NATIONAL FEDERATION OF LABOR, PETITIONER, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION AND FRANKLIN BAKER COMPANY OF THE PHILIPPINES (DAVAO PLANT), RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
National Federation of Labor versus National Labor Relations Commission and Franklin Baker Company of the Philippines
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by the National Federation of Labor against the National Labor Relations Commission and Franklin Baker Company of the Philippines, Davao Plant. The Union asks the Supreme Court to set aside the resolution of the NLRC Fifth Division, which held that the wage distortion in the Company had ceased after 1 July 1984. The case matters because it is the Court's clearest early attempt to define wage distortion and to fix the remedy for it, before and alongside the statutory definition later written into Article 124 of the Labor Code.
Procedural History
The dispute began as a labor case certified by the Secretary of Labor to the National Labor Relations Commission for compulsory conciliation. On 11 November 1987, the NLRC En Banc rendered a decision finding a wage distortion and requiring the Company to pay a one-peso wage increase effective 1 May 1984. The Company moved for partial reconsideration. Because the Commission had been reorganized in 1989, the motion was resolved by the NLRC Fifth Division, which, on 16 December 1991, set aside that portion of the En Banc decision and held that the distortion lasted only fifteen days, from 16 June 1984 to 30 June 1984, ordering a two-peso increase for that period only. The Union then came to the Supreme Court on a petition for certiorari, alleging grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction.
Facts
Between November 1983 and November 1984, four successive Wage Orders raised the statutory minimum wage. Before Wage Order No. 3, regular employees of the Company earned 22 pesos and 56 centavos a day while casual employees earned 18 pesos, a gap of 4 pesos and 56 centavos. As each Wage Order took effect, that gap shrank. Upon Wage Order No. 5 on 16 June 1984, both groups stood at 34 pesos a day, and the gap fell to zero.
On 21 June 1984, at the Union's request, the Company regularized all its casual employees. On 1 July 1984, the 1984 Collective Bargaining Agreement took effect and gave all regular employees an increase of 1 peso and 84 centavos, restoring a gap of 1 peso and 84 centavos. Wage Order No. 6 later raised the casuals to 36 pesos, while the Company unilaterally granted an across-the-board increase of 2 pesos to regulars, keeping the same gap. By 1 July 1985, a CBA anniversary increase pushed the gap to 3 pesos and 60 centavos.
Meanwhile, the Company suffered a work output slowdown, dismissed 205 workers who failed to explain the reduction, and suspended operations. The Union struck, alleging a lock-out and demanding correction of the wage distortion. The lock-out issue was settled by an agreement granting the 205 employees financial assistance equivalent to thirty days' separation pay, leaving only the wage distortion issue for resolution.
Issues
- Whether or not the NLRC Fifth Division committed grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction in holding that the wage distortion ceased to exist after 1 July 1984.
- Whether or not a wage distortion continued to exist between the old regular employees and the newly regularized employees on the basis of seniority.
Applicable Provisions
Section 6 of Wage Order No. 3 provides:
Section 6. Where the application of the minimum wage rate prescribed herein results in distortions of the wage structure of an establishment, the employer and the union shall negotiate to correct the distortions. Any dispute arising from wage distortions shall be resolved through the grievance procedure under their collective bargaining agreement or through conciliation.
This is the provision that identifies negotiation, not unilateral imposition, as the remedy for distortion.
Article 124 of the Labor Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 6727, provides:
As used herein, a wage distortion shall mean a situation where an increase in prescribed wage rates results in the elimination or severe contraction of intentional quantitative differences in wage or salary rates between and among employee groups in an establishment as to effectively obliterate the distinctions embodied in such wage structure based on skills, length of service, or other logical bases of differentiation.
This is the statutory definition the Court uses to test whether a distortion existed and whether it persisted.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that no grave abuse of discretion was shown. A wage distortion presupposes an existing classification of employees on a legitimate basis, reflected in differing wage rates. Here there were two classes, regular and casual. The distortion arose when Wage Order No. 5 eliminated the gap on 16 June 1984. But fifteen days later, the CBA re-created a gap of 1 peso and 84 centavos, which persisted and even grew. The Court held that this re-establishment of a significant differential was more than substantial compliance with the Wage Orders and Article 124. That it came from collective bargaining rather than a grievance procedure was no basis for ignoring it. The Court stressed the public policy of encouraging employers to pay above the minimum, and quoted its earlier ruling that to obliterate the creditability provisions would be to penalize employers who grant their workers more than the statutorily prescribed minimum rates of increases.
On the second issue, the Court held that the Union's claim was really a demand to split the regular employees into new regulars and old regulars. No such sub-classification existed in the Company. The Court held that whether to establish a new scheme of classification is a matter of management judgment and, ultimately, of bargaining. The NLRC is not authorized unilaterally to impose a new scheme of classification under the guise of rectifying a wage distortion.
Doctrine
Wage distortion is the elimination or severe contraction of intentional quantitative differences in wage rates between employee groups, obliterating distinctions based on skills, length of service, or other logical bases. It presupposes an existing classification; where none exists, there can be no distortion. The remedy is negotiation between employer and union to re-adjust rates, and the law does not require that the historical gap be restored in precisely the same form or amount. A significant differential restored by collective bargaining or by unilateral grant counts as substantial compliance, consistent with the creditability provisions. The NLRC cannot impose a new classification scheme on the employer.
Disposition
The petition for certiorari was dismissed for lack of merit, with no pronouncement as to costs, and the NLRC Fifth Division's decision was upheld.
Remember This
Memorize the rule that wage distortion requires a pre-existing classification and that its remedy is negotiation, not judicial or arbitral imposition of a new wage structure. Examiners use this case to test the definition of wage distortion under Article 124 and the limits of the NLRC's power to correct it.