JOSE V. L. GONZAGA, PETITIONER, VS. W. F. NORRIS, JUDGE OF THE COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE OF NEGROS, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Gonzaga versus Norris
The Case
This is a special civil action of mandamus brought by Jose V. L. Gonzaga against W. F. Norris, the judge of the Court of First Instance of Negros. Gonzaga asks the Supreme Court to compel the judge to approve and certify a bill of exceptions in the form the plaintiff tendered, after the judge signed a different and, in the plaintiff's view, defective bill. The case matters because it fixes the standard for what a bill of exceptions must contain: it is not enough to recite the question and the court's reason for overruling the objection; the bill must state enough of the evidence to show the relevancy of each exception and its bearing on the case.
Procedural History
The case originated in the Court of First Instance of Negros, where the plaintiff, Gonzaga, was the losing party or otherwise aggrieved and sought to perfect a bill of exceptions for appeal. The plaintiff tendered a proposed bill of exceptions. The defendant submitted amendments. The court and both counsel discussed and considered both at a session held for the purpose of settling the bill. The judge then signed his own bill, which omitted much of the plaintiff's proposed material.
Gonzaga sought relief from the Supreme Court by a writ of mandamus issued under the provisions of article 499 of the Code of Civil Procedure, directed to Judge Norris. The judge made a return to the writ. The Supreme Court, in this decision, resolved whether the judge's bill was complete and what corrections were required.
Facts
Gonzaga, as plaintiff in the court below, proposed a bill of exceptions containing, among other things, the detailed testimony of many witnesses who had testified without objection, the plaintiff's opening statement of the facts, and eight pages of legal argument against the judgment. The defendant proposed amendments. The trial judge, after a session with counsel to settle the bill, signed a bill that included all of the exceptions contained in the plaintiff's proposed bill but stated most of them only by reciting the question asked and the court's reason for overruling the objection.
The plaintiff complained that the signed bill was incomplete. The Supreme Court examined the record and found that no exception had been taken that required, for its elucidation, any of the fifteen documents presented by the plaintiff, except document fourteen. The Court also found that the evidence of witnesses who testified without objection, the opening statement, and the legal argument were properly excluded from the bill.
The Court noted that the exceptions from number three to number eighteen, inclusive, in the bill as allowed were stated in a defective manner. The judge limited himself to stating the question and his reasons for overruling the objection. Supposing those reasons were insufficient, there remained only the question, with no answer and nothing to show the connection of the question with the other testimony or with the issues in the case.
Issues
- Whether or not the judge erred in excluding from the bill of exceptions the detailed testimony of witnesses who testified without objection, the plaintiff's opening statement, and the legal argument against the judgment.
- Whether or not the fact that the bill signed by the judge was prepared by the adverse party or by the court affects its validity.
- Whether or not the bill of exceptions signed by the judge was complete and sufficient in its statement of the exceptions.
- Whether or not mandamus lies to compel the judge to correct, sign, and certify the bill of exceptions.
Applicable Provisions
Article 143 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as cited by the Court, provides:
Article 143 requires the bill of exceptions to state enough of the evidence to show the relevancy of the exceptions and the bearing which the answer excepted to has on the case.
This provision is the measure of the judge's duty: the bill must do more than recite the question and the ruling; it must show why the exception matters.
Article 499 of the Code of Civil Procedure is the source of the remedy invoked, under which the writ of mandamus was issued to the respondent judge.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the judge did not err. No motion for a new trial having been made, the Supreme Court could not weigh the evidence nor retry the questions of fact. Consequently, the testimony of the witnesses had no place in the bill except so far as necessary to explain the exceptions taken and their relevancy. The evidence of witnesses who testified without objection or exception was properly excluded. The plaintiff's opening statement was properly excluded. The eight pages of legal argument against the judgment had no place in any bill of exceptions.
On the second issue, the Court held that it is of no consequence who prepared the bill. If it is a correct and full statement of the exceptions, the fact that it was prepared by the adverse party or by the court is not important. The Court noted that the plaintiff's bill and the defendant's amendments were discussed and considered by the court and both counsel at a session held for the purpose of settling the bill.
On the third issue, the Court held that the judge committed no error as to the points mentioned, but in other respects the bill signed by him was incomplete. The Court applied article 143 and found that in most of the exceptions, from number three to number eighteen, inclusive, the bill failed to state enough of the evidence to show the relevancy of the exceptions and the bearing of the answer excepted to on the case. The Court gave exception number fourteen as an example of how the exceptions were stated:
No. 14. The defendant on cross-examination asked a witness for the plaintiff the following question: Do you know if your brother sowed sugar cane in the Rosario estate the year nineteen hundred? The plaintiff objected; the court overruled the objection on the ground that the question was pertinent; the plaintiff took exception.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that the bill should be amplified by adding to the several exceptions the evidence contained in the indicated pages of the first bill of exceptions presented by the plaintiff. If such evidence is not truly stated in that bill, the court will make the necessary corrections so as to make it conform to the truth. The Court specified the additions to exceptions number three, seven, eight, nine, ten, twelve, thirteen, fourteen, fifteen, sixteen, seventeen, and eighteen. The Court found that the exceptions relating to the jurisdiction of the court, the challenge of the judge, and those numbered nineteen, twenty, and twenty-one were sufficiently stated. It also noted that exceptions number four, five, six, and eleven did not appear in the plaintiff's bill.
Doctrine
A bill of exceptions must state enough of the evidence to show the relevancy of the exceptions and the bearing which the answer excepted to has on the case, as article 143 of the Code of Civil Procedure requires. It is not enough to recite the question and the court's reason for overruling the objection; the bill must show the connection of the question with the other testimony and the issues. Evidence of witnesses who testified without objection, the opening statement, and legal argument have no place in a bill of exceptions. The identity of the preparer of the bill is immaterial; what matters is whether it is a correct and full statement of the exceptions. Mandamus lies to compel a judge to correct, sign, and certify a bill of exceptions that fails to comply with the statutory requirement.
Disposition
The respondent judge was directed to correct the bill of exceptions as indicated in the decision and to sign and certify the same.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a bill of exceptions must state enough of the evidence to show the relevancy of the exceptions and the bearing of the answer excepted to on the case. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of a bill of exceptions and the availability of mandamus to compel a judge to complete and certify it.