🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. AGUSTIN ABLAZA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 1032. February 19, 1903 February 19, 1903

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Ablaza

The Case

This is a criminal appeal from a conviction for murder, brought by the Government of the United States against Agustin Ablaza. The defendant was found guilty below and sentenced to a long term of imprisonment, and he appealed to the Supreme Court. The case matters for two reasons. First, it fixes the rule that a confession of guilt is not an extenuating circumstance, so it cannot lower the penalty. Second, it fixes the rule that the benefits of the amnesty proclamation of July 1902 belong only to persons who took part in the insurrection against the United States or Spain, and that a person outside those terms must apply to the executive, not to the courts.

Procedural History

The defendant was tried and convicted in the court below for murder, and the trial court imposed a penalty of fourteen years, eight months, and one day. The defendant appealed to the Supreme Court. On appeal, the Court modified the penalty, reducing it to twelve years and one day, and affirmed the judgment in all other respects, with costs of the appeal against the appellant.

Facts

The defendant, Agustin Ablaza, was charged with murder and was convicted of that crime in the court below. The record shows that he confessed his guilt. On appeal, he sought to have that confession counted in his favor as an extenuating circumstance, and he also sought the benefits of the amnesty proclaimed on July 4, 1902.

The Court found that the case showed an extenuating circumstance defined in article 9, number 5, of the Penal Code, and gave the defendant the benefit of it. The Court also examined whether the defendant fell within the terms of the amnesty proclamation.

The Court found that it did not appear that the defendant took part against the United States or Spain in the insurrection mentioned in the amnesty. On that ground alone, without considering other grounds, the Court denied the application for the benefits of the amnesty.

Issues

  • Whether or not the fact that the defendant confessed his guilt may be considered as an extenuating circumstance within the meaning of article 9 of the Penal Code.
  • Whether or not the extenuating circumstance defined in article 9, number 5, of the Penal Code should be taken into account in this case.
  • Whether or not the defendant is entitled to the benefits of the amnesty of July 4, 1902.

Applicable Provisions

Article 9 of the Penal Code, which defines the extenuating circumstances, provides:

Article 9. Extenuating circumstances: 1. Those enumerated in the second paragraph of article 8. 2. That the offender has not previously committed any crime. 3. That the offender has not been convicted of any crime. 4. That the offender has not been guilty of any offense. 5. That the offender has not been guilty of any offense against the person or property of another. 6. That the offender has not been guilty of any offense against the person or property of another, or against the public order. 7. That the offender has not been guilty of any offense against the person or property of another, or against the public order, or against the public peace.

The Court held that a confession of guilt is not among the extenuating circumstances defined in this article, so it cannot reduce the penalty.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the fact that the defendant confessed his guilt cannot be considered as an extenuating circumstance within the meaning of article 9 of the Penal Code. A confession, in other words, is not one of the circumstances that the law allows to be weighed in the offender's favor.

On the second issue, the Court held that the case shows that the extenuating circumstance defined in article 9, number 5, should be taken into account. Giving the defendant the benefit of that circumstance, the Court modified the penalty from fourteen years, eight months, and one day to twelve years and one day.

On the third issue, the Court held that the application for the benefits of the amnesty of July 4, 1902, must be denied, without considering other grounds, for the reason that it does not appear that the defendant took part against the United States or Spain in the insurrection mentioned in the amnesty. The Court added that in cases not covered by the terms of the proclamation, the special application therein permitted must be made to the executive and not to the judicial authorities, as had been done in this case.

Doctrine

Two rules must be retained. First, a confession of guilt is not an extenuating circumstance under article 9 of the Penal Code. It cannot be used to lower the penalty, because the law lists the extenuating circumstances and a confession is not among them. Second, the benefits of the amnesty of July 4, 1902, belong only to persons who took part against the United States or Spain in the insurrection mentioned in the amnesty. A person outside those terms cannot obtain the amnesty from the courts. The special application permitted by the proclamation must be made to the executive, not to the judicial authorities.

Disposition

The Court modified the judgment by changing the penalty from fourteen years, eight months, and one day to twelve years and one day, affirmed it in all other respects, and ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal.

Remember This

The line worth memorizing is that a confession of guilt is not an extenuating circumstance, and that amnesty outside the terms of the proclamation must be sought from the executive, not the courts. Examiners use this case to test the rule on extenuating circumstances under article 9 of the Penal Code and the limits of judicial power over amnesty.