🎧 Case Brief Lecture

LBC EXPRESS, INC., PETITIONER, VS. THE COURT OF APPEALS, ADOLFO M. CARLOTO, AND RURAL BANK OF LABASON, INC., RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 108670. September 21, 1994 September 21, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

LBC Express versus Court of Appeals

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by LBC Express, Inc. against the Court of Appeals, Adolfo Carloto, and the Rural Bank of Labason, Inc. The private respondents sued LBC for damages arising from the non-performance of its obligation to deliver a cashpack containing money and documents, and both the trial court and the Court of Appeals held LBC liable. The case matters because the Supreme Court uses it to fix two enduring rules: a corporation, being an artificial person, cannot recover moral damages, and in a breach of contract the defendant who did not act fraudulently or in bad faith is liable only for the natural and probable consequences of the breach, never for moral damages.

Procedural History

Adolfo Carloto filed an action for damages arising from non-performance of obligation before the Regional Trial Court of Dipolog City, and the complaint was later amended to join the Rural Bank of Labason, Inc. as a co-plaintiff. After hearing, the trial court rendered judgment ordering LBC to pay moral damages of 10,000 pesos, exemplary damages of 5,000 pesos, attorney's fees of 3,000 pesos, and litigation expenses of 1,000 pesos; to reimburse the rural bank 32,000 pesos in penalty interest with legal interest from the filing of the case; and to pay the costs. LBC appealed, and the Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment but deleted the award of attorney's fees. LBC's motion for reconsideration was denied, so LBC came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari.

Facts

Adolfo Carloto, the President-Manager of the Rural Bank of Labason, was in Cebu City on November 12, 1984, transacting business with the Central Bank Regional Office. He was instructed to proceed to Manila on or before November 21, 1984, to follow up the bank's plan of payment of its rediscounting obligations with the Central Bank's main office. He bought a round trip plane ticket and asked his sister, Elsie Carloto-Concha, to send him 1,000 pesos for pocket money, together with some rediscounting papers, through LBC's office at Dipolog City.

On November 16, 1984, Mrs. Concha, through her clerk Adelina Antigo, consigned the documents and the 1,000 pesos through LBC's Dipolog branch for delivery to Carloto in Cebu City. On November 17, 1984, the documents arrived but the cashpack did not. Carloto made personal follow-ups on that day and again on November 19 and 20, 1984, but LBC failed to deliver the money. He then traveled to Dipolog City on November 24, 1984, to claim the money at LBC's office, but his effort was again in vain. On November 27, 1984, he returned to LBC's office in Cebu City and was advised that the money had been returned to Dipolog City upon the shipper's request. He received the money only on December 15, 1984, less the revenue charges.

Carloto claimed that because of the delay he failed to submit the rediscounting documents to the Central Bank on time, and his rural bank was made to pay 32,000 pesos in penalty interest. LBC, for its part, alleged that the cashpack was forwarded to its Cebu City branch on November 22, 1984, and delivered the same day to Carloto's residence, but he was not around, so the delivery man served a claim notice. When Carloto did not claim the cashpack, it was returned to the shipper on November 23, 1984.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Rural Bank of Labason, Inc., being an artificial person, may be awarded moral damages.
  • Whether or not the award of 32,000 pesos as reimbursement of penalty interest was made with grave abuse of discretion.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals gravely abused its discretion in affirming the award of moral and exemplary damages despite LBC's performance of its obligation.

Applicable Provisions

Article 2217 of the Civil Code describes what moral damages compensate:

Moral damages include physical suffering, mental anguish, fright, serious anxiety, besmirched reputation, wounded feelings, moral shock, social humiliation, and similar injury. Though incapable of pecuniary computation, moral damages may be recovered if they are the proximate result of the defendant's wrongful act or omission.

This defines the injuries the Court holds a corporation cannot suffer, since it has no feelings, emotions, or senses.

Article 2232 of the Civil Code governs exemplary damages in contractual relations:

In contracts and quasi-contracts, the court may award exemplary damages if the defendant acted in a wanton, fraudulent, reckless, oppressive, or malevolent manner.

This is the standard the Court applies in testing whether exemplary damages may be awarded against LBC.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the Court of Appeals erred in awarding moral damages to the Rural Bank of Labason, Inc. A corporation is an artificial person, having existence only in legal contemplation; it has no feelings, no emotions, no senses, and therefore cannot experience physical suffering and mental anguish. Mental suffering can be experienced only by one having a nervous system, and it flows from the real ills, sorrows, and griefs of life, all of which an artificial person cannot suffer.

The Court likewise denied moral damages to Carloto himself. The right to recover moral damages is based on equity, and he who comes to court to demand equity must come with clean hands. Carloto was not without fault: he knew his bank's obligation would mature on November 21, 1984, he had the documents and the plane ticket, yet he tarried for days allegedly to claim his 1,000 pesos pocket money, which he said he needed to invite people for a snack or dinner. Because of his delayed trip, the rediscounting papers were not submitted on time and the bank was penalized. The Court found it revolting to its sense of ethics to use that attitude as a basis for damages.

On the remaining issues, the Court held that the respondents failed to show that LBC's late delivery was motivated by personal malice or bad faith, whether intentional or through gross negligence. The cashpack was consigned on a Friday and sent to Cebu on the next business day, so LBC could not be charged with gross neglect of duty. Bad faith cannot be presumed; it must be established by clear and convincing evidence. In breach of contract cases where the defendant is not shown to have acted fraudulently or in bad faith, liability is limited to the natural and probable consequences of the breach which the parties had foreseen or could reasonably have foreseen, and the damages will not include moral damages. With no basis for moral damages, the award of exemplary damages had no legal leg to support itself, since Article 2232 requires a wanton, fraudulent, reckless, oppressive, or malevolent manner, which the established facts did not warrant.

Doctrine

A corporation, being an artificial person with existence only in legal contemplation, has no feelings, emotions, or senses, and cannot experience physical suffering and mental anguish; it cannot, therefore, recover moral damages under Article 2217 of the Civil Code. The right to recover moral damages is based on equity, and a claimant who comes to court with unclean hands cannot recover them. In a breach of contract where the defendant is not shown to have acted fraudulently or in bad faith, liability for damages is limited to the natural and probable consequences of the breach which the parties foreseen or could reasonably have foreseen, and excludes moral damages. Bad faith cannot be presumed; it must be established by clear and convincing evidence. Exemplary damages in a contractual relationship may be awarded only if the defendant acted in a wanton, fraudulent, reckless, oppressive, or malevolent manner under Article 2232 of the Civil Code.

Disposition

The Court reversed and set aside the decision of the Court of Appeals and ordered the dismissal of the complaint, with no costs; LBC won.

Remember This

The line worth memorizing is that a corporation has no nervous system and so can suffer no mental anguish, and that absent bad faith a breaching party owes only the natural and probable consequences of the breach, never moral damages. Examiners use this case to test the corporate incapacity to recover moral damages and the rule that bad faith is never presumed in breach of contract.