🎧 Case Brief Lecture

SITIA TECO, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, VS. THE HEIRS OF BALBINO VENTURA HOCORMA, DEFENDANTS AND APPELLEES.

G.R. No. 1066. November 22, 1902 November 22, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Sitia Teco versus the Heirs of Balbino Ventura Hocorma

The Case

Sitia Teco, the plaintiff, sued the heirs of Don Balbino Ventura Hocorma in the Court of First Instance of Manila, seeking to establish against them a contract of lease over a plot of land on Calle Santa Elena in the District of Tondo. The plaintiff claimed that the deceased had let him the lot so that he could build upon it, and that the heirs, by collecting the monthly rents, had ratified that contract. The heirs resisted, insisting that the lease was for no fixed term, that the rent was monthly, and that under the Civil Code the lease ended at the expiration of the month upon their notice. The case matters because it fixes the rule on monthly leases of no fixed duration and because it teaches a hard procedural lesson: an appeal does not revive a dissolved interlocutory injunction, and a defective bill of exceptions will not carry an applicant to relief.

Procedural History

The action was commenced in the Court of First Instance of Manila. During the pendency of the suit the plaintiff applied for a preliminary injunction, on the ground that the house he had placed on the lot was destroyed by order of the municipality, that the defendants had repossessed themselves of the premises, and that they were preparing to build a house thereon. After trial, judgment was rendered against the plaintiff on the merits, and the injunction was dissolved. The plaintiff appealed by bill of exceptions. Before the Supreme Court he moved to restore the injunction, arguing that the judgment dissolving it had lost its operative effect by virtue of the appeal and the giving of a supersedeas bond. He also asked for a preliminary injunction under the provisions of section 164 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1901. The case thus reached the Supreme Court on appeal by bill of exceptions.

Facts

During his lifetime, Don Balbino Ventura Hocorma entered into a rental contract with Sitia Teco over a plot of land on Calle Santa Elena, District of Tondo, city of Manila. According to the plaintiff, the land was let to him for the purpose of building upon it. After the death of Don Balbino, his heirs collected the monthly rents due under the lease, and the plaintiff says that by doing so they ratified the rental contract.

Later, the plaintiff alleged, the defendants without just cause refused to receive the amount due for the month of February, and continued to refuse the rents. The plaintiff thereupon sought to establish the rental contract against them. The defendants denied that the contract contained any provision about building a structure on the premises, and denied any ratification from which it might be inferred that the plaintiff was to use the premises for any particular purpose.

The defendants further alleged that the contract was for no fixed term, that the rent was monthly, and that the lease therefore ceased at the expiration of the month without need of special notice. They elected to terminate the lease at the end of the month and gave the plaintiff notice of that intention. Meanwhile, the house the plaintiff had placed on the lot was destroyed by order of the municipality, and the defendants repossessed the premises and were preparing to build a house thereon.

Issues

  • Whether or not article 1581 of the Civil Code applies to a lease of land for no fixed term where the rent is fixed by the month, so that the lease ceases at the expiration of the month without the necessity of special notice.
  • Whether or not the owners were at liberty to terminate the lease at the end of the month, the rent having been fixed by the month.
  • Whether or not the plaintiff is entitled to have the interlocutory injunction restored on appeal, or to a new preliminary injunction, where his right to possession of the property is not shown.

Applicable Provisions

Article 1581 of the Civil Code, as invoked by the defendants, provides:

The lease ceases, without the necessity of a special notice, at the expiration of the month.

This is the provision on which the defendants rested their right to end the lease at the close of any month, and which the plaintiff argued should not apply because the lot was leased for the purpose of placing a building thereon.

Section 164 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1901, is the provision under which the plaintiff sought a preliminary injunction from the Supreme Court:

The applicant has also asked a preliminary injunction under the provisions of section 164 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1901.

The Court found that the application did not bring the plaintiff within the relief that provision affords, because his right to possession was not shown.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that there was no reason why article 1581 of the Civil Code should not apply, and that the owners were at liberty to terminate the lease at the end of the month, the rent having been fixed by the month. The plaintiff's contention that the provision should not govern because the lot was leased for the purpose of placing a building thereon did not persuade the Court. The Court added that if any equities could exist on account of the erection of a building upon the land, a question upon which it expressed no opinion, the building having been demolished would render them ineffectual.

On the second issue, the Court confirmed that the owners could terminate the lease at the end of any month, and that they had done so by electing to terminate and giving notice of that intention.

On the third issue, the Court refused to restore the injunction. It relied on its earlier ruling in Watson and Company versus Enriquez, decided on October 26, 1902, that an appeal from an order dissolving an injunction does not suspend the operation of the decision so as to revive the interlocutory injunction. As to the request for a new preliminary injunction, the Court said that after a preliminary injunction has been issued by the Court of First Instance, a full hearing had on the merits, the case determined, the injunction dissolved, and an appeal taken, it was sufficient to say that the application does not show that the plaintiff is entitled to the relief he requests, in that his right to the possession of the property is not shown. The Court also observed that the bill of exceptions was defective in a material respect, since it did not appear from it that any exception was taken to any order, ruling, or judgment of the court, and that the application upon which the interlocutory injunction was granted was entirely omitted from the bill.

Doctrine

A lease for no fixed term, with rent fixed by the month, falls squarely under article 1581 of the Civil Code: the lease ceases at the expiration of the month without the necessity of a special notice. The lessor may terminate it at the end of any month, and the fact that the land was let for the purpose of building thereon does not take the lease out of the provision. Any equities arising from the erection of a building, assuming they exist, are rendered ineffectual once the building is demolished.

Procedurally, an appeal from an order dissolving an injunction does not suspend the operation of the decision so as to revive the interlocutory injunction. A party seeking a preliminary injunction must show a right to the possession of the property in dispute; absent that showing, the application must fail. And a bill of exceptions that does not show that an exception was taken to any order, ruling, or judgment is defective in a material respect.

Disposition

The judgment went against the plaintiff on the merits, the injunction was dissolved, and the Supreme Court denied the application to restore or grant the injunction, with costs of the application adjudged against the plaintiff.

Remember This

Memorize this line: a monthly lease for no fixed term ceases at the expiration of the month without the necessity of a special notice, and an appeal does not revive a dissolved injunction. Examiners use this case for article 1581 of the Civil Code and for the rule that a preliminary injunction will not issue where the applicant's right to possession is not shown.