🎧 Case Brief Lecture

MARIA DEL CARMEN VIUDA DE BUSTILLOS, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLEE, VS. ROQUE GARBANZOS, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 1035. December 04, 1902 December 4, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Vda. de Bustillos versus Garbanzos

The Case

This is an early Philippine Supreme Court decision, from December 1902, in an action for the recovery of a sum of money brought by Maria del Carmen Viuda de Bustillos against Roque Garbanzos. The plaintiff sought payment of a claim, and the defendant resisted it. What makes the case worth studying is not the merits of the debt but the state of the record: the case was heard during the transition from the old Spanish procedural law to the new Code of Civil Procedure, and the trial court sent the Supreme Court an incomplete record that made review on the merits impossible. The decision is therefore a lesson in procedure, in the duty of the trial judge to preserve the evidence, and in the consequences of appealing with a defective record.

Procedural History

The proceeding was commenced on the twelfth of February 1900, and was carried on under the law then in force until the fifteenth of June 1900, when the defendant filed a formal objection to the complaint. After that date nothing was done until the twenty-seventh of May 1902, when the plaintiff filed a petition alleging that the proceeding was being carried on under the Code of Civil Procedure, and asking that a demand for payment be made upon the defendant and that, if he did not pay in the act, his property be seized.

The judge of the Special Court of Negros cited the parties to a trial and, after receiving documentary and oral evidence, none of which appears in the record, rendered a decision reciting the proceedings had, finding that the defendant had not proved the illegality of the plaintiff's claim, and ordering judgment in favor of the plaintiff. That court allowed an appeal in both effects and directed the original records to be sent to the Supreme Court. The case thus reached the Supreme Court by appeal, with the original record forwarded by the trial court.

Facts

The plaintiff held a claim against the defendant and, in February 1900, commenced this proceeding to enforce it. The case began under the old procedure, and the defendant filed a formal objection to the complaint in June 1900. Nearly two years then passed without action.

In May 1902 the plaintiff filed a petition asserting that the proceeding was now governed by the Code of Civil Procedure, and asking the court to demand payment from the defendant and, failing payment in the act, to seize his property. The judge of the Special Court of Negros set the case for trial, received documentary and oral evidence, and decided in favor of the plaintiff, holding that the defendant had not proved the illegality of the claim.

The difficulty surfaced on appeal. The evidence received by the trial court was not preserved in the record sent up. The Supreme Court could not tell with certainty whether the trial judge had proceeded under the old law or the new Code, and under either view the record as transmitted was defective.

Issues

  • Whether or not the trial court proceeded under the old procedure or under the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Whether or not the decision and record transmitted were sufficient to permit the Supreme Court to pass upon the merits of the case.
  • Whether or not the judgment should be reversed and the case remanded for a new trial.
  • Whether or not the costs of the appeal should be charged against the appellant.

Applicable Provisions

The decision refers to article 133 of the Code of Civil Procedure as the provision governing the form of the decision under the new procedure, in these terms:

If tried according to the new procedure the decision should have conformed to article 133, and the judge should have required the settlement of a bill of exceptions and should not have sent the original record here.

This bears on the case because, measured against that standard, the decision was entirely insufficient to support the judgment, and the appeal was not perfected in the manner the new Code required.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court observed that there were more indications that the court was pursuing the old procedure than that it was pursuing the new. The timing of the proceedings, begun and long carried on under the prior law, pointed that way.

On the second issue, the Court held that under the old procedure the evidence should have been preserved and returned to the Supreme Court, and that it was impossible to pass upon the merits without it. The Court also held that, viewed as a decision under the present Code, the decision was entirely insufficient to support the judgment, so that if the new Code were applied the judgment would be reversed for that reason. Either way, review on the merits was foreclosed by the incomplete record. The Court noted that a prior appeal from the same court, the case of Gonzaga versus Canete, had arrived in the same condition, and that only by agreement of the parties were questions of law there resolved.

On the third issue, the Court reversed the judgment and remanded the case to the Court of First Instance for Occidental Negros for a new trial.

On the fourth issue, the Court charged the costs of the appeal against the defendant, in view of the fact that he removed the case knowing, as he must have known, how incomplete the record was, and because he did not suggest the defect until the argument of the case.

Doctrine

First, the evidence received by the trial court must be preserved and transmitted on appeal; without it the appellate court cannot pass upon the merits, and the judgment cannot stand.

Second, a decision rendered under the Code of Civil Procedure must conform to article 133, and the trial judge must require the settlement of a bill of exceptions rather than forward the original record.

Third, an appellant who brings up a record he knows to be incomplete, and who raises that defect only at the argument, bears the costs of the appeal.

Disposition

The judgment was reversed and the case remanded to the Court of First Instance for Occidental Negros for a new trial, with the costs of the appeal charged against the defendant.

Remember This

The line to memorize is that without the preserved evidence the appellate court cannot pass upon the merits, and the case must go back for a new trial. Examiners use this case on the completeness of the record on appeal, the requirements of a bill of exceptions, and the charging of costs against an appellant who appeals knowing the record is defective.