ALBERTO S. ACENAS II, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, HON. ANTONIO P. SOLANO, IN HIS CAPACITY AS PRESIDING JUDGE OF THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURT OF QUEZON CITY, BRANCH 86, RODRIGO…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Acenas versus Court of Appeals
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari and prohibition brought by Alberto S. Acenas II against the Court of Appeals and the presiding judge of the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, Branch 86, with Rodrigo S. Ligon as private respondent. Acenas seeks to reverse the denial of his motion for leave to intervene in a collection suit filed by Ligon against Evelyn Guanzon, a woman the complaint describes as Acenas's wife but whom Acenas claims he is not married to. The case matters because it is the Supreme Court's clearest statement on the liberality owed to a motion for intervention filed by a third party who claims ownership of the very property attached in the main case, and on how that liberality interacts with the court's jurisdiction over the res.
Procedural History
Ligon filed a complaint for recovery of a sum of money and damages with a prayer for a writ of attachment against Evelyn Guanzon before Branch 86 of the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City. Acenas moved for leave to intervene. The trial court granted Ligon's prayer for a writ of attachment upon posting of an attachment bond, and then denied Acenas's motion for leave to intervene. Guanzon was declared in default, Ligon presented evidence ex parte, and the trial court rendered judgment against Guanzon. Acenas then filed an affidavit of third party claim; after hearing, the trial court denied the third party claim and his prayer to discharge the attachment. Acenas went to the Court of Appeals on certiorari and prohibition with preliminary injunction to stop the trial court from issuing a writ of execution. The Court of Appeals dismissed the petition, without prejudice to Acenas's right to vindicate his claim in a proper action. Hence this petition before the Supreme Court.
Facts
Rodrigo Ligon sued Evelyn Guanzon, also known as Evelyn Lalic or Evelyn Acenas, for jewelries she had obtained from him over several years and paid for with postdated checks that were later dishonored because her bank accounts had been closed. The complaint alleged that Guanzon had left for abroad to avoid him and could no longer be located, and it identified among her properties a one-half ownership share in a parcel of land and the house thereon covered by Transfer Certificate of Title Number 44209, registered in the name of Alberto S. Acenas, Junior, married to Evelyn Lalic, located in Barrio Barranca, Mandaluyong.
It is undisputed that Guanzon had already gone abroad when Ligon filed the complaint. Despite this, and despite the in personam character of the case, the deputy sheriff made a substituted service of summons and complaint on Guanzon's daughter-in-law at a Mandaluyong address. Shortly thereafter, Acenas filed a motion for leave to intervene, claiming that the land covered by the title was his exclusive property and that Guanzon had no one-half interest in it because he was not married to her. The trial court granted Ligon's prayer for a writ of attachment upon an attachment bond, then denied Acenas's motion for leave to intervene. Guanzon was declared in default, and judgment was rendered ordering her to pay Ligon the principal sum plus interest, moral damages, exemplary damages, attorney's fees, and costs.
To prevent execution over his property, Acenas filed an affidavit of third party claim, reiterating absolute ownership of the land. After hearing, the trial court denied the third party claim and his prayer to discharge the attachment. Acenas then went to the Court of Appeals on certiorari and prohibition, which dismissed the petition without prejudice to his right to vindicate his claim in a proper action.
Issues
- Whether or not petitioner Acenas should be allowed to intervene in the collection case against Evelyn Guanzon.
- Whether or not the trial court's denial of intervention, and the Court of Appeals' dismissal of the petition, should be set aside in the greater interest of justice.
Applicable Provisions
Section 2 of Rule 12 of the Rules of Court, on intervention, provides:
Section 2. Intervention. A person may, before or during a trial be permitted by the court, in its discretion, to intervene in an action, if he has legal interest in the matter in litigation, or in the success of either of the parties, or an interest against both, or when he is so situated as to be adversely affected by a distribution or other disposition of property in the custody of the court or of an officer thereof.
This is the governing rule, and the entire case turns on whether Acenas falls within its requirement of a legal interest.
The same Section 2 continues, on the motion for intervention:
(a) Motion for intervention. A person desiring to intervene shall file a motion for leave of court with notice upon all the parties to the action.
Acenas complied with this requirement when he filed his motion for leave to intervene shortly after the complaint was served.
And on the court's discretion, the same Section 2 provides:
(b) Discretion of court. In allowing or disallowing a motion for intervention, the court, in the exercise of discretion, shall consider whether or not the intervention will unduly delay or prejudice the adjudication of the rights of the original parties and whether or not the intervenor's rights may be fully protected in a separate proceeding.
These are the two factors the Court weighed, and it found that neither justified denying Acenas's intervention.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court granted the petition and allowed Acenas to intervene. It held that while Acenas has shown no interest in the checks or the jewelries in litigation, and no interest in the success of either party or against both, he has shown a legal interest in the attached real property covered by the title, which is under threat of being levied on execution and sold at public auction. The Court stressed that when Ligon filed the complaint, Guanzon had already gone abroad, so the trial court acquired jurisdiction over the case on the basis of its jurisdiction over the res, that is, the property allegedly one-half owned by Guanzon but now claimed by Acenas as his exclusive property. Since that same property gave the court jurisdiction and is now claimed by Acenas, the trial court should have been more liberal in allowing intervention, to avoid multiplicity of suits, to determine if the court's jurisdiction was validly exercised, and so that the real controversy may be threshed out and the case decided on the merits without unnecessary delay.
On the second issue, the Court held that Acenas's claim could not possibly be better threshed out in a separate proceeding, because his cause of action is interwoven with the civil case, and his defense and evidence would be no different from what he would present in a separate action. Admitting the intervention avoids a multiplicity of suits and leads toward a definitive resolution. The Court also noted, though it did not bar relief on that ground, that it viewed with disfavor Acenas's deceit in denying being married to Evelyn Lalic, who was described in the title as his wife and who was his co-mortgagor in favor of Pilipinas Shell Petroleum Corporation. Nevertheless, in the greater interest of justice, the Court admitted the intervention.
Doctrine
A person may intervene when he has a legal interest in the matter in litigation, in the success of either party, or an interest against both, or when he is so situated as to be adversely affected by a distribution or other disposition of property in the custody of the court or of an officer thereof. A third party who claims ownership of property attached in the main case has such a legal interest, even if he has no interest in the subject matter of the original complaint. Where the property attached is the very res that gave the court jurisdiction over an absent defendant, the court should be more liberal in allowing intervention, to avoid multiplicity of suits and to determine whether jurisdiction was validly exercised. The liberality is most manifest in the early stages of a lawsuit, especially where the motion for leave to intervene is filed before trial. The court's discretion under the rule must consider whether intervention will unduly delay or prejudice the adjudication of the rights of the original parties, and whether the intervenor's rights may be fully protected in a separate proceeding; where the intervenor's cause of action is interwoven with the main case, a separate proceeding is not the better remedy.
Disposition
The petition was granted; the decision of the Court of Appeals was set aside, and the trial court was ordered to allow Acenas to intervene in the collection case.
Remember This
The one line to memorize: a third party claiming ownership of property attached in the main case has a legal interest that warrants intervention, especially where that property is the res that gave the court jurisdiction. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of intervention under Rule 12, Section 2, and the interplay between intervention and jurisdiction over the res in actions against defendants who have left the country.