ISABEL RUBIO ALCASID, ASSISTED BY HER HUSBAND DOMINGO A. ALCASID, PETITIONERS, VS. THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS AND RUFINA L. LIM, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Alcasid versus Court of Appeals
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Isabel Rubio Alcasid, assisted by her husband Domingo Alcasid, against the Court of Appeals and Rufina Lim. The petitioner asks the Supreme Court to set aside the appellate court's decision, which had dismissed her complaint for annulment of a deed of sale and damages on the ground that it stated no cause of action. The case matters because it is a compact laboratory on the vices of consent — fraud, mistake, and undue influence — and on how strictly the Court reads the allegations of a complaint before it will allow a contract of sale to be annulled.
Procedural History
The petitioner filed a complaint in the Regional Trial Court of Calamba, Laguna, Branch 34, for annulment of the contract of sale and damages, with a prayer for a temporary restraining order or writ of preliminary injunction against the private respondent. The private respondent moved to dismiss on the ground that the complaint stated no cause of action. The trial court denied the motion to dismiss. The petitioner then moved to declare the private respondent in default, and the trial court granted that motion. The private respondent appealed these orders to the Court of Appeals, which reversed the trial court and held that the complaint indeed stated no cause of action. The petitioner then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review under Rule 45 of the Revised Rules of Court.
Facts
The petitioner was one of the co-owners of two parcels of land in Calamba, Laguna. The private respondent offered to purchase the property from the petitioner and her co-owners. The petitioner was willing to sell her share for 4,500,000 pesos, but only on the condition that all her co-owners would sell their respective shares as well.
The petitioner engaged the services of Atty. Antonio Fernandez to negotiate the sale, not knowing that he was also representing the private respondent. In March 1990, Atty. Fernandez confirmed to the petitioner that all her co-owners were already amenable to sell their shares for 1,500,000 pesos. On March 4, 1990, the petitioner signed a deed of sale drafted by Atty. Fernandez. She later learned that the other co-owners had not in fact agreed to sell their shares.
On November 4, 1990, the petitioner filed her complaint for annulment and damages. She alleged that her consent was vitiated by fraud, mistake, and undue influence, claiming that but for the misrepresentation that her co-owners had agreed to sell, she would never have signed. The private respondent countered that the complaint was really a malpractice suit against Atty. Fernandez, not against her. A letter dated March 4, 1990, sent by Atty. Fernandez to the petitioner, showed that he was acting as counsel for the private respondent, which belied the petitioner's claim that she was unaware of the dual representation.
Issues
- Whether or not the complaint states a cause of action for annulment of the contract of sale on the ground of fraud.
- Whether or not the petitioner's consent was vitiated by mistake.
- Whether or not the petitioner's consent was vitiated by undue influence.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1338 of the Civil Code provides:
There is fraud when, through insidious words or machinations of one of the contracting parties, the other is induced to enter into a contract which, without them, he would not have agreed to.
This is the provision the petitioner invokes, and the Court measures her allegations against its requirement that the fraud be employed by one contracting party upon the other.
Article 1331 of the Civil Code provides:
In order that mistake may invalidate consent, it should refer to the substance of the thing which is the object of the contract, or to those conditions which have principally moved one or both parties to enter into the contract.
This governs the petitioner's claim of mistake, which the Court tests against whether the error was real and unavoidable.
Article 1337 of the Civil Code provides:
There is undue influence when a person takes improper advantage of his power over the will of another, depriving the latter of a reasonable freedom of choice. The following circumstances shall be considered: the confidential, family, spiritual and other relations between the parties, or the fact that the person alleged to have been unduly influenced was suffering from mental weakness, or was ignorant or in financial distress.
This is the standard against which the petitioner's claim of undue influence is weighed.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the complaint stated no cause of action for fraud. For fraud to vitiate consent and be a cause for annulment, several things must concur: it must have been employed by one contracting party upon the other; it must have induced the other party to enter into the contract; it must have been serious; and it must have resulted in damage and injury to the party seeking annulment. The Court noted that the petitioner's own letter evidence showed she knew Atty. Fernandez was acting for the private respondent, so her claim of ignorance failed. More fundamentally, the private respondent committed no wrongful act or omission that violated a primary right of the petitioner.
On the second issue, the Court held that the alleged mistake could not invalidate consent. To invalidate consent, the error must be real and not one that could have been avoided by the party alleging it; it must arise from facts unknown to him. The petitioner could have avoided the alleged mistake had she exerted efforts to verify from her co-owners whether they really consented to sell their shares.
On the third issue, the Court held that there was no undue influence. Undue influence is any means employed upon a party which, under the circumstances, he could not well resist and which controlled his volition and induced him to give his consent to a contract he would otherwise not have entered into. It must in some measure destroy the free agency of a party. The Court found that the Court of Appeals' finding that the petitioner executed the contract of her own free will and choice, and not from duress, was fully supported by the evidence and should not be disturbed.
Doctrine
For fraud to annul a contract under Article 1338, it must be employed by one contracting party upon the other, must have induced the other to enter the contract, must be serious, and must have caused damage and injury to the party seeking annulment. For mistake to invalidate consent under Article 1331, the error must be real and not one that could have been avoided by the party alleging it; a party cannot invoke an error that ordinary prudence could have avoided. For undue influence under Article 1337, the means employed must be such that the party could not well resist, controlling his volition and destroying his free agency. A complaint that alleges none of these with supporting facts states no cause of action.
Disposition
The petition was denied and the decision of the Court of Appeals was affirmed; the private respondent prevailed.
Remember This
The single line to memorize: fraud, mistake, and undue influence must each be real, serious, and unavoidable, and a party who could have verified the facts by ordinary diligence cannot later cry mistake. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of fraud under Article 1338 and the rule that an avoidable error does not vitiate consent.