🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PACIFIC BANKING CORPORATION, PETITIONERS, VS. COURT OF APPEALS, (FOURTH DIVISION), WILLIAM LOK GO, FRANKLIN LOK GO, NATHALIE LOK GO-ONG AND CARL DICKSON LOK GO, REPRESENTED HERE…

G.R. No. 102553. July 18, 1994 July 18, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Pacific Banking Corporation versus Court of Appeals

The Case

This is a petition for certiorari and mandamus filed by Pacific Banking Corporation against the Court of Appeals and the Lok Go family. The bank asks the Supreme Court to reverse two resolutions of the Court of Appeals that dismissed its appeal for failure to prosecute. The case matters because it fixes the standard of diligence owed by an appellant in moving the records of a case from the trial court to the appellate court, and it teaches that the appellant cannot simply fold his arms and blame the clerk of court for delay.

Procedural History

The case began as a civil action for annulment of foreclosure, conveyance and damages filed by the private respondents against the petitioner bank before the Regional Trial Court of Pasig, Branch 163. On November 15, 1990, the trial court decided in favor of the private respondents. It declared the foreclosure proceedings over two parcels of land null and void, ordered the Register of Deeds to cancel the new certificates of title and restore the old ones, ordered the bank to pay attorney's fees of 20,000 pesos, and dismissed the bank's counterclaim.

On November 26, 1990, the bank filed a notice of appeal. Nine months later, on August 16, 1991, the private respondents moved the Court of Appeals to dismiss the appeal for failure to prosecute, pointing to the bank's failure to cause the transmission of the records. The bank opposed the motion. On September 17, 1991, the Court of Appeals, through its Fourth Division, dismissed the appeal. On November 8, 1991, it denied the bank's motion for reconsideration. The bank then filed this petition for certiorari and mandamus before the Supreme Court.

Facts

The bank obtained a judgment against it in the trial court and timely filed a notice of appeal. From the filing of that notice in November 1990 until the motion to dismiss in August 1991, nine long months passed, and the records of the case were never transmitted to the Court of Appeals.

When ordered to explain, the bank blamed the delay on the stenographers who had not completed the transcripts, and on a court aide who failed to forward the records. It argued that the rules impose on the clerk of court and the stenographers the duty to transmit the records and to transcribe the notes without unnecessary delay, and that it should not be punished for their failure.

The Court of Appeals rejected the excuse. It noted that the transcripts had in fact been finished long before, and that the initials and duplicates the bank complained of were minor matters obtainable with ordinary diligence. It found the bank's counsel indifferent and slothful, and dismissed the appeal.

Issues

  • Whether or not the petitioner was denied due process when the Court of Appeals dismissed its appeal on a purely technical ground.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals committed grave abuse of discretion in applying the Sarmiento ruling instead of the A-One Feeds and Alonzo rulings.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals exhibited bias in favor of the private respondents and prejudice against the petitioner.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals acted without jurisdiction in deciding the appeal on the merits when the sole ground for dismissal was failure to prosecute.

Applicable Provisions

The decision applies the rule on dismissal of appeals for failure to prosecute, as stated in the early case of Fagtanac versus Court of Appeals:

A rule long familiar to practitioners in this jurisdiction is that it is the duty of the appellant to prosecute his appeal with reasonable diligence. He cannot simply fold his arms and say that it is the duty of the Clerk of the Court of First Instance (now Regional Trial Court) to transmit the record on appeal to the appellate court. It is appellant's duty to make the Clerk act and, if necessary, procure a court order to compel him to act. He cannot idly sit by and wait till this is done. He cannot afterwards wash his hands and say that delay in the transmittal of the record on appeal was not his fault. For, indeed, this duty imposed upon him was precisely to spur on the slothful.

This rule bears directly on the case because it places the burden of diligence on the appellant, not on the clerk of court.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that there was no denial of due process. The dismissal was not a mere technicality; it was grounded on the bank's own failure to prosecute its appeal with reasonable diligence. The bank had nine months to act and did nothing.

On the second issue, the Court held that the Court of Appeals did not commit grave abuse of discretion. The Sarmiento ruling was correctly applied, because it is the appellant's duty to see to it that the clerk acts. The excuse that the transcripts were incomplete could not justify the delay, since the bank could have informed the trial judge of the neglect of duty through a proper motion, and the records show it never did. Such nonchalance negated its interest in prosecuting the appeal.

On the third and fourth issues, the Court found no bias and no lack of jurisdiction, and upheld the dismissal.

Doctrine

An appellant must prosecute his appeal with reasonable diligence. It is not enough to file a notice of appeal and then wait; the appellant must make the clerk of court act, and if necessary procure a court order to compel him to act. He cannot idly sit by and later wash his hands of the delay by blaming court personnel. This duty is imposed precisely to spur on the slothful. Failure to comply warrants dismissal of the appeal for failure to prosecute.

Disposition

The petition was denied, the resolutions of the Court of Appeals were affirmed, and costs were taxed against the petitioner.

Remember This

Memorize the line that the appellant cannot fold his arms and blame the clerk, for the duty to prosecute the appeal with diligence rests on him. Examiners use this case to test the rule on dismissal of appeals for failure to prosecute and the standard of diligence owed by an appellant.