PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. MOISES BACAMANTE Y ORDANIZA, ACCUSED-APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
People versus Bacamante
The Case
This is the People of the Philippines against Moises Bacamante y Ordaniza, a criminal appeal from a conviction for robbery with homicide. Bacamante, an all-around serviceman at a hardware store in Paco, Manila, was accused of conspiring with unidentified persons to rob his employer, Chua Huat, and of killing him on the occasion of that robbery. The case matters for two reasons a reviewee must hold onto. First, it is a clean teaching case on the constitutional requirements for a valid extrajudicial confession during custodial investigation, particularly the demand for effective and vigilant counsel. Second, it is a rigorous demonstration of when circumstantial evidence fails to form the unbroken chain required for conviction beyond reasonable doubt.
Procedural History
Bacamante was charged with robbery with homicide before the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 18. He pleaded not guilty when arraigned in April 1986. After trial, the trial court rendered its decision in October 1991, finding him guilty beyond reasonable doubt and sentencing him to reclusion perpetua with the accessory penalties, and ordering him to pay the costs. Bacamante, through counsel de parte, appealed to the Supreme Court, assigning as errors the sufficiency of the circumstantial evidence, the violation of his right to counsel of his choice during custodial investigation, and the trial court's reliance on his confession. The Supreme Court reviewed the entire records and reversed.
Facts
Moises Bacamante worked as an all-around serviceman at Chua Huat Enterprises, a hardware store on Pedro Gil Street in Paco, Manila, owned by Chua Huat. The victim lived with his wife and adopted son Fernando Ngo on Paz Street, just across from the store's back entrance. On the afternoon of 19 December 1985, Ngo saw Bacamante cutting electric cords into irregular lengths of about two and one-half meters. When asked why, Bacamante said a customer had requested those lengths. Bacamante, who was supposed to work until seven in the evening, asked permission to leave at about five thirty, saying he had to meet a relative in Parañaque.
At around eight thirty that evening, a woman vendor saw smoke coming from the hardware store and informed the Chua residence. Fernando Ngo rushed to the store, called out for his father, and found him on the ground floor lying in a pool of blood. He smelled paint thinner poured on the body and around the area. About two meters away lay an ax with dried blood. Three electric flat irons, connected to outlets and placed on top of cans of paint thinner, were very hot and had caused the smoke. Money was missing from the cash register and vault. The victim died of multiple stab and puncture wounds that penetrated the lungs and heart, and lacerated wounds on the head.
The next morning, all employees reported for work except Bacamante. Police investigators from the Western Police District, led by a policeman who was a close friend and kumpadre of the victim, focused on Bacamante. In January 1986, a police team went to his hometown in Bohol. Upon seeing them, Bacamante ran, and after warning shots he hid in a grassy area. The police persuaded his parents to ask him to surrender, and he did, voluntarily going with them to Manila. On 25 January 1986, he executed a statement admitting his guilt, signed by a police officer as witness and by his brother Teotimo. At the investigation, a certain Attorney Gilbert Zulueta, who was merely visiting the police station, was asked to act as counsel for Bacamante.
Issues
- Whether or not the extrajudicial confession of the accused is admissible in evidence, given that his alleged counsel was not present and able to advise him throughout the custodial investigation.
- Whether or not the circumstantial evidence adduced by the prosecution is sufficient to establish the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt.
Applicable Provisions
Section 12, paragraphs 1 and 3, of Article III of the Constitution provides:
Any person under investigation for the commission of an offense shall have the right to be informed of his right to remain silent and to have competent and independent counsel preferably of his own choice. If the person cannot afford the services of counsel, he must be provided with one. These rights cannot be waived except in writing and in the presence of counsel. Any confession or admission in violation of this or Section 17 hereof shall be inadmissible in evidence against him.
This provision governs the confession, and it is the basis for excluding it because the assisting lawyer was not effective and vigilant counsel.
Section 17 of Article III of the Constitution provides:
No person shall be compelled to be a witness against himself.
This reinforces the exclusion, since a confession taken without the safeguards of counsel offends the privilege against self-incrimination.
Section 4 of Rule 133 of the Rules of Court provides:
Circumstantial evidence is sufficient for conviction if: (a) There is more than one circumstance; (b) The facts from which the inferences are derived are proven; and (c) The combination of all the circumstances is such as to produce a conviction beyond reasonable doubt.
This is the test the Court applies to the prosecution's circumstantial case.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held the extrajudicial confession inadmissible. The prosecution's own witnesses sealed its fate. The police officer who witnessed the confession admitted that Attorney Zulueta would come and go during the investigation and was not at all times within hearing distance of the accused, but merely within the premises. Attorney Zulueta himself admitted he could not remember having informed the accused of the constitutional presumption of his innocence. The Court quoted its recent ruling in People versus Lucero:
We hold that when the Constitution requires the right to counsel, it did not mean any kind of counsel but effective and vigilant counsel.
The Court explained that effective and vigilant counsel requires the lawyer to be present and able to advise and assist the confessant from the first question until the signing of the confession, and to ascertain that the confession is voluntary and that the person fully understands its nature and consequences in relation to his constitutional rights. A contrary rule would be antagonistic to the rights to remain silent, to counsel, and to be presumed innocent.
On the second issue, the Court held the circumstantial evidence insufficient. Each circumstance failed to make a strong link in the unbroken chain. Mere presence near the crime scene does not establish guilt, and the vendor testified only that the accused passed by, not that he came from or went toward the store. The cutting of electric cords of similar length did not point to him as the felon, especially since only Fernando Ngo testified to it, no testimony showed the cords were of the same type as those on the flat irons, and a witness heard Ngo tell the accused in the vernacular that he had nothing to do with the death of Ngo's father and that it was Pepito Guevarra. Flight did not indicate guilt, because the officers were in civilian clothes, the accused knew the lead investigator was the victim's close friend and kumpadre, and his reaction could have been natural fear of reprisal; he later agreed to go with the team to Manila. Failure to return to work was explained by the Christmas vacation, and there was nothing to show he went into hiding. The Court noted it did not entirely discount the possibility that the accused committed the crime, but the Constitution allows conviction only upon moral certainty of guilt, and such moral certainty was absent.
Doctrine
First, the right to counsel during custodial investigation means effective and vigilant counsel, not just any lawyer. Counsel must be present and able to advise and assist the confessant from the first question until the signing of the extrajudicial confession, and must ascertain that the confession is voluntary and that the confessant understands its nature and consequences. A confession taken in violation of Section 12 of Article III of the Constitution is inadmissible in evidence against the accused.
Second, circumstantial evidence suffices for conviction only when there is more than one circumstance, the facts from which the inferences are derived are proven, and the combination of all the circumstances produces a conviction beyond reasonable doubt. The circumstances must form an unbroken chain leading to one fair and reasonable conclusion of guilt. If any theory based on the circumstances is consistent with innocence, the accused must be acquitted, for it is better to free a guilty person on reasonable doubt than to imprison an innocent one.
Disposition
The Supreme Court set aside the appealed decision, acquitted Moises Bacamante on reasonable doubt, and ordered his release unless he is detained for some other legal ground.
Remember This
Memorize the line that the Constitution requires not any kind of counsel but effective and vigilant counsel, present from the first question to the signing of the confession. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of a valid extrajudicial confession and the unbroken chain rule for circumstantial evidence.