BANK OF AMERICA NT & SA, PETITIONER, VS. HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS, AND THE COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Bank of America versus Court of Appeals and the Commissioner of Internal Revenue
The Case
This is a petition for review brought by the Bank of America, a foreign corporation licensed to do business in the Philippines through a local branch, against the Court of Appeals and the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. The bank paid the fifteen percent branch profit remittance tax and then sought a refund of a portion of it, insisting that the tax should be computed on the profit actually sent abroad, so that the tax itself does not swell the tax base. The Commissioner reads the law the other way, treating the tax as inclusive of the sum deemed remitted. The case matters because it fixes the tax base of the branch profit remittance tax and illustrates the cardinal rule that a tax statute clear and unambiguous in its terms is applied as written, without judicial addition.
Procedural History
The bank filed a claim for refund with the Bureau of Internal Revenue and, without awaiting the Commissioner's decision, filed a petition for review with the Court of Tax Appeals. The Court of Tax Appeals upheld the bank and granted the refund. The Commissioner appealed to the Supreme Court, which referred the appeal to the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals set aside the decision of the Court of Tax Appeals and ruled for the Commissioner. The bank then came to the Supreme Court by petitions for review, filed separately through two law firms by inadvertence, which the Court resolved together.
Facts
The Bank of America operated in the Philippines through a branch office in Makati. On July 20, 1982, it paid the fifteen percent branch profit remittance tax in the amount of 7,538,460 pesos and 72 centavos on profit from its regular banking unit operations, and 445,790 pesos and 25 centavos on profit from its foreign currency deposit unit operations, for a total of 7,984,250 pesos and 97 centavos. The tax was computed on net profits after income tax, without deducting the amount corresponding to the fifteen percent tax itself.
The bank filed a claim for refund, contending that the tax should have been computed on the profit actually remitted, which it placed at 45,244,088 pesos and 85 centavos, and not on the amount before the profit remittance tax, which it placed at 53,228,339 pesos and 82 centavos. It sought the recovery of 1,041,424 pesos and 2 centavos, representing the difference between the Commissioner's computation and its own.
The Commissioner maintained that in computing the fifteen percent remittance tax, the tax should be inclusive of the sum deemed remitted. The tax court sided with the bank, the appellate court sided with the Commissioner, and the matter reached the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not the fifteen percent branch profit remittance tax should be computed on the amount actually remitted abroad, excluding the tax itself from the tax base.
- Whether or not the withholding tax system and the constructive remittance concept may be extended by analogy to the branch profit remittance tax.
- Whether or not the bank's written claim for refund was lawfully made within the prescriptive period.
Applicable Provisions
Section 24, paragraph (b), subparagraph (2), item (ii) of the National Internal Revenue Code, as worded in 1982, provides:
Any profit remitted abroad by a branch to its head office shall be subject to a tax of fifteen per cent (15%).
This is the provision whose tax base is in dispute, and the Court reads it literally to impose the tax on the profit remitted abroad.
Section 327 of the National Internal Revenue Code, on non-retroactivity of rulings, provides:
Any revocation, modification, or reversal of any of the rules and regulations promulgated in accordance with the preceding section or any of the rulings or circulars promulgated by the Commissioner shall not be given retroactive application if the revocation, modification, or reversal will be prejudicial to the taxpayer except in the following cases (a) where the taxpayer deliberately misstates or omits material facts from his return or in any document required of him by the Bureau of Internal Revenue; (b) where the facts subsequently gathered by the Bureau of Internal Revenue are materially different from the facts on which the ruling is based, or (c) where the taxpayer acted in bad faith.
The Court cites this to explain why the earlier Burroughs case, which turned on the non-retroactivity of a revenue ruling, cannot control the present controversy.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled for the bank. The law specifies its own tax base, namely the profit remitted abroad, and there is nothing equivocal about that language. The tax is imposed on the amount sent abroad, and the law then in force calls for nothing further. The Court stressed that where the law does not qualify that the tax is imposed and collected at source on the profit to be remitted, that qualification should not be read into the law, for when the language of the law is clear and unambiguous it should be applied as written. The term any profit remitted abroad means such profit as is forwarded, sent, or transmitted abroad, in its common and popular sense.
On the second issue, the Court rejected the suggested analogy to the withholding tax system. In withholding, the payee is the taxpayer and the payor is a separate entity acting merely as the government's collecting agent, so the amount used to settle the tax may be deemed sourced from the proceeds constituting the tax base. In the remittance tax, however, there is but one taxpayer using its own domestic funds to pay the tax, and to speak of a constructive remittance of such funds would stretch the rule too far. Sound logic does not defy but must concede to facts.
On the third issue, the Court held that the written claim for refund of the excess tax payment was lawfully filed within the two-year prescriptive period with the Court of Tax Appeals.
Doctrine
The branch profit remittance tax is imposed on the profit actually remitted abroad, and the tax itself does not form part of the tax base. The Court put the rule this way:
In the 15% remittance tax, the law specifies its own tax base to be on the profit remitted abroad.
Where a tax statute is clear and unambiguous, it is applied as written, and a qualification not found in the text, such as collection at source on the total amount to be remitted, cannot be read into it. The withholding tax system and the constructive remittance concept do not extend by analogy to the remittance tax, because there the branch is a single taxpayer paying with its own domestic funds, not a separate payor acting as collecting agent for another. Finally, a written claim for refund filed within the two-year prescriptive period with the Court of Tax Appeals is lawfully made.
Disposition
The Court reversed and set aside the decision of the Court of Appeals and reinstated that of the Court of Tax Appeals, upholding the bank's claim for refund.
Remember This
Memorize the line that the remittance tax is imposed on the profit remitted abroad, so the fifteen percent tax is not part of its own tax base. Examiners use this case to test the literal rule of statutory construction in taxation and the distinction between the withholding tax system and the branch profit remittance tax.