🎧 Case Brief Lecture

TEODORO ARAOS, ALEJANDRO LANG­CAUAN, EUGENIA PITOY, SPOUSES PERFECTO REYES AND ROSARIO REYES, RUTH RAYCO, PROSPERO PERALTA, MYRNA MENDOZA, AND SPOUSES REDENTOR COMINTAN AND LUCY…

G.R. No. 107057. June 02, 1994 June 2, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Araos versus Jovan Land

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by long-time lessees of a ten-door apartment building in Sta. Ana, Manila against Jovan Land, Incorporated, the purchaser of the property, in a batch of unlawful detainer cases. The tenants ask the Supreme Court to reverse the Court of Appeals, which had reinstated the Metropolitan Trial Court's judgment of ejectment and, more importantly for the Court's resolution, its award of steeply increased monthly rentals. The case matters because it draws a bright line on the power of courts in ejectment suits: a court may award reasonable compensation for the use and occupation of the premises, but it may not, on its own, fix a new and higher rent where the lessor never demanded that increase from the tenant.

Procedural History

The private respondent filed ten separate complaints for unlawful detainer before the Metropolitan Trial Court of Manila, Branch 26, which rendered a joint judgment ordering the defendants to vacate and to pay rental arrearages, reasonable compensation at increased monthly rates, attorney's fees, and costs. The lessees appealed to the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 38, which reversed the Metropolitan Trial Court. The Regional Trial Court held that the month-to-month lease, even if expired under Article 1687 of the Civil Code, could not be a ground for judicial ejectment because the rent control law had suspended paragraph 1 of Article 1673, and it found the rental increase iniquitous and unconscionable. The private respondent then filed a petition for review with the Court of Appeals, which reversed the Regional Trial Court and affirmed the Metropolitan Trial Court, holding that an oral month-to-month lease is a lease with a definite period that expires upon demand to vacate. The lessees came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari, which was initially denied but later reinstated and given due course on a prima facie showing of merit on the issue of rental rates.

Facts

The petitioners had occupied their respective units in the ten-door apartment building for some twenty-five years, originally under a written lease with the owner, Vivien Bernardino, which expired on 31 January 1988. Even after expiry, they peacefully stayed on and the lessor continued to collect monthly rentals despite the absence of a written contract.

On 11 July 1991, the apartment was sold to the private respondent, Jovan Land, Incorporated. Three days later, on 15 July 1991, demands to vacate were made simultaneously by Bernardino and the private respondent. When the demands went unheeded, ten separate unlawful detainer cases were filed.

The Metropolitan Trial Court held that the leases were on a month-to-month basis and had expired, ordered the tenants to vacate, and fixed increased monthly rentals, taking into account that the area was highly commercialized. The former rentals ranged from 710 pesos to 945 pesos a month, while the increased rentals were fixed at 4,500 pesos or 6,000 pesos a month. The records showed no prior dispute over rentals and no demand for an increase made by the private respondent or its predecessor upon the petitioners; the demand letters spoke only of the purchase of the units.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals and the Metropolitan Trial Court validly decreed an increase in the monthly rates of rentals in the ejectment cases.
  • Whether or not the courts may fix increased rentals for the parties absent a valid demand for increased rent made by the lessor upon the lessee.

Applicable Provisions

Section 6 of Batas Pambansa Blg. 25, as amended by Batas Pambansa Blg. 877, provides:

SEC. 6. Application of the Civil Code and the Rules of Court of the Philippines. -- Except when the lease is for a definite period, the provisions of paragraph (1) of Article 1673 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, insofar as they refer to residential units covered by this Act, shall be suspended during the effectivity of this Act, but other provisions of the Civil Code and the Rules of Court on lease contracts, insofar as they are not in conflict with the provisions of this Act shall apply.

This is the provision the Regional Trial Court relied on to hold that the expiration of the month-to-month lease could not ground ejectment, and which the Court of Appeals read differently in the light of the amendatory law.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that there is no basis for the increase in the rentals, and resolved the matter in favor of the petitioners. The rule is settled that in forcible entry or unlawful detainer cases, the only damage that can be recovered is the fair rental value or the reasonable compensation for the use and occupation of the leased property. The reason is that the only issue in ejectment is rightful possession; hence the damages recoverable are those the plaintiff could have sustained as a mere possessor, or those caused by the loss of the use and occupation of the property, not damages having no direct relation to the loss of material possession.

On the second issue, the Court stressed that although the rent control laws allow unilateral increases by the lessor within the period and maximum rates provided, the demand for such increase must still be made upon the lessee himself. The courts have no authority to fix the same for the parties where no valid demand for an increased rent has been made by the lessor. The Court cited its earlier ruling in Orlino versus Court of Appeals, where it reversed an award of rental increase that was based merely on the prayer in the complaint although no previous demand was made on the defendant-lessee. In this case, the demand letters mentioned only the purchase of the apartment units; nothing showed any prior dispute on rentals or any demand for increased rentals by the private respondent or its predecessor. Hence, the Metropolitan Trial Court had no authority to decree the increase.

Doctrine

First, in forcible entry and unlawful detainer cases, the only damage recoverable is the fair rental value or reasonable compensation for the use and occupation of the leased property, because the sole issue is rightful possession. Second, while rent control laws permit unilateral increases by the lessor within the period and maximum rates fixed by law, the demand for the increase must be made upon the lessee himself; courts have no authority to fix increased rentals for the parties where no valid demand for increased rent has been made by the lessor. These rules tie directly to Section 6 of Batas Pambansa Blg. 25, as amended, which governs the suspension of paragraph 1 of Article 1673 of the Civil Code but does not empower the courts to impose new rents on their own.

Disposition

The petition was partly granted: the Court modified the challenged decisions by setting aside the increase in rentals and directing the petitioners to pay accumulated rentals from 15 July 1991 until they effectively vacate, at the same monthly rates they were paying before 15 July 1991, with interest at the legal rate, and made no pronouncement as to costs.

Remember This

Memorize this line: in ejectment, the court awards only reasonable compensation for use and occupation, and it cannot fix a higher rent that the lessor never demanded from the tenant. Examiners use this case to test the limits of a court's award in unlawful detainer and the requirement of a prior demand for rental increase under the rent control laws.