THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. PABLO JUDIT, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Judit
The Case
This is a criminal case from the early years of the American regime in the Philippines. The United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted Pablo Judit, the defendant and appellant, for having bitten off a part of the ear of an elderly man named Apinan. The question that gives the case its lasting value is a definitional one: whether the loss of a portion of an ear amounts to a deformity under the old Penal Code. The Supreme Court said yes, and that holding is why the case is still taught — it fixes the meaning of deformity for purposes of the graver penalties attached to serious physical injuries.
Procedural History
The case began in the trial court, which convicted Pablo Judit and imposed the penalty in its medium grade, together with an indemnification fixed at an appropriate sum. Judit appealed his conviction. The appeal came before the Supreme Court, which reviewed the judgment of conviction and the penalty imposed. The Court affirmed the conviction in all respects and returned the case to the court below for execution of the judgment.
Facts
The defendant and his brother were fighting and making a disturbance in their house. Apinan, an elderly man, reproved them for the noise and the disturbance.
Incensed by that rebuke, the defendant turned on Apinan and bit off a part of one of the old man's ears.
That is the whole of the material narrative: a disturbance, a reproof by an elderly neighbor, and a retaliatory act of mutilation. The case therefore turned not on disputed facts but on the legal characterization of the injury — whether the missing portion of the ear was a deformity within the meaning of the Penal Code.
Issues
- Whether or not the loss of a portion of an ear constitutes a deformity within the meaning of article 416, number 3, of the Penal Code.
- Whether or not the conviction and the penalty imposed in the medium grade, absent any extenuating or aggravating circumstance, were correct.
Applicable Provisions
Article 416, number 3, of the Penal Code, as applied by the Court, provides:
The loss of a portion of an ear constitutes a deformity within the meaning of article 416, No. 3, of the Code.
This is the provision the decision construes, and it bears on the case because the classification of the injury as a deformity determines the gravity of the offense and therefore the penalty.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the loss of a portion of an ear is a deformity within the meaning of article 416, number 3, of the Code. The Court rested this on prior authority, citing the judgment in cassation of October 28, 1887, for the proposition that:
The loss of a portion of an ear constitutes a deformity within the meaning of article 416, No. 3, of the Code.
On the second issue, the Court held that the conviction was right. In the absence of either extenuating or aggravating circumstances, the penalty was properly applied in the medium grade, and the indemnification was fixed at an appropriate sum. The judgment was therefore affirmed in all respects.
Doctrine
Two rules may be carried into an answer. First, the loss of a portion of an ear is a deformity within the meaning of article 416, number 3, of the Penal Code. The mutilation need not remove the whole ear; the loss of a part suffices, because the provision speaks of deformity, and a missing portion of the ear deforms the person. Second, where neither extenuating nor aggravating circumstances attend the offense, the penalty is imposed in its medium grade, and the indemnification is fixed at an appropriate sum. The case is a reminder that the classification of the injury — deformity or not — controls the gravity of the offense and hence the penalty, and that the Court will follow a settled construction of the Code where one exists.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of conviction in all respects and returned the case to the court below for execution of the judgment; Pablo Judit lost his appeal.
Remember This
Memorize the line: the loss of a portion of an ear is a deformity under article 416, number 3, of the Penal Code. Examiners use this case to test the definition of deformity in serious physical injuries, and to test whether a candidate knows that the medium grade applies absent extenuating or aggravating circumstances.