🎧 Case Brief Lecture

EDMUNDO QUEBRAL, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND UNION REFINERY CORPORATION, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 101941. January 25, 1996 January 25, 1996

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Quebral versus Union Refinery Corporation

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Edmundo Quebral against the Court of Appeals and Union Refinery Corporation. Quebral was sued by Union Refinery in the Regional Trial Court for a sum of money and damages, on the theory that he and a certain Higidio Gay-ya, Junior, doing business as Taurus Commercial, had purchased oil products from the corporation and failed to pay for them. The trial court dismissed the case against Quebral on his demurrer to evidence, but the Court of Appeals reversed and held him liable. The case matters because it teaches two lessons at once: what happens when an appellate court reverses a dismissal grounded on a demurrer to evidence, and when the Supreme Court will disturb the factual findings of the Court of Appeals.

Procedural History

Union Refinery Corporation filed a complaint for a sum of money and damages with preliminary attachment against Quebral and Gay-ya before the Regional Trial Court of Valenzuela. The trial court granted the writ of preliminary attachment, later lifted it as to Quebral, and declared Gay-ya in default. After the corporation rested its evidence, Quebral filed a demurrer to evidence. The trial court sustained the demurrer and dismissed the case against Quebral, while rendering judgment against Gay-ya for the full amount claimed.

Union Refinery appealed to the Court of Appeals, which reversed and set aside the trial court's judgment and entered a new one holding both Quebral and Gay-ya liable. Quebral moved for reconsideration, but the motion was denied. He then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45, assigning errors that were, in substance, attacks on the factual findings of the appellate court.

Facts

Union Refinery Corporation is engaged in refining, sale, and distribution of oil, gasoline, and lubricants. In August 1984 it approved Quebral's credit application, allowing him to sell its products in La Union, Ilocos Sur, Abra, and Baguio City. In October 1984, oil products were delivered under two sales invoices: twenty drums of Uniplus oil products worth 68,790 pesos, including freight, allegedly for the service station of Joseph Li in Mangaldan, Pangasinan, and ten drums worth 34,201.54 pesos allegedly for Susan Lo of a Shell service station in Dagupan City. The total value of the two invoices was 102,991.54 pesos.

When demands for payment went unheeded, the corporation inquired and discovered that Susan Lo and Joseph Li had never ordered its products, and that the goods had actually been sold to third persons. It sued Quebral and Gay-ya. Gay-ya, in a letter and a promissory note dated July 19, 1985, assumed personal liability for 91,904.73 pesos out of the account of Quebral, and Quebral signed the note under the word Conforme. Quebral, for his part, denied any partnership with Gay-ya and claimed that Gay-ya had transacted with the corporation without his knowledge or consent.

At trial, the corporation presented, among other exhibits, a handwritten letter dated January 19, 1985 from Quebral to its official Efren Vargas, introducing Gay-ya as his representative and referring to the consolidation of collections for the drums delivered to Joseph Li and Susan Lo. After the corporation rested, Quebral filed a demurrer to evidence instead of commenting on the offered exhibits. The trial court sustained the demurrer and dismissed the case against him. The Court of Appeals reversed, giving weight to the letter and to Quebral's admissions, and held him liable.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in admitting and considering the handwritten letter of Quebral as evidence, given his claim that the original was never produced and its addressee never presented as a witness.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in finding that Quebral had knowledge of and liability for the unpaid sales invoices.
  • Whether or not the reversal by the appellate court of the trial court's order of dismissal based on a demurrer to evidence bars the movant from presenting evidence on his behalf.
  • Whether or not the Supreme Court may review the factual findings of the Court of Appeals in a petition for review under Rule 45.

Applicable Provisions

Section 1 of Rule 35 of the Revised Rules of Court provides:

Section 1. Effect of judgment on demurrer to evidence. After plaintiff has completed the presentation of his evidence, the defendant without waiving his right to offer evidence in the event the motion is not granted, may move for a dismissal on the ground that upon the facts and the law the plaintiff has shown no right to relief. However, if the motion is granted and the order of dismissal is reversed on appeal, the movant loses his right to present evidence in his behalf.

This provision supplies the decisive rule: because Quebral's demurrer was granted and that dismissal was reversed on appeal, he lost his right to present evidence, leaving the corporation's evidence uncontradicted.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that Quebral's claim of a defective exhibit was an attempt to foist a falsehood. The original letter, handwritten on stationery bearing the printed line "From the desk of: E.V. Quebral," was in the folder of exhibits and was formally offered in evidence. Even if it had been a mere photocopy, Quebral made no timely objection. Objection to documentary evidence must be made at the time it is formally offered, not earlier, and an objection to identification and marking is not equivalent to an objection at the formal offer. Evidence not objected to became the property of the case, and all parties are amenable to its favorable or unfavorable effects.

On the second issue, the Court upheld the appellate court's appreciation of the evidence. Quebral's own letter introduced Gay-ya as his representative and promised to remit the collections for the drums delivered to Joseph Li and Susan Lo. The Court also noted that the trial court's factual findings were at variance with those of the Court of Appeals, which justified a review of the records.

On the third issue, the Court applied the rule squarely. A demurrer to evidence abbreviates proceedings, but whoever avails of it gambles his right to adduce evidence. Pursuant to Rule 35, if the motion is granted and the order of dismissal is reversed on appeal, judgment is rendered in favor of the adverse party because the movant loses his right to present evidence. Quebral's choice to file a demurrer instead of commenting on the exhibits proved to be a costly error.

On the fourth issue, the Court recognized that factual findings of the appellate court are normally not reviewable in a petition under Rule 45, but it examined the records because the findings of the Court of Appeals conflicted with those of the trial court.

Doctrine

A demurrer to evidence is a gamble. Under Section 1 of Rule 35, the movant who succeeds before the trial court but whose dismissal is reversed on appeal loses his right to present evidence, and judgment is entered for the adverse party on the evidence already of record. A party who fails to object to documentary evidence at the time of its formal offer cannot raise that objection for the first time on appeal; the evidence becomes part of the case. And while the Supreme Court does not ordinarily review the factual findings of the Court of Appeals under Rule 45, it will go over the records when those findings are at variance with those of the trial court.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the petition and affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeals, holding Quebral liable to Union Refinery Corporation.

Remember This

Memorize the line: whoever demurs to evidence gambles his right to adduce evidence, and if the dismissal is reversed on appeal, he loses that right entirely. Examiners use this case to test the effect of a reversed demurrer to evidence and the rule on timely objection to documentary exhibits.