🎧 Case Brief Lecture

ANGEL GUSTILO, PETITIONER, VS. ESTANISLAO YUSAY, JUDGE OF THE COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE OF NEGROS OCCIDENTAL, RESPONDENT.

G.R. No. 1089. October 31, 1902 October 31, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Gustilo versus Yusay

The Case

This is an original action in the Supreme Court of the Philippine Islands, brought by Angel Gustilo against Estanislao Yusay, Judge of the Court of First Instance of Negros Occidental. Gustilo asks the Court to compel the judge to sign a bill of exceptions that the judge had refused to sign, so that Gustilo's case could be reviewed on appeal. The case matters because it fixes, in the earliest years of the Code of Civil Procedure, the strict and orderly way a litigant must preserve and raise objections: an exception to an order must be taken at the proper time, and an appeal from a judgment must be perfected in the manner the law prescribes. It is a foundational lesson on the finality of procedural steps.

Procedural History

In the Court of First Instance of Negros Occidental, the defendant demurred to the complaint. The demurrer was overruled, the case was tried, and on the thirtieth of August a judgment was entered against the defendant. On the fifth of September the defendant presented a so-called bill of exceptions. The judge failed to sign this bill. The defendant then came to the Supreme Court by petition, seeking relief under article 499 of the Code of Civil Procedure, asking that the judge be required to sign the bill. The Supreme Court resolved the petition in this decision.

Facts

The defendant in the court below filed a demurrer to the complaint. The court overruled the demurrer. The defendant did not take an exception to that order at the time he received notice of it. The case then proceeded to trial, and on the thirtieth of August the court entered judgment against the defendant.

On the fifth of September the defendant presented what he called a bill of exceptions. In it he stated that he based his exception upon the fact that his demurrer was overruled. He also stated that he appealed from the judgment. The judge declined to sign the bill of exceptions.

The defendant then filed a petition in the Supreme Court, attaching the proposed bill of exceptions, and asked for relief under article 499 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The petition was vague and indefinite, and the Court could not say that by his so-called appeal the defendant intended to present for review any questions other than those raised by his demurrer.

Issues

  • Whether or not a party who wishes to except to an order overruling a demurrer must take that exception forthwith upon receiving notice of the order, and cannot wait until after trial to raise it for the first time in a proposed bill of exceptions.
  • Whether or not an appeal from a judgment in an ordinary action is perfected only by presenting an exception to the judgment, having that exception incorporated in a bill of exceptions signed by the judge and certified to the Supreme Court.

Applicable Provisions

Article 142 of the Code of Civil Procedure governs the time for taking an exception to an order, and it provides:

An exception to the order overruling the demurrer should have been taken forthwith upon receiving notice thereof.

This fixes the moment for objecting: the exception must be taken immediately upon notice, not saved for later.

Article 143 of the Code of Civil Procedure governs the manner of appealing from a judgment, and it provides:

The only way of appealing from a judgment in an ordinary action is by presenting an exception to it, having that exception incorporated in a bill of exceptions signed by the judge and certified to this court.

This defines the exclusive method of appeal, so that a bill of exceptions signed by the judge is indispensable.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the exception to the order overruling the demurrer should have been taken forthwith upon receiving notice of that order. The defendant did not do so. He could not wait until after the trial and then, for the first time, except to the order by including a statement to that effect in his proposed bill of exceptions. The Court rested this on the statutory command that the exception be taken forthwith upon notice.

On the second issue, the Court held that the only way of appealing from a judgment in an ordinary action is by presenting an exception to it, having that exception incorporated in a bill of exceptions signed by the judge and certified to the Supreme Court. The Court also observed that the petition with the proposed bill of exceptions was very vague and indefinite, and it could not say that by his so-called appeal the defendant intended to present for review any questions other than those raised by his demurrer. Since the exception to the demurrer was not timely taken, and the appeal was not perfected in the manner the law requires, the petition could not succeed.

Doctrine

An exception to an order overruling a demurrer must be taken forthwith upon receiving notice of the order. A party may not sleep on the objection, proceed to trial, and then raise it for the first time in a proposed bill of exceptions. The time for excepting is fixed by article 142, and it is not a matter of convenience.

An appeal from a judgment in an ordinary action is perfected only in the manner prescribed by article 143: by presenting an exception to the judgment, having it incorporated in a bill of exceptions signed by the judge and certified to the Supreme Court. That is the exclusive mode, and a litigant who does not follow it has no appeal to speak of.

A petition that is vague and indefinite, and that does not clearly show the questions the petitioner intends to present for review, will not be read generously to supply what the law requires.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the relief sought, and the judge was not compelled to sign the bill of exceptions.

Remember This

Memorize the rule: an exception to an order overruling a demurrer must be taken forthwith upon notice, and an appeal from a judgment is perfected only by an exception incorporated in a bill of exceptions signed by the judge and certified to the Supreme Court. Examiners use this case to test the timely taking of exceptions and the mandatory manner of perfecting an appeal under the old Code of Civil Procedure.