PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. FELIMON JAVA Y MERCADO, ACCUSED-APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
People of the Philippines versus Felimon Java
The Case
This is the People of the Philippines against Felimon Java, a former Quezon City policeman, convicted of the special complex crime of robbery with homicide for a hold-up at a trading establishment in Cubao, Quezon City, in which the owner's son was shot dead during a hot pursuit of the fleeing robbers. The case matters to a reviewee for three reasons: it teaches how courts treat the positive identification of an accused despite discrepancies in cartographic sketches, it illustrates the procedural rules on the formal offer of testimonial evidence and the effect of a failure to object, and it fixes the rule that a killing committed while the robbers are being pursued still qualifies the crime as robbery with homicide.
Procedural History
An information for robbery with homicide was filed against the accused before the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City. After trial, the court rendered judgment finding him guilty beyond reasonable doubt as a principal and sentencing him to reclusion perpetua, and ordering him to pay the victims civil damages. The accused appealed directly to the Supreme Court, assigning eight errors. The Supreme Court, speaking through Justice Nocon, reviewed each assignment of error in turn and affirmed the judgment of conviction in its entirety.
Facts
At about three o'clock in the afternoon of March 19, 1988, at the V. Valdez Trading, a gravel and sand establishment on P. Tuazon Street, Cubao, Quezon City, two men who appeared to be customers arrived. One of them poked a gun at Salvador Cambaya, a truck helper weighing cement outside, announced a hold-up, took his twenty pesos, and ordered him into the office building. The other man ransacked the drawers, took money, and went to the room of Michael Valdez, the owner's son. Employees heard Michael say that the key was not with him and that there was no money there, then heard something being destroyed, and saw the man rush out holding a brown envelope. The two men hurriedly left.
Virginia Valdez, Michael's mother, was at a beauty parlor across the street. Told of the commotion, she rushed out and learned from her son that they had been robbed of fifty thousand pesos. Michael insisted on chasing the robbers, and she boarded his car with him. They spotted the maroon passenger jeepney of the holduppers, bumped it several times, and followed it along Katipunan Road. The holduppers bumped their car in turn, and one of them fired at them, hitting Michael on the torso and the left side of his body. Michael died. The holduppers sped away.
Cambaya described the man who accosted him to the Quezon City cartographer, and Mrs. Valdez described the gunman. On August 25, 1988, Mrs. Valdez was brought to Quezon City Hall and, from twenty to twenty-five meters away, saw a man inside a building and positively declared that he was the gunman, saying she could not forget the face and the eyes of the man who shot her son. The accused was arrested the next day and charged. At trial, the defense relied on alibi, presenting the accused, Colonel Rodolfo Garcia, and two police officers, all claiming he was at the colonel's office at the time of the crime seeking a letter of recommendation for reinstatement.
Issues
- Whether or not the accused was positively identified as a principal actor in the crime despite the disparity in the cartographic sketches.
- Whether or not the robbery was established, considering that the testimony of Pastor Valdez was not formally offered by the prosecution.
- Whether or not Mrs. Valdez positively identified the accused as the gunman despite her tension and her tears during the car chase.
- Whether or not the prosecution proved that the robbers and the killers were the same persons, so as to establish robbery with homicide.
- Whether or not the defense of alibi should be given credence in light of the testimony of Colonel Garcia and the other defense witnesses.
Applicable Provisions
Section 34 of Rule 132 of the Revised Rules of Court, on the offer of evidence, provides:
The court shall consider no evidence which has not been formally offered. The purpose for which the evidence is offered must be specified.
This provision is the basis of the accused's claim that the testimony of Pastor Valdez, which was never formally offered, cannot be considered by the court.
Section 35 of the same Rule, on the time of the offer, provides:
As regards the testimony of a witness, the offer must be made at the time the witness is called to testify.
This provision, effective July 1, 1989, governs the procedure for offering testimonial evidence and explains why the prosecution should have offered Pastor Valdez's testimony when he was called.
Section 36 of the same Rule, on objections, provides:
Objection to evidence offered orally must be made immediately after the offer is made. Objection to a question propounded in the course of the oral examination of a witness shall be made as soon as the grounds therefor shall become reasonably apparent.
This provision is decisive: because the defense never objected to Pastor Valdez's testimony, the objection raised for the first time on appeal cannot be considered.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the disparity in the cartographs did not destroy the identification. Except for the age range, the descriptions of both witnesses agreed and pointed to one and the same person: a circular face, a stocky physique, and curly hair. The cartographer may simply have perceived their declarations along different lines. What mattered was that both witnesses identified the accused in court when they came face to face with him, one as a robber and the other as the gunman. Where the conditions of visibility are favorable and the witness does not appear biased, the identification of the malefactor is normally accepted.
On the second issue, the Court acknowledged that evidence must be formally offered, but held that the failure to offer Pastor Valdez's testimony was cured by the absence of any objection. The defense never objected when he testified, and an objection raised for the first time on appeal will not be considered. In any event, the robbery was established by Cambaya, whose twenty pesos were taken at gunpoint and whose office was ransacked, and by Mrs. Valdez, who testified that her son told her immediately after the commotion that they had been robbed of fifty thousand pesos, a statement admissible as part of the res gestae.
On the third issue, the Court rejected the conjecture that Mrs. Valdez's tension and tears blinded her. The jeepney and the car were running side by side at high speed when the shooting occurred, and it was impossible for the assailant not to be seen and identified. A witness usually strives to remember the uncovered face of an assailant.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that the connection between the robbery and the homicide was sufficiently established, since Cambaya identified the accused as one of the robbers and Mrs. Valdez identified him as the gunman. Even though the robbers had already fled with their loot when the shooting took place during the pursuit, the killing was done to repel an aggression that would have endangered the success of the robbery and to defend the possession of the stolen property. It was an act that tended to insure the successful termination of the robbery.
On the fifth issue, the Court found the alibi inherently weak and contrived. There was no logbook recording the visit, and no independent proof that the letter of recommendation was issued on March 19, 1988. Colonel Garcia himself admitted he could not remember his visitors. The trial judge noted that the accused's own testimony showed the alibi was contrived, because the Garcia note could not have been issued on that date when the accused was still a tricycle driver. Alibi must yield to the positive identification by the prosecution witnesses.
Doctrine
First, the positive identification of an accused in court prevails over discrepancies in cartographic sketches, especially where the conditions of visibility are favorable and no bias is shown. Second, evidence not formally offered is generally excluded, but the objection must be raised at the time the evidence is presented; an objection raised for the first time on appeal will not be considered. Third, a statement made immediately after a startling occurrence, before the declarant had time to concoct, is admissible as part of the res gestae. Fourth, a killing committed during the pursuit of robbers, even after they have fled with the loot and at a place different from the robbery, is robbery with homicide, because the killing was done to insure the success of the robbery and to secure the stolen property. Fifth, alibi, an inherently weak defense, cannot prevail over positive identification and is unavailing where the circumstances show it to be contrived.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the decision of the trial court in its entirety, finding the accused guilty beyond reasonable doubt of robbery with homicide and sentencing him to reclusion perpetua, with the civil damages awarded by the trial court sustained.
Remember This
Memorize this line: a killing during the pursuit of robbers, even after they have fled with the loot, is robbery with homicide, because it is done to insure the success of the robbery. Examiners like to use this case on the formal offer of evidence and the effect of a failure to object, and on the complex crime of robbery with homicide committed during a hot pursuit.