🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PHILIPPINE NATIONAL BANK, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, REMEDIOS JAYME-FERNANDEZ AND AMADO FERNANDEZ, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 107569. November 08, 1994 November 8, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Philippine National Bank versus Jayme-Fernandez

The Case

This is a petition for review brought by the Philippine National Bank against the spouses Remedios Jayme-Fernandez and Amado Fernandez, borrowers who obtained a cottage industry loan secured by real estate and chattel mortgages. The bank unilaterally raised the interest rate on the loan from twelve percent to twenty-five, then thirty, then forty-two percent, and the borrowers sued. The case matters because it fixes the rule that an escalation clause in a loan agreement does not license the lender to raise the interest rate at will; any adjustment requires the mutual assent of the parties, and a stipulation to the contrary offends the principle of mutuality of contracts.

Procedural History

The private respondents filed a complaint for specific performance against the Philippine National Bank and the National Cottage Industries Development Authority before the Regional Trial Court of Cebu City, praying for a release of mortgage, damages, and other relief. The trial court dismissed the complaint. On appeal, the Court of Appeals reversed the dismissal as to the bank and disallowed the increases in interest rates, ordering the bank to re-apply the twelve percent per annum rate to the indebtedness and to take the appropriate charges from the payment of eighty-one thousand pesos made in December 1985, with any balance likewise charged twelve percent interest. The bank then elevated the matter to the Supreme Court by petition for review.

Facts

On April 7, 1982, the Fernandez spouses, as owners of a registered cottage enterprise, obtained a loan of fifty thousand pesos from the Philippine National Bank under the Cottage Industry Guaranty Loan Fund, evidenced by a Credit Agreement and a Promissory Note. The loan was to be amortized over three years at twelve percent interest annually. To secure it, the spouses executed a Real Estate Mortgage over a parcel of unregistered agricultural land in Toledo City and a Chattel Mortgage over a thermo plastic-forming machine. On February 17, 1983, they obtained an additional loan of fifty thousand pesos, executing another Promissory Note with the same terms, and a new Credit Agreement raising the loan amount to one hundred thousand pesos. As additional security, they constituted another real estate mortgage over two registered parcels in Cebu City.

The Credit Agreement, the Promissory Notes, and the Real Estate Mortgage all carried escalation clauses. The Credit Agreement reserved to the bank the right to increase the interest rate within the limits allowed by law at any time depending on whatever policy it may adopt in the future, provided that the rate shall be correspondingly decreased if the applicable maximum is reduced by law or by the Monetary Board. The Promissory Note authorized the bank to raise the rate beyond twelve percent but only within the limits allowed by law.

In a letter dated August 1, 1984, the bank informed the spouses that the interest rate on their loan was now twenty-five percent per annum plus a six percent penalty on past dues. The bank further increased the rate to thirty percent on October 15, 1984, and to forty-two percent on October 25, 1984. As of December 1985, the spouses had an outstanding principal account of eighty-one thousand pesos, of which eighteen thousand five hundred twenty-three pesos and fourteen centavos was credited to principal, fifty-seven thousand four hundred eighty-eight pesos and eighty-nine centavos to interest, and the rest to penalty and other charges, leaving an unpaid principal obligation of sixty-two thousand eight hundred thirty pesos and thirty-two centavos. The spouses sought to have the bank re-adopt the twelve percent rate and condone the interest and penalties, but to no avail.

Issues

  • Whether or not the increases in interest rates made by the bank were authorized.
  • Whether or not the Credit Agreement and the Promissory Notes are the law between the parties.
  • Whether or not Central Bank Circular No. 773 and Central Bank Circular No. 905 are applicable.
  • Whether or not the private respondents are estopped from questioning the increase of the rate of interest made by the petitioner.

Applicable Provisions

Section 2 of Presidential Decree No. 1684, amending the Usury Law, provides:

Section 2. The same Act is hereby amended by adding a new section after Section 7, to read as follows: Sec. 7-a. Parties to an agreement pertaining to a loan or forbearance of money, goods or credits may stipulate that the rate of interest agreed upon may be increased in the event that the applicable maximum rate of interest is increased by law or by the Monetary Board: Provided, That such stipulation shall be valid only if there is also a stipulation in the agreement that the rate of interest agreed upon shall be reduced in the event that the applicable maximum rate of interest is reduced by law or by the Monetary Board: Provided further, That the adjustment in the rate of interest agreed upon shall take effect on or after the effectivity of the increase or decrease in the maximum rate of interest.

This provision authorizes an escalation clause but only where the increase tracks a change in the maximum rate fixed by law or by the Monetary Board, and it requires a matching de-escalation clause.

Section 5 of Central Bank Circular No. 905, series of 1982, provides:

Sec. 5. Section 1303 of the Manual of Regulations (for Banks and Other Financial Intermediaries) is hereby amended to read as follows: SEC. 1303. Interest and Other Charges. The rate of interest, including commissions, premiums, fees and other charges, on any loan, or forbearance of any money, goods or credits, regardless of maturity and whether secured or unsecured, shall not be subject to any ceiling prescribed under or pursuant to the Usury Law, as amended.

This circular removed the usury ceiling, but the Court held it did not authorize either party to raise the rate unilaterally without the other's consent.

Article 1308 of the Civil Code provides:

ART. 1308. The contract must bind both contracting parties; its validity or compliance cannot be left to the will of one of them.

This is the mutuality of contracts that the bank's unilateral increases violated.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the increases were unauthorized. Presidential Decree No. 1684 and Central Bank Circular No. 905 allow contracting parties to stipulate freely regarding any subsequent adjustment in the interest rate, upward or downward, but they did not authorize either party to unilaterally raise the rate without the other's consent. There can be no contract in the true sense without mutual assent, and contract changes must be made with the consent of the contracting parties, especially when the change affects a vital component such as the rate of interest. The Court quoted its earlier ruling:

The unilateral action of the PNB in increasing the interest rate on the private respondent's loan violated the mutuality of contracts ordained in Article 1308 of the Civil Code.

On the second issue, the Court rejected the bank's posturing that the escalation clause gave it an unbridled right to adjust the rate upward. That would take away from the borrowers the right to assent to an important modification and would negate the element of mutuality. A contract containing a condition which makes its fulfillment dependent exclusively upon the uncontrolled will of one of the contracting parties is void.

On the third issue, the Court found that the law and the circular did not support the bank's unilateral action; they merely permitted the parties to agree on adjustments.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that the borrowers were not estopped. No one receiving a proposal to change a contract is obliged to answer the proposal, and silence per se cannot be construed as acceptance. The circumstances did not show that the borrowers implicitly agreed to increases that were, by any standard, too sudden and too stiff.

Doctrine

An escalation clause is valid under Section 2 of Presidential Decree No. 1684 only if it provides for an increase within the limits allowed by law and a corresponding decrease when the maximum rate is reduced. The lender cannot unilaterally raise the interest rate; any adjustment requires the mutual assent of the parties, because Article 1308 of the Civil Code ordains that the contract must bind both contracting parties and its compliance cannot be left to the will of one of them. A stipulation giving one party uncontrolled power to modify the rate is void for violating mutuality, and the borrower's silence on a proposed increase does not amount to acceptance.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the petition for lack of merit and affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeals, with costs against the petitioner bank.

Remember This

The single line to memorize: an escalation clause does not authorize a unilateral increase in the interest rate, for that violates the mutuality of contracts under Article 1308 of the Civil Code. Examiners use this case to test the validity of escalation clauses, the requirement of mutual assent in loan modifications, and the rule that silence is not acceptance.