🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. ANTONIO ALEGADO, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 105. October 16, 1901 October 16, 1901

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Alegado

The Case

This is a criminal case from the early years of the American regime in the Philippines. The United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted Antonio Alegado for burning down a dwelling house in the town of Paoay. The case matters to a Bar candidate because it is an early application of the old Penal Code on arson, and it shows how the Court treated a deliberate burning of an occupied house, how it weighed the plea of alibi against the accused's own admissions, and how it tempered a harsh penalty by invoking the indulto provision of the Code.

Procedural History

The prosecuting attorney presented an information charging Antonio Alegado with the crime. Alegado pleaded not guilty. The case was tried in the court below, which convicted him and imposed the penalty prescribed for arson. Alegado appealed the judgment to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court reviewed the evidence and the judgment and affirmed the conviction, with a modification of the penalty and a recommendation addressed to the Civil Governor.

Facts

On the night of May 21, 1900, the body of Catalino Biado's father lay in the latter's house on the outskirts of Paoay. Seven or more persons had gathered in the house for the occasion of the death. Among them was the defendant, Antonio Alegado.

A bolo belonging to Alegado disappeared. He searched for it and failed to find it. He then said, in a threatening manner, that he would burn the house unless the bolo was found. The bolo was not found. Alegado took a piece of burning bamboo and set fire to the house. The house was burned to the ground, and so was a granary nearby, together with the rice stored in it. The occupants discovered the fire soon after it broke out but could not extinguish it. Experts estimated the total damage at 105 pesos and 75 cents.

Two witnesses called by the accused to prove an alibi testified that they had gone to the scene to help put out the fire. They said that a woman, Basilisa Baraoid, told them that Juan Catubay was the incendiary. But they also said that the accused himself told them that it was he who set the fire, because he had not found his bolo, which was lost in the house.

Issues

  • Whether or not the facts proved constitute the crime of arson under article 549 of the Penal Code.
  • Whether or not the accused's plea of not guilty and his alibi can overcome the evidence of his guilt, including the testimony of the very witnesses he called.
  • Whether or not the accused can claim that he did not know the house was occupied at the time he set it on fire.
  • Whether or not the penalty prescribed by article 549 should be reduced to its minimum grade, and whether the case should be referred to the Civil Governor.

Applicable Provisions

Article 549 of the Penal Code, which defines and penalizes the arson committed in this case, provides:

Article 549. The penalty of cadena temporal in its maximum degree to death shall be imposed upon any person who shall set fire to a dwelling house, provided the circumstances mentioned in the next preceding article are present.

The Court applied this article because the fire was intentionally started to destroy a dwelling house occupied by seven persons and a corpse.

Article 11 of the Penal Code, which allows the penalty to be reduced to its minimum grade, provides:

Article 11. The courts shall impose the penalty prescribed by law in the degree and extent required by the circumstances of the crime and the personal circumstances of the offender.

The Court applied this article for the sole purpose of reducing the penalty to the minimum grade.

Article 2, paragraph 2, of the Penal Code, which allows the Court to call the attention of the Civil Governor to a case, provides:

Article 2. The following are exempt from criminal liability: ... 2. A person who commits a crime in order to avoid a greater evil, provided the evil avoided is greater than the evil caused.

The Court invoked this provision to temper the evidently excessive penalty prescribed by article 549.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the facts constitute the crime of arson under article 549 of the Penal Code. The fire was intentionally started with the malicious intent to destroy the dwelling house of Catalino Biado at a time when it was occupied by seven persons and a corpse. The Court said the facts were completely proved by expert testimony and by witnesses who were present.

On the second issue, the Court held that the plea of not guilty and the alibi could not overcome the evidence. The accused was incriminated not only by witnesses who were present but also by the very witnesses he had called to prove his innocence. The Court said the incriminating circumstances produced full conviction of his delinquency.

On the third issue, the Court rejected any claim of ignorance that the house was occupied. The accused had been present in the house a few moments before and had even threatened those inside that he would set it on fire if he did not find his bolo. He therefore well knew that the house contained persons and even a corpse.

On the fourth issue, the Court applied article 11 of the Penal Code for the sole purpose of reducing the penalty to the minimum grade. It sentenced the accused to twelve years and one day of cadena temporal, with the accessory penalties and the payment of costs. The Court also affirmed the order declaring the accused insolvent and ordering the restoration of the attached rice field valued at 4 pesos. Finally, because the strict application of article 549 would be evidently excessive given the degree of malice and the damage caused, the Court applied article 2, paragraph 2, of the same Code by calling the attention of the Civil Governor to the case.

Doctrine

A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, arson under article 549 of the Penal Code is committed when a person intentionally sets fire to a dwelling house that is occupied. The malicious intent to destroy the house, together with the presence of occupants, completes the crime. Second, the accused's own admissions, even when made to witnesses he himself called, are competent evidence against him and may outweigh a plea of not guilty and an alibi. Third, a person who was present in the house shortly before the fire and who threatened to burn it cannot claim ignorance that the house was occupied. Fourth, the courts may reduce the penalty to its minimum grade under article 11 of the Penal Code, and may call the attention of the Civil Governor under article 2, paragraph 2, when the strict application of the penalty is evidently excessive in view of the degree of malice and the damage caused.

Disposition

The judgment of the court below was affirmed. Antonio Alegado was sentenced to twelve years and one day of cadena temporal, with accessory penalties and costs, and the Court called the attention of the Civil Governor to the case for possible clemency.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that the intentional burning of an occupied dwelling house is arson under article 549 of the Penal Code, and the accused's own admissions may seal his conviction. Examiners like to use this case to test the elements of arson under the old Penal Code, the weight of an alibi against the accused's own statements, and the court's power to reduce a penalty to its minimum grade and to recommend clemency to the executive.