🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. JUAN TAÑOTE, SALVADOR DELA CRUZ, SALVADOR TORRENTE AND RODRIGO TAOC, ACCUSED.  SALVADOR TORRENTE, ACCUSED- APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 109769. November 28, 1994 November 28, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

People versus Torrente

The Case

This is the People of the Philippines against Salvador Torrente, a criminal appeal from a conviction for the special complex crime of robbery with homicide. Torrente was one of four men charged with robbing the store and home of Pastor Verano, Senior, and killing him and his son, Pastor Verano, Junior, on the night of August 22, 1987, in Caramoran, Catanduanes. The case matters to a reviewee for three reasons: it shows how the Supreme Court treats the factual findings of the trial court on credibility, it restates the strict requirements of the defense of alibi, and it illustrates the rule on solidary liability when the judgment against some co-accused has already become final.

Procedural History

All four accused were charged with robbery with homicide before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 52, Virac, Catanduanes. Three of them, Juan Tañote, Salvador dela Cruz and Rodrigo Taoc, first pleaded not guilty, then pleaded guilty on re-arraignment. Because of the gravity of the offense, the trial court still required the prosecution to present its evidence against them. On August 22, 1988, the trial court found those three guilty, sentenced each to reclusion perpetua, and ordered them to pay damages to the heirs of the two victims.

Torrente was not apprehended and remained at large. He was arrested in Manila sometime in 1990. On arraignment, with the assistance of counsel, he pleaded not guilty. After trial on the merits, the trial court rendered judgment on November 27, 1990, finding him guilty beyond reasonable doubt of robbery with homicide under Article 294, paragraph 1 of the Revised Penal Code, sentencing him to reclusion perpetua, and holding him jointly and severally liable with his co-accused for the same damages. Torrente appealed to the Supreme Court, assigning errors against the finding of identification, the rejection of his alibi, the finding of flight, and the refusal to acquit him on reasonable doubt.

Facts

About seven o'clock in the evening of August 22, 1987, Pastor Verano, Senior, and his wife, Nery Verano, were preparing for dinner at their residence in Inalmasinan, Caramoran, Catanduanes. With them were Lilia Braga and Pastor Verano, Junior, who had come to get money for a trip abroad. Near the Verano compound, a farmer named Miguel Solero was bringing rattan to sell. At the gate, Rodrigo Taoc poked a gun at him and told him not to shout. Torrente stood beside Taoc holding a flashlight. Solero recognized Torrente because Torrente had stayed in his hut for a week while gathering rattan. Solero ran to the house of Dioscoro Clavano and told Clavano and Domingo Burac that the Veranos were being robbed.

Inside the house, Verano, Senior, opened the main door and heard someone say hold-up. Nery Verano and Verano, Junior, saw him being held by Jesus Tapanan and Salvador dela Cruz. Juan Tañote entered through the kitchen door and threatened them with a gun. A shot came from the sala. Verano, Junior, struggled with Tañote, and two more gunshots followed. Before Nery Verano could hide, Torrente came through the door and poked a gun at her. Tapanan, wounded in the fray, was brought outside and died. After the robbers fled, Nery Verano found her husband and stepson dead, and the day's sales of 500 pesos and the 10,000 pesos intended for Verano, Junior's trip were gone.

The next morning, Francisco Padayao was at his hut by the river in Maraubos with his common-law wife and several companions. Rodrigo Taoc arrived, and about twenty minutes later Torrente, Salvador dela Cruz and Juan Tañote arrived. Padayao saw that dela Cruz's hand was dripping with blood, and that Torrente carried two guns. After eating, Padayao overheard Torrente say that if their trip was unlucky, they got two and lost one, running his forefinger across his neck. Before leaving, Torrente told Padayao not to tell anyone they had passed by. The autopsy showed that Verano, Senior, died of gunshot and stab wounds to the chest, and Verano, Junior, of a gunshot wound to the head. For his part, Torrente claimed alibi and mistaken identity, saying he was in the forest of Maraubos gathering rattan from August 13 to August 25, 1987, and that he later went to Quezon and then to Manila.

Issues

  • Whether or not the trial court erred in finding that Torrente was one of the men who robbed and killed the two Veranos.
  • Whether or not the trial court erred in not giving credence to Torrente's defense of alibi.
  • Whether or not the trial court erred in holding that the accused fled after the commission of the offense.
  • Whether or not Torrente should be acquitted on the ground of reasonable doubt.

Applicable Provisions

Article 294, paragraph 1 of the Revised Penal Code, as cited in the judgment of conviction, defines and penalizes the offense:

Any person guilty of robbery with the use of violence against or intimidation of any person shall suffer the penalty of reclusion perpetua to death, when by reason or on occasion of the robbery, the crime of homicide shall have been committed.

This is the special complex crime for which Torrente was convicted and sentenced.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court affirmed the finding of guilt. The assigned errors hinge on credibility, and the settled rule is that an appellate court will generally not disturb the trial court's findings, because the trial judge heard the witnesses and observed their deportment, unless some fact of value was plainly overlooked. The Court scrutinized the record and found no such oversight. Nery Verano positively identified Torrente as the man who poked a gun at her at the kitchen door, and the Court held that her relationship to the victim did not discredit her but lent more credence to her testimony. The alleged inconsistency between her sworn description of curly hair and regular build and Torrente's actual features was more apparent than real, since a height a little above five feet is normal for a Filipino and a change of hairstyle is of negligible effect against a positive identification based on facial features. Miguel Solero also positively identified Torrente, who had stayed in his hut for a week, and the Court held that Solero's failure to tell everyone was belied by his testimony that he told Clavano and Burac. The Court further noted that the eyewitnesses had no ill feelings against Torrente, and that the motives imputed to Padayao and his wife were inconsequential because their testimony was merely corroborative.

On the second issue, the Court rejected the alibi. Alibi cannot prevail over the positive testimony of prosecution witnesses and their clear identification of the accused. Torrente also failed to show that it was physically impossible for him to be at the Verano residence when the crime was committed, and the Court called alibi the weakest defense an accused can concoct.

On the third issue, the Court held that flight is a clear indication of guilt. Torrente's claim that he left Catanduanes only to attend his father-in-law's burial was not worthy of belief, since he stayed away for three years until his arrest in 1990, went to Manila to work in construction instead of returning to his farm, and left immediately after his co-accused were arrested. The Court quoted the ancient wisdom that the wicked flee even when no man pursueth, but the righteous are as bold as a lion.

On the fourth issue, the Court found no reasonable doubt and affirmed the conviction. On the penalty, the Court held that the prescribed penalty for robbery with homicide is reclusion perpetua to death, but since the death penalty was proscribed at the time of the commission of the offense, the trial court correctly imposed only reclusion perpetua despite the aggravating circumstances. On damages, the Court increased the death indemnity for each victim from 30,000 pesos to 50,000 pesos, for a total of 100,000 pesos. Because the judgment against the three co-accused had become final and executory, they are solidarily liable with Torrente only up to the amount awarded against them, and any excess is the sole liability of Torrente.

Doctrine

First, when the issue is the credibility of witnesses, the appellate court will generally not disturb the findings of the trial court, which had the advantage of hearing the witnesses and observing their demeanor, unless facts of value were plainly overlooked. Second, alibi cannot prevail over positive identification, and to be believed it requires credible and tangible proof of physical impossibility for the accused to be at the scene of the crime or its vicinity at the time of its commission. Third, flight from the scene and hiding until arrest are circumstances highly indicative of guilt. Fourth, the special complex crime of robbery with homicide carries the penalty of reclusion perpetua to death under Article 294, paragraph 1 of the Revised Penal Code, but where the death penalty was proscribed at the time of the offense, only reclusion perpetua may be imposed. Fifth, where the judgment against some co-accused has become final, they are solidarily liable only up to the amount fixed in that final judgment, and any excess is the sole liability of the appellant.

Disposition

The Supreme Court affirmed the appealed decision with modification, increasing the civil indemnity for the death of each victim to 50,000 pesos, for a total of 100,000 pesos, with Torrente jointly and severally liable with his three co-accused for 60,000 pesos of that amount and exclusively liable for the remaining 40,000 pesos.

Remember This

Memorize this line: alibi cannot prevail over positive identification, and it fails unless the accused proves that it was physically impossible for him to be at the scene of the crime. Examiners use this case to test the credibility rule, the strict requirements of alibi, flight as evidence of guilt, and the rule on solidary liability when a co-accused's judgment has already become final.