GERSON R. MENESES, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND PROCTER AND GAMBLE PHILS., INC., RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Meneses versus Court of Appeals and Procter and Gamble Philippines
The Case
This is a petition for review brought by Gerson Meneses against the Court of Appeals and his former employer, Procter and Gamble Philippines. Meneses had sued the company for damages after suffering catastrophic burns in a plant explosion, but the trial court dismissed his complaint for lack of jurisdiction, holding that the matter belonged to the labor tribunals. He then brought a petition for review under Rule 45 to the Court of Appeals, which dismissed it on procedural grounds. The case matters because it is the Supreme Court's clearest restatement of two enduring rules: that a final order of a regional trial court is reviewable only by appeal, never by certiorari, and that an appeal taken by the wrong mode to the wrong court is simply dismissed, not transferred.
Procedural History
Meneses filed a complaint for damages with the Regional Trial Court of Manila, which was assigned to one of its branches. Instead of answering, the company moved to dismiss on grounds of laches and lack of jurisdiction, contending that the claim fell within the exclusive original jurisdiction of the labor arbiters of the National Labor Relations Commission. The trial court initially deferred the motion, but later granted it and dismissed the complaint for lack of jurisdiction. Meneses moved for reconsideration, and the trial court denied the motion.
Instead of filing a notice of appeal, Meneses filed a petition for certiorari under Rule 45, but he filed it with the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals dismissed the petition, reasoning that the orders in question were final orders, that the only question raised concerned the jurisdiction of the lower court, and that the matter therefore fell within the exclusive appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. It also invoked the rule that an appeal taken by the wrong or inappropriate mode should be dismissed. Meneses moved for reconsideration, and the Court of Appeals denied the motion. He then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review, and the Supreme Court gave the petition due course and required the parties to submit their memoranda.
Facts
Meneses had worked for twelve years as an operator of a jumbo machine in the Perla Department of the company's plant in Tondo, Manila, where the ingredients of soap are mixed. In the course of his duties he had to go to another area of the plant to switch on a caustic system that feeds ingredients into the jumbo machine. As early as April 1986 he had recommended that the caustic switch be transferred nearer the jumbo machine. The company accepted the recommendation but failed to act on it.
The switch stood in the vicinity of several giant steel storage kettles of boiling soap oil, each fitted with steel covers strong enough to contain the pressure built up inside. Shortly before the accident, the company changed the cover of one of these kettles from steel to a cheaper but more brittle fiberglass cover. On the first of June 1987, at around half past three in the afternoon, as Meneses was leaving the caustic switch after turning it on, the fiberglass cover of the kettle exploded.
Meneses was drenched in, and burned by, boiling soap oil. He suffered third degree burns over eighty percent of his body surface, leaving highly visible scars; seven toes of his feet were amputated; he underwent psychiatric treatment; he spent six months confined in a hospital and seventeen months in physical therapy. After the explosion the company replaced the fiberglass cover with a steel cover and transferred the caustic switch nearer the jumbo machine. Meneses then sued for actual, moral, and exemplary damages and attorney's fees.
Issues
- Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in not certifying the petition to the Supreme Court under Section 3, Rule 50 of the Rules of Court, in light of the Victorias Milling case.
- Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in not reversing the trial court's judgment dismissing the complaint for lack of jurisdiction, the trial court having held that the labor tribunals rather than the civil courts had jurisdiction.
Applicable Provisions
Section 3, Rule 50 of the Rules of Court, which the petitioner invoked, provides:
Where the appeal taken is not authorized by these Rules, or where the appeal is taken to the wrong court, the appellate court shall dismiss the appeal; but the court may, in its discretion, certify the case to the proper court.
This is the provision on which Meneses relied to ask the Court of Appeals to pass his case up to the Supreme Court instead of dismissing it, and which the Supreme Court held no longer available to him.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petitioner's ground is devoid of merit. Section 3, Rule 50 gives him no sanctuary, because in Murillo versus Consul the Court had already ruled that there is no longer any justification for allowing transfers of erroneous appeals from one court to the other. The Court explained that the old provisions, Section 31 of the Judiciary Act of 1948 and Section 3, Rule 50, had reference to a situation in the past when appeals could be brought from the Court of First Instance either to the Court of Appeals or to the Supreme Court by the same procedure, so that a transfer entailed little difficulty or delay. Those provisions have been largely superseded and rendered functus officio, that is, no longer in force, by later statutes that wrought substantial changes in appellate procedure.
The Court stressed that at present, except in criminal cases where the penalty imposed is life imprisonment or reclusion perpetua, there is no way by which judgments of regional trial courts may be appealed to the Supreme Court except by petition for review on certiorari in accordance with Rule 45, and that it is not possible to take an appeal by certiorari to the Court of Appeals. It concluded that if an appeal is essayed to either court by the wrong procedure, the only course of action open is to dismiss the appeal. The Court also held that Victorias Milling did not modify Murillo, because in that case the Court applied the law controlling when the appellate court resolved the challenged motions, there having been a seasonable alternative motion to certify the case which Section 3 of Rule 50 then allowed.
On the second issue, the Court held that the trial court's order dismissing the complaint was, whether right or wrong, a final order, because it had put an end to the particular matter resolved and left nothing more to be done except its execution. The remedy against such an order is appeal, not certiorari. If the appeal raised solely questions of law, it should have been taken to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari; if it raised questions of fact and law, it should have been taken to the Court of Appeals by ordinary appeal. Having chosen the wrong remedy in the wrong court, Meneses could not be heard to complain. The Court found no reversible error in the dismissal and no longer found it necessary to discuss the other issues raised.
Doctrine
First, the remedy against a final order of a regional trial court is appeal, not certiorari. An order that puts an end to the particular matter resolved and leaves nothing more to be done except execution is final, and the availability of the remedy does not depend on whether the order was correct.
Second, the mode and forum of appeal are inseparable. An appeal raising purely questions of law is taken to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45; an appeal raising questions of fact and law is taken to the Court of Appeals by ordinary appeal. An appeal by certiorari to the Court of Appeals is not possible.
Third, an appeal taken by the wrong mode to the wrong court is dismissed, not transferred. Section 3, Rule 50 no longer authorizes certification to the proper court, and counsel must determine the errors to be raised, ascertain which court has appellate jurisdiction, and observe the requisites of appeal scrupulously, because any error may be fatal to the client's cause.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the petition for lack of merit, so the Court of Appeals' dismissal of Meneses's petition stands and the trial court's dismissal of his complaint is left undisturbed.
Remember This
Memorize the line that a final order is corrected by appeal, never by certiorari, and that an appeal taken by the wrong mode to the wrong court is dismissed, not transferred. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between questions of law and questions of fact in choosing between the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeals, and to test whether you know that the old certification rule under Section 3, Rule 50 is dead.