JURADO & CO., PLAINTIFFS, VS. HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION, DEFENDANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Jurado and Company versus Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation
The Case
This is an early decision of the Philippine Supreme Court, penned by Justice Willard, resolving a challenge to the competency of one of its own members to sit in a pending matter. The suit was brought by Jurado and Company against the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation. The question that reached the Court was procedural rather than substantive: when a party challenges the competency of a Justice of the Supreme Court on the ground that he had earlier acted as fiscal in the same controversy, who decides that challenge, and by what procedure? The case matters because it fixes the rule that the challenged magistrate does not decide his own disqualification alone, but sits with the Court and the question is settled by the Court as a body.
Procedural History
The matter arose from a motion filed by Jurado and Company, dated September 11, 1902, which was heard on October 8, 1902. At that hearing, the attorney for the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation challenged the competency of one of the judges of the Supreme Court to sit in the case, on the ground that he had acted as fiscal. The Court examined the original documents referred to at the argument and then resolved the challenge itself. There was no intermediate appellate court in the ordinary sense; the challenge was raised and decided within the Supreme Court, which is the forum where the motion was pending.
Facts
Jurado and Company had a case pending before the Supreme Court against the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation. At the hearing of the company's motion on October 8, 1902, counsel for the bank challenged the competency of one of the justices to sit, because that justice had previously acted as fiscal.
The Court looked into the original documents referred to during the argument. It found nothing in them that supported the challenge, and nothing that expressed an opinion on the merits of the case. What the records showed was that the fiscal had earlier filed a complaint whose purpose was to compel a judge to comply with the law. The fiscal had failed to send up a report that he had been directed to make in connection with that complaint. The justice who was now challenged, then serving as fiscal, simply made a written request that the judge be directed to send in that report, which the Court characterized as a mere matter of procedure.
The challenge was not made in writing, although the applicable rule required it. The Court nevertheless found it more convenient to settle the question on the merits rather than on the defect of form.
Issues
- Whether or not a challenge to the competency of a Justice of the Supreme Court is decided by the challenged magistrate alone, or by the Court as a body with the challenged magistrate sitting.
- Whether or not the challenge in this case is supported by the records, given that the challenged justice, while acting as fiscal, had merely requested that a judge be directed to submit a report.
- Whether or not the challenge, not having been made in writing as required, should be resolved on the merits.
Applicable Provisions
Article 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which the Court applies to challenges of competency, provides:
The application of article 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, now in force, to a challenge directed to the competency of a judge of the Court of First Instance is free from doubt.
This provision is the textual anchor of the Court's ruling: its application to judges of the Court of First Instance is clear, but its application to a Justice of the Supreme Court admits of more than one construction, which the Court had to resolve.
The same article also requires that the challenge be made in writing, as the Court notes:
In accordance with article 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure in force the challenge should have been made in writing, but it appears to the court more convenient to settle the question on the merits.
This requirement of written form bears on the third issue, because the challenge here was oral, yet the Court chose to pass on its merits rather than dismiss it on form.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court adopted the construction under which the challenged magistrate sits with the Court and the question of his competency is decided by the Court as a body. It expressly rejected the alternative that the magistrate decides the question for himself with his decision being conclusive and the other members having no voice in it. It also refused a third construction under which the Court would decide the question while excluding the challenged members from its consideration, reasoning that such a construction would put it in the power of a party to stop all proceedings in the cause by challenging three of the justices.
On the second issue, the Court examined the original documents and found nothing in them to support the challenge or to show that the challenged justice had expressed an opinion on the merits of the case. The fiscal's complaint had for its purpose compelling the judge to comply with the law, and the justice, then fiscal, had merely made a written request that the judge be directed to send in the required report, which was a mere matter of procedure.
On the third issue, although the challenge should have been made in writing under Article 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the Court found it more convenient to settle the question on the merits. For the reasons stated, the challenge was not allowed.
Doctrine
A challenge to the competency of a Justice of the Supreme Court is not decided by the challenged magistrate alone, nor by the Court sitting without him. The challenged magistrate sits with the Court, and the question of his competency is decided by the Court as a body. This is the construction the Court gave to Article 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, whose application to judges of the Court of First Instance it regarded as free from doubt. The Court also refused a construction that would exclude the challenged members from deliberation, because it would allow a party, by challenging three justices, to stop all proceedings in the cause. Finally, a challenge grounded on a justice's prior act as fiscal will not lie where that act was a mere matter of procedure, such as a written request that a judge be directed to submit a report, and where the records show no expression of opinion on the merits.
Disposition
The challenge to the competency of the justice was not allowed, and the hearing of the motion was ordered continued on the following Monday.
Remember This
Memorize the line that the challenged magistrate sits with the Court and the question of his competency is decided by the Court as a body, never by the magistrate alone and never by the Court without him. Examiners use this case to test the procedure for challenging the competency of a Supreme Court Justice under Article 8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the policy against letting a party stall proceedings by challenging several justices at once.