🎧 Case Brief Lecture

JOSE L. GARCIA, EDUARDO ALAS, NOEL APAYA, RICARDO ARMAMENTO, MARCOS AVEJERO REYNALDO BANTIGUE, ROMEO BORRAS, MARGARITO CABICUELAS, ROLANDO CAMUA, JOSE DENNIS CASTILLO, DICOROSO …

G.R. No. 110518. August 01, 1994 August 1, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Garcia versus National Service Corporation

The Case

This is a petition for certiorari brought by fifty-one former employees of the National Service Corporation, known as NASECO, a government-owned or controlled corporation engaged in providing manpower services such as security guards, radio operators, janitors and clerks, principally for the Philippine National Bank. The petitioners challenge the validity of their retrenchment, which the Labor Arbiter and later the National Labor Relations Commission upheld. The case matters because it is the Court's careful working out of the requisites of a valid retrenchment, and because it shows that the constitutional policy of protecting labor is not a license to oppress management.

Procedural History

The petitioners were among the employees who staged a strike and picketed the premises of the Philippine National Bank on November 19, 1988. The bank filed a complaint for damages with preliminary injunction before the Regional Trial Court of Manila, which granted the writ and ordered the lifting of the picket. NASECO, for its part, filed a petition with the National Labor Relations Commission to declare the strike illegal, and the Commission sustained NASECO, deeming the union officers who knowingly and actively participated in the strike, and the members who committed illegal acts, to have legally lost their employment status, while ordering the rest of the striking members, including these fifty-one petitioners, to report for work immediately.

The petitioners reported for work on March 1, 1989, but could not be given assignments because the bank had contracted with another company to fill their former positions. NASECO paid their salaries and benefits from April 1, 1989 although they were not actually working, and on October 13, 1989 served them notice of separation effective thirty days thereafter, with a corresponding thirty-day notice to the Department of Labor and Employment. The petitioners refused to acknowledge receipt of the notice and filed a complaint with the National Labor Relations Commission for unfair labor practice, illegal dismissal, non-payment of wages and damages. The Labor Arbiter rendered a decision finding that the petitioners had been fairly discharged in a valid act of simple retrenchment. The petitioners appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission, which affirmed the Labor Arbiter, and denied their motion for reconsideration. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court by this petition for certiorari, asserting grave abuse of discretion.

Facts

NASECO assigned its employees to its clients, principally the Philippine National Bank, under a Service Agreement that gave the bank the right to reject or replace any and all of NASECO's employees assigned to it, for inefficiency or other valid reasons. On November 19, 1988, the petitioners, who were members of the NASECO Employees Union or of the Alliance of Concerned Workers of NASECO, staged a strike and picketed the premises of the bank. The bank obtained a preliminary injunction ordering the lifting of the picket, and the National Labor Relations Commission declared the strike illegal, but ordered the fifty-one petitioners, who were not among those deemed to have lost their employment, to report for work.

When the petitioners reported on March 1, 1989, they could not be assigned because the bank had meanwhile contracted with another company to fill their positions. NASECO inquired whether the bank would still accept them, and the bank manifested that it was no longer accepting them back as their positions were no longer vacant. NASECO then sought new assignments for the petitioners with its other clients, but the petitioners insisted on reassignment to the bank. Starting April 1, 1989, NASECO paid their salaries and other benefits although they were not actually working.

On October 13, 1989, the petitioners received notice of separation effective thirty days thereafter, the reason given being the financial losses NASECO was incurring, due mainly to the salaries paid to employees who could not be posted despite efforts to place them. The Department of Labor and Employment was given a thirty-day notice of the intended retrenchment, and NASECO offered a separation package equivalent to three-fourths of the estimated new basic monthly salary for every year of service, better than the statutory requirement. The petitioners refused to acknowledge the notice and filed their complaint. NASECO extended the effective date of termination several times for humanitarian considerations, finally to December 31, 1989. For the year 1989, NASECO incurred losses amounting to 1,457,700.42 pesos, directly caused by the salaries and benefits paid to the petitioners from April 1 to December 31, 1989.

Issues

  • Whether or not the retrenchment of the fifty-one petitioners was valid under the requisites laid down in Lopez Sugar Corporation versus Federation of Free Workers.
  • Whether or not NASECO is guilty of unfair labor practice, the dismissal being allegedly discriminatory and violative of the petitioners' rights to self-organization and to engage in concerted activities.
  • Whether or not the petitioners' monetary claim for increases under Republic Act 6640 and Republic Act 6727 may be granted although not contained in the complaint.
  • Whether or not the petitioners are entitled to moral and exemplary damages and to attorney's fees.

Applicable Provisions

Article 283 of the Labor Code, which the decision cites as the provision governing retrenchment, provides:

Article 283. Closure of establishment and reduction of personnel. The employer may also terminate the employment of any employee due to the installation of labor-saving devices, redundancy, retrenchment to prevent losses or the closing or cessation of operation of the establishment or undertaking unless the closing is for the purpose of circumventing the provisions of this Title, by serving a written notice on the workers and the Ministry of Labor and Employment at least one month before the intended date thereof. In case of termination due to the installation of labor-saving devices or redundancy, the worker affected thereby shall be entitled to a separation pay equivalent to at least his one month pay or to at least one month pay for every year of service, whichever is higher. In case of retrenchment to prevent losses and in cases of closures or cessation of operations of establishment or undertaking not due to serious business losses or financial reverses, the separation pay shall be equivalent to one month pay or at least one half month pay for every year of service, whichever is higher. A fraction of at least six months shall be considered as one whole year.

This is the provision under which NASECO effected the retrenchment, giving the required notices, and under which the separation pay of the petitioners must be computed, including the minimum wage increases that took effect before their retrenchment.

Section 3, Rule V of the Revised Rules of the National Labor Relations Commission, which the decision quotes in substance, provides:

Section 3. Parties should not be allowed to allege facts not referred to or included in the complaint, or position paper, affidavits and other documents.

This rule bears on the monetary claim, because it means that although a claim is not contained in the complaint, it may still be averred in the position paper, as the petitioners did.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the retrenchment was valid. The requisites of a valid retrenchment, as laid down in Lopez Sugar Corporation versus Federation of Free Workers, are that the losses expected should be substantial and not merely de minimis in extent; that the substantial losses apprehended must be reasonably imminent; that the retrenchment must be reasonably necessary and likely to effectively prevent the expected losses; and that the alleged losses, if already incurred, and the expected imminent losses sought to be forestalled, must be proved by sufficient and convincing evidence. The Court found that the losses incurred by NASECO for the year 1989 amounted to 1,457,700.42 pesos and were adequately proved, and were directly caused by the salaries and other benefits paid to the petitioners from April 1 to December 31, 1989, an amount not insubstantial in light of the economic difficulties of the country during that year. It was also not true that NASECO did not look for other measures, for it had tried to place the petitioners with its other clients, and it was the petitioners themselves who refused reassignment. The particular facts precluded application of the first in, last out rule, and there was no discrimination, because NASECO could not compel the bank to take the petitioners back in view of its contractual right to reject any employee for inefficiency and other valid reasons, and the bank had already filled the vacated positions during the strike to ensure the continued operation of its business.

On the second issue, the Court held that NASECO was not guilty of unfair labor practice, there being no discrimination against the petitioners, and their dismissal being attributable to the valid retrenchment and not to their participation in the strike.

On the third issue, the Court held that the monetary claim under Republic Act 6640 and Republic Act 6727 should be granted. The National Labor Relations Commission had denied it on the ground that the petitioners failed to include it in their basic complaint, but the Court found this contention unacceptable because the claim was clearly included and prayed for in their position paper, and under the rule quoted above, any claim can still be averred in the position paper. The increases, which took effect before the petitioners' retrenchment, should be considered in the computation of their separation pay in accordance with Article 283 of the Labor Code.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that moral damages are recoverable only where the dismissal of the employee was attended by bad faith or fraud or constituted an act oppressive to labor or was done in a manner contrary to morals, good customs or public policy, and exemplary damages may be awarded only if the dismissal was effected in a wanton, oppressive or malevolent manner. None of these grounds was proven, so the award of moral and exemplary damages was disallowed. However, the Court granted the claim for attorney's fees equivalent to ten percent of the total amount awarded, as authorized by the Labor Code. The Court closed with the reminder that the constitutional policy of providing full protection to labor is not intended to oppress or destroy management, and that the employer cannot be compelled to retain employees it no longer needs, to be paid for work unreasonably refused and not actually performed.

Doctrine

A valid retrenchment under Article 283 of the Labor Code requires that the losses expected be substantial and not merely de minimis in extent; that the substantial losses apprehended be reasonably imminent; that the retrenchment be reasonably necessary and likely to effectively prevent the expected losses; and that the alleged losses, if already incurred, and the expected imminent losses sought to be forestalled, be proved by sufficient and convincing evidence. The employer must show that it exerted efforts short of dismissal, and the first in, last out rule yields to the particular facts where the employer could not compel the client to take the employees back under a contractual right of rejection. The constitutional policy of providing full protection to labor is not intended to oppress or destroy management, and the employer cannot be compelled to retain employees it no longer needs. A monetary claim not stated in the complaint may still be granted if averred in the position paper, and minimum wage increases that took effect before retrenchment must be included in the computation of separation pay under Article 283.

Disposition

The Court affirmed the decision of the Labor Arbiter and the resolutions of the National Labor Relations Commission, with the modification that the monetary claim under Republic Act 6640 and Republic Act 6727, and attorney's fees equivalent to ten percent of the total amount awarded, were granted, while the award of moral and exemplary damages was disallowed.

Remember This

Memorize the four requisites of a valid retrenchment from Lopez Sugar Corporation versus Federation of Free Workers, and the line that the constitutional policy of providing full protection to labor is not intended to oppress or destroy management. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of retrenchment, the first in, last out rule and its exceptions, and the rule that claims may be averred in the position paper even if not in the complaint.