A. S. WATSON & CO., LIMITED, PLAINTIFFS AND APPELLANTS, VS. RAFAEL ENRIQUEZ ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLEES.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Watson and Company versus Enriquez
The Case
This is a case about the life and death of a preliminary injunction. A. S. Watson and Company, Limited, sued Rafael Enriquez and others and, at the very start, obtained a preliminary injunction as prayed for in its complaint. The trial court later decided the case against the plaintiff and dissolved the injunction. The plaintiff appealed and then asked the Supreme Court to keep the injunction alive while the appeal was pending. The case matters because it fixes a rule every litigator must know: an appeal does not by itself revive an injunction that the lower court has dissolved, and the appellate court will grant interim relief only when the probabilities of the appellant's success are strong enough to justify it.
Procedural History
The plaintiff commenced the action and obtained a preliminary injunction at the outset. The case was afterwards tried, and in September 1902 the trial court entered a final judgment in favor of the defendants and dissolved the temporary injunction. On the twentieth of September a bill of exceptions was perfected and signed by the judge, and a certified copy was transmitted to the Supreme Court. Once in the Supreme Court, the plaintiff filed a motion asking that the preliminary injunction be continued. The Supreme Court resolved that motion in this decision.
Facts
A. S. Watson and Company, Limited, brought suit against Rafael Enriquez and others. At the commencement of the action the plaintiff obtained a preliminary injunction as prayed for in its complaint, so the defendants were restrained while the case proceeded.
The case was tried, and in September 1902 the trial court rendered a final judgment in favor of the defendants. In that same judgment the temporary injunction was dissolved. The plaintiff did not accept the judgment.
On the twentieth of September the plaintiff perfected a bill of exceptions, which the judge signed, and a certified copy was transmitted to the Supreme Court. The plaintiff then moved in the Supreme Court to have the preliminary injunction continued in force during the appeal. The motion rested on the bill of exceptions and upon nothing else.
Issues
- Whether or not the filing of the bill of exceptions continued in force the preliminary injunction that the trial court had dissolved in its final judgment.
- Whether or not the Supreme Court has the power to grant a preliminary injunction in a case pending before it on a bill of exceptions.
- Whether or not the circumstances of this case justified the Supreme Court in granting the temporary relief asked for.
Applicable Provisions
Article 144 of the Law of Civil Procedure, then in force, provides:
But the filing of a bill of exceptions shall of itself stay execution until the final determination of the action, unless, etc.
The Court compared this provision with the federal supersedeas statute and held that a stay of execution is not the same thing as the continuance of a dissolved injunction.
Article 163 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides:
A preliminary injunction may be granted by any judge of the Supreme Court in any action pending in the Supreme Court.
The Court read this language broadly, as reaching not only actions commenced in the Supreme Court originally but also actions pending there on a bill of exceptions or appeal.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the filing of the bill of exceptions did not operate to revive the preliminary injunction that was dissolved in and by the final judgment. The Court noted that Article 144 stays execution, and it adopted the American doctrine construing the word supersedeas, which was defined as follows:
A supersedeas, properly so called, is a suspension of the power of the court below to issue an execution on the judgment or decree appealed from; or, if a writ of execution has issued, it is a prohibition emanating from the court of appeals against the execution of the writ.
The Court then adopted the general ruling of the Supreme Court of the United States:
The general ruling is well settled that an appeal from a decree granting, refusing, or dissolving an injunction does not disturb its operative effect. When an injunction has been dissolved it can not be revived except by a new exercise of judicial power, and no appeal by a dissatisfied party can of itself revive it.
The Court reinforced this with the reasoning that to allow a plaintiff, after a full trial in which the judge has decided that neither upon the facts nor the law is the plaintiff entitled to any relief, to continue an injunction in force simply by appealing and giving a supersedeas bond would be manifestly unjust.
On the second issue, the Court held that it does have the power to grant a preliminary injunction in a case pending before it on a bill of exceptions, because the language of Article 163 is broad enough to include such actions. The Court also held that the judge below retains the power, if the purposes of justice require it, to order a continuance of the status quo until the appellate court decides or orders otherwise.
On the third issue, the Court looked into the record far enough to satisfy itself that the probabilities of the plaintiff prevailing in the Supreme Court were not strong enough to justify the temporary relief asked. The motion was therefore denied.
Doctrine
An appeal from a decree granting, refusing, or dissolving an injunction does not disturb its operative effect. Once an injunction has been dissolved, it cannot be revived except by a new exercise of judicial power, and no appeal by a dissatisfied party can of itself revive it. The filing of a bill of exceptions under Article 144 of the Law of Civil Procedure stays execution, but it does not continue a dissolved injunction in force.
The Supreme Court may itself grant a preliminary injunction in any action pending before it, including an action pending on a bill of exceptions or appeal, under Article 163 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The trial judge may also, when the purposes of justice require it, order a continuance of the status quo pending appeal. But the appellate court will grant such interim relief only when the probabilities of the appellant's success are strong enough to justify it.
Disposition
The motion to continue the preliminary injunction was denied, and the injunction dissolved by the trial court remained dissolved.
Remember This
Memorize this line: an appeal does not of itself revive a dissolved injunction, for only a new exercise of judicial power can do that. Examiners use this case on provisional remedies, on the effect of a bill of exceptions and supersedeas, and on the power of the Supreme Court to grant a preliminary injunction in cases pending before it on appeal.