THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. IGNACIO CRUZ, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Cruz
The Case
This is a criminal prosecution for rape brought by the Government of the United States in the Islands against Ignacio Cruz, a member of the Insular Police. The case matters for two reasons. First, it is an early decision applying article 438 of the old Penal Code to a crime committed by armed policemen acting in concert, and it shows how the Court reasons from circumstantial and corroborative evidence to guilt. Second, it illustrates how the aggravating circumstance of committing the offense in the dwelling of the injured party, with no mitigating circumstance, fixes the penalty at the minimum of the maximum degree. A reviewee should read it as a compact lesson on the elements of rape by violence and intimidation, on the appreciation of aggravating circumstances, and on the civil liability that follows a conviction.
Procedural History
The case began in the trial court, which rendered a judgment against the accused. The accused appealed that judgment to the Supreme Court. On appeal, the Court reviewed the evidence and the penalty imposed, and it reversed the judgment of the trial court and entered its own judgment of conviction with the penalty and civil liability set out in the decision.
Facts
At about seven o'clock in the evening of the thirtieth of March, 1902, the defendant and two other members of the Insular Police entered the house where Antonia Evangelista, a girl of seventeen years, lived with her grandmother, Carmen Tayag, in the town. They were looking for the girl's father, who was then in Manila. The three took Carmen downstairs and tied her to a chico tree. They then went upstairs, where Antonia had been left alone, stretched her upon the floor, stuffed a handkerchief into her mouth to prevent her from calling for help, and ravished her in succession.
The facts were corroborated by Carmen Tayag and by Nicolasa Cruz, a neighbor who, from the window of her house, saw the girl in the hands of two men inside the house and shortly after heard her voice crying for help. Paula Cruz, a relative of the victim who lived nearby, also heard the cries, came out of her house, and unsuccessfully tried to prevent the assailants from taking the girl away. Antonia was carried to the barrio of Sucat and there, according to the testimony of the accused himself, she was again ravished by three other policemen.
The accused pleaded not guilty. After hearing the complaining witness, who said she knew him because he was a resident of the same town and who gave a full account of the occurrence, the court asked her whether she was mistaken in what she had stated, and she replied that all she had testified to was true. The accused then testified that he did not rape the girl at all, but that two constables did, and that she was not raped at her house but at the barrio of Sucat. He presented no exculpatory evidence.
Issues
- Whether or not the evidence established beyond reasonable doubt that the accused committed the crime of rape defined and punished under article 438 of the Penal Code.
- Whether or not the aggravating circumstance of committing the offense in the dwelling of the injured party, with no mitigating circumstance, should be appreciated against the accused.
- Whether or not the accused is civilly liable to the injured party for indemnification, for the support of the issue that may be born, and for the costs of the appeal.
Applicable Provisions
Article 438 of the Penal Code, as applied by the Court, defines and punishes the crime charged:
The crime of rape is committed by having carnal knowledge of a woman by using violence or intimidation.
The Court invoked this provision because the accused, in order to outrage the girl, used violence and intimidation, aided by two others who, like himself, were armed with guns as members of the Insular Police.
Number 20 of article 10 of the Penal Code, as cited by the Court, supplies the aggravating circumstance:
The offense was committed in the dwelling of the injured party, and without provocation.
This circumstance bears on the penalty because, with no mitigating circumstance to offset it, the adequate penalty must be imposed in the minimum grade of the maximum degree.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the facts, as established by the testimony of credible witnesses and by the damaging statements of the defendant himself, constitute the crime of rape under article 438 of the Penal Code. The accused used violence and intimidation, and was aided by two armed companions. His own testimony placed the girl in the hands of the other policemen, and the witnesses who saw or heard the struggle and the victim's cries proved his guilt conclusively. He offered no exculpatory evidence.
On the second issue, the Court appreciated the aggravating circumstance of article 10, number 20, there being no mitigating circumstance, because the offense was committed in the dwelling of the injured party and without provocation. The Court therefore imposed the adequate penalty in the minimum grade of the maximum degree.
On the third issue, the Court held the accused civilly liable. He was ordered to pay the injured party an indemnification of 300 Mexican pesos, to recognize and support the issue that may be born if its origin should not be a bar thereto, and to pay the costs of the appeal.
Doctrine
Rape under article 438 of the Penal Code is committed by having carnal knowledge of a woman by using violence or intimidation. The presence of armed companions who aid the accused in overpowering the victim reinforces the violence and intimidation that characterize the crime.
Guilt may be established by the credible testimony of witnesses who saw or heard the occurrence, corroborated by the accused's own damaging statements. An accused who offers no exculpatory evidence cannot overcome such proof.
When the offense is committed in the dwelling of the injured party and without provocation, the aggravating circumstance of number 20 of article 10 of the Penal Code is appreciated. With no mitigating circumstance, the penalty is imposed in the minimum grade of the maximum degree.
Conviction for rape carries civil liability: indemnification of the injured party, recognition and support of the issue that may be born if its origin should not be a bar thereto, and payment of the costs.
Disposition
The Court reversed the judgment of the trial court and sentenced Ignacio Cruz to seventeen years four months and one day of imprisonment, with the accessory penalty of temporary absolute disqualification and surveillance during confinement and for a like period thereafter, to pay 300 Mexican pesos as indemnification, to recognize and support the issue that may be born, and to pay the costs of the appeal.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that rape is committed by having carnal knowledge of a woman by using violence or intimidation, and that commission in the dwelling of the injured party, without provocation, raises the penalty to the minimum of the maximum degree. Examiners use this case to test the elements of rape by violence and intimidation, the appreciation of the aggravating circumstance of dwelling, and the civil liability that follows conviction.