is required, no title to the office can be deemed permanently vested in favor of the appointee, and the appointment can still be recalled or withdrawn by the appointing authority. Until an appointment has become a completed act, it is precipitate to invoke the rule on security of tenure. The Court quoted its earlier ruling in Favis versus Rupisan:
The tolerance, acquiescence or mistake of the proper officials, resulting in the non-observance of the pertinent rules on the matter does not render the legal requirement, on the necessity of approval of the Commissioner of Civil Service of appointments, ineffective and unenforceable. The employee, whose appointment was not approved, may only be considered as a de facto officer.
On the third issue, the Court held that it was well within the authority and discretion of the new Director of the Office on Muslim Affairs to appoint the private respondent, and that this prerogative could not be questioned even on a showing that the petitioner might have been better qualified. An appointment is essentially a discretionary act, performed by the officer in whom it is vested according to his best judgment, the only condition being that the appointee should possess all the qualifications required. The Court found nothing on record to show that the new Director unjustly favored the private respondent or exercised the power of appointment in an arbitrary, whimsical, or despotic manner.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that there was no grave abuse of discretion on the part of the public respondents in dismissing the petitioner's protest.
Doctrine
An appointment to a civil service position requiring the approval of the Civil Service Commission must be submitted to the Commission within thirty days from the date of issuance appearing on the face of the appointment. If it is not so submitted, the appointment becomes ineffective by operation of law. Without the favorable certification or approval of the Commission, no title to the office is permanently vested in the appointee, and the appointment may still be recalled or withdrawn by the appointing authority. Until the appointment becomes a completed act, security of tenure cannot be invoked. The tolerance, acquiescence, or mistake of officials in not observing these rules does not render the requirement ineffective, and the employee whose appointment was not approved may only be considered a de facto officer. Appointment is essentially a discretionary act of the appointing authority, and the exercise of that discretion will not be disturbed absent grave abuse.
Disposition
The petition for certiorari was dismissed, with no special pronouncement on costs. The private respondent prevailed, and the dismissal of the petitioner's protest was upheld.
Remember This
Memorize this line: an appointment not submitted to the Civil Service Commission within thirty days from issuance is ineffective, and no security of tenure attaches until the appointment is completed by approval. Examiners use this case to test the effect of non-submission of appointments and the limits of security of tenure in the civil service.