🎧 Case Brief Lecture

TELENGTAN BROTHERS & SONS, INC. (LA SUERTE CIGAR & CIGARETTE FACTORY), PETITIONER, VS. THE COURT OF APPEALS, KAWASAKI KISHEN KAISHA, LTD. AND SMITH, BELL & CO., INC., RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 110581. September 21, 1994 September 21, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Telengtan Brothers and Sons versus Court of Appeals

The Case

This is a petition for review brought by Telengtan Brothers and Sons, Inc., doing business as La Suerte Cigar and Cigarette Factory, against the Court of Appeals, the foreign shipping company Kawasaki Kishen Kaisha, Ltd., and its Philippine shipping agent, Smith, Bell and Company, Inc. The action below was one for specific performance, seeking the release of container vans free of charge and the refund of demurrage charges already paid. The case matters because it fixes the rule that a consignee is bound by the terms of a bill of lading, including the tariff of a shipping conference incorporated into it, and it marks out when container demurrage may and may not be charged.

Procedural History

La Suerte filed a complaint for specific performance in the Regional Trial Court, together with a prayer for a writ of preliminary injunction to restrain the respondents from charging additional demurrage. After a bond was posted, the container vans were released to La Suerte. The trial court dismissed the complaint, ordered La Suerte to pay demurrage for the detention of seven forty-footer container vans, and awarded attorney's fees. On appeal, the Court of Appeals affirmed the dismissal but deleted the award of attorney's fees. The case then reached the Supreme Court through a petition for review.

Facts

On May 8, 1979, Van Reekum Paper, Inc. entered into a contract of affreightment with Kawasaki Kishen Kaisha for the shipment of 468 rolls of container board liners from Savannah, Georgia to Manila, consigned to La Suerte. The contract was embodied in a bill of lading, and the expenses of loading and unloading were for the account of the consignee. The shipment was packed in twelve container vans. At Tokyo the cargo was transhipped: ten vans were loaded on the SS Far East Friendship and two on the SS Hangang Glory.

On June 11, 1979, the SS Far East Friendship arrived in Manila, and La Suerte was notified in writing of the arrival and of container demurrage rates. The SS Hangang Glory arrived on June 21, 1979. The next day the shipping agent released the delivery permit for twelve containers upon payment of freight charges. But when the broker presented the documents to the Bureau of Customs, the Bureau refused to act because the manifest of the SS Far East Friendship covered only ten containers while the bill of lading covered twelve. The agent at first refused to amend the manifest, invoking the Tariff and Customs Code on unmanifested cargo, and only later agreed to add a footnote explaining that two vans had been carried by the SS Hangang Glory. The corrected manifest was picked up on June 29, 1979 and approved on July 3, 1979.

When the broker sought release on July 11, 1979, it was told that the free time had expired and that demurrage had begun to run. La Suerte paid 47,680 pesos on July 13, 1979, and a further 20,160 pesos on July 19, 1979, for a total of 67,840 pesos. It was able to obtain only partial release of the cargo, partly because of the breakdown of the arrastre operator's equipment. It then refused to pay more demurrage, and its request for a refund was denied on the ground that the carrier, as a member of the Far East Conference, could not modify the rules or authorize refunds of the stipulated tariffs.

Issues

  • Whether or not demurrage may be collected from the consignee under the bill of lading and the conference tariff, absent any detention of the vessel.
  • Whether or not the consignee is bound by the terms of the bill of lading, including the incorporated tariff, even if it did not sign the contract.
  • Whether or not the consignee is liable for demurrage for the entire period claimed by the carrier, or only for a shorter period.

Applicable Provisions

Clause 29 of the bill of lading, as quoted in the decision, provides:

29. . . . The terms of the ocean carrier's applicable tariff, including tariffs covering intermodal transportation on file with the Federal Maritime Commission and the Interstate Commission or any other regulatory body which governs a portion of the carriage of goods, are incorporated herein.

This clause makes the conference tariff, which fixes container demurrage, part of the contract of carriage.

Rule 21 of the Far East Conference Tariff No. 28, as quoted in the decision, provides:

Demurrage charges on Containers with CY Cargo. 1. Free time will commence at 8:00 a.m. on the first working calendar day following completion of discharge of the vessel. It shall expire at 12:00 p.m. (midnight) on the tenth working calendar day, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and holidays.

This rule supplies the free time and the demurrage rates that the carrier sought to enforce against the consignee.

Section 1 of Republic Act No. 1407, as described in the decision, declares that the Philippines recognizes the international character of shipping in foreign trade and existing international practices in maritime transportation. This supports enforcement of the conference rules.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that although the word demurrage in clause 23 of the bill of lading may refer to detention of the vessel, clause 29 of the same bill of lading, read with Rule 21 of the conference tariff, specifically provides for payment by the consignee of demurrage for the detention of containers after the free time. The Court quoted its own definition:

Demurrage, in its strict sense, is the compensation provided for in the contract of affreightment for the detention of the vessel beyond the time agreed on for loading and unloading.

On the second issue, the Court held that a bill of lading is both a receipt and a contract, and as a contract its terms are conclusive on the parties, including the consignee. It rejected the argument that the consignee was not bound because the contract was one of adhesion with fine print, holding that one who adheres to such a contract is free to reject it and, if he adheres, gives his consent.

On the third issue, the Court held that the consignee could not be charged demurrage from June 27, 1979, because the delay was not its fault. The manifest issued by the carrier stated only ten containers while the bill of lading showed twelve, and the Bureau of Customs refused an entry permit until the discrepancy was corrected. The Court found the correction was made only on June 29, 1979, and the manifest was approved on July 3, 1979. Demurrage therefore ran only from July 3 to July 13, 1979 for the ten containers, and from July 10 to July 13, 1979 for the two others. The period stopped on July 13, 1979, when the consignee paid, because the further delay was due to the breakdown of the arrastre operator's cranes, which could not be blamed on the consignee.

Doctrine

A bill of lading is both a receipt and a contract, and its terms and conditions are conclusive on the parties, including the consignee. A tariff of a shipping conference incorporated into the bill of lading forms part of the contract, and container demurrage may be collected under it even absent detention of the vessel. A contract of adhesion is not prohibited; one who adheres to it gives consent. Demurrage is a claim for damages for failure to accept delivery, and it may be charged only for delay attributable to the consignee, not for delay caused by the carrier's defective manifest or by the breakdown of the arrastre operator's equipment.

Disposition

The Court held the consignee liable for demurrage only for the shorter period stated, and the petition was resolved accordingly, with the consignee entitled to the corresponding adjustment of the charges it had paid.

Remember This

Memorize the line that a bill of lading is both a receipt and a contract whose terms bind the consignee, including an incorporated conference tariff. Examiners use this case on contracts of adhesion and on the requisites for charging container demurrage.